Hello, fellow BHPians.
Since the last 6 years, the Toyota Innova (2009 make) has been a very reliable family car. It has clocked almost 1,15,000 kms and surely can go a long way. But now the engine feels a bit sluggish and being a car enthusiast himself, my father thinks that we need an upgrade to go on those long highway trips and I just couldn't agree more!
Now the biggest problem is finding a car which is as comfortable and spacious as the innova and at the same time fun and engaging to drive. As the grand i10 is used for the daily commute, this car is going to be used more on the highways and hence family comfort matters more than driving pleasure
Though we're just a family of 4, my parents have gotten used to the height, extra bootspace and legroom in the Innova so much, that they refuse to look at the sedans.
So the obvious choice was the new Innova Crysta, which according to me is not at all worth shelling out 26Lacs. Yet, we went for a test drive.
The crysta looks handsome when viewed from the front but somehow, the rear does not do justice at all. The interiors look decent, but it's still underequipped for a car with that price tag. After getting in on the driver seat, the first thing I noticed was the changed position of the steering. The seat is placed much higher than the previous innova and it felt a bit uncomfortable. Apart from that, the car did not excite me much and fortunately, my dad too, wasn't happy with it.
That brought us down to the following alternatives:
1. Toyota Fortuner
2. Mercedes GLA
3. Audi Q3
4. BMW X1
Toyota Fortuner
The car was on display when we took a test drive for the Innova. The fortuner is huge car and the first impressions were good. But the interiors of the fortuner feel too old school when compared to the other cars of the segment. The Ford Endavour gets loads of features for a lesser price which is very surprising. The exteriors are stylish and give it a very upmarket feel. It feels good when driving a fortuner as it gives you a feeling of being above everyone else, quite literally
The legroom and space are adequate and it seemed like a perfect upgrade.
Mercedes GLA
The minute my dad sat inside the GLA, he refused to even look at the specifications of the car. It is so cramped and the spare tyre in the boot eats up so much space that we didn't even request a testdrive.
Audi Q3
The Q3 felt nice and premium and hence we took a test drive. The Q3 is a sweet car with decent features and was comfortable too. The only problem was the rear seating which was not as spacious and the boot is not too large. There were good deals for the Q3 but the car just did not live up to the expectations.
BMW X1
Finally, a car which had enough space, good legroom, adequate features. The 2016 X1 is way better than it's predecessor. From a distance, you can easily mistake it for an X3. Full marks to the exterior styling. I simply fell in love with the car after driving it. My parents were happy with it too.
So, we finally shortlisted the X1 and the Fortuner. I was happy with the options which were shortlisted but I thought of making my parents try the Skoda Superb. Hence, I arranged for a testdrive. Taking the superb test drive was a total game changer. My parents who were refusing to even consider sedans were suddenly convinced that this was a worthy upgrade to the Innova. My mother preferred the Superb over the X1, which is justified, since she's never going to be behind the wheel. The superb is a fantastic car and has the best features among all the cars discussed in this thread. Also, the comfort in the Superb is unmatched without compromising on the driving pleasure.
Now there are 3 options and the more I think of it, the more confusing it gets for me which is why I thought of seeking help from fellow BHPians. Though we're more inclined towards the X1 or the Superb.
Also, existing Skoda and BMW owners, what is your take on the after sales service and maintainance of these cars?
The car we buy is going to be used for a good 5-6 years which is why Toyota seems safer though.
It would be great to get some advice on which car to go for out of the three.
Thanks in advance!