Re: Want to buy an enthusiast's car for ~10 lakh rupees I am in the market for a new car too and have been following this thread. I too had a WagonR CNG and was honestly bored with the way it used to drive. Without any doubt, it scored a 100/100 on practicality for a vehicle being used solely for travel between point A to point B. But I never felt safe in it, was a tin can. So now after selling the car, I have a budget of around 10-12 lakhs and and am looking for a fun to drive, safe car. The vehicles I have in mind are as follows (not in any order of preference):
- Skoda Rapid 1.0 TSI: While this car begs to be driven hard and is a peach of a car, main concerns are long term reliability and maintenance. If I plan to keep the car for atleast 75000 kms over 5 years, would I be facing any major issues? Also, I have heard that turbo petrols aren't too frugal. Though the company claims an average of ~18kmpl, how much can I expect in real world scenario in Mumbai city traffic? My usage would be 70:30 city: highway. Also, this product is towards the end of it's lifecycle as the new Rapid/Vento is expected next year on a brand new platform. How much would that make a difference? Would anyone be able to give any insights if VW group plans to introduce any new engines in their vehicles in the coming months? Honda and Hyundai consider their turbo-petrols as a premium offering. But VW has made it their bread and butter. What should we deduce from this? Surely this is the future of petrol engines. But does it also mean I might be buying a vehicle which is not an accomplished product? Also, why does Hyundai sell its Verna turbo petrol at such a premium?
Ford EcoSport: Tried and tested 1.5 TDCi in its BS6 avatar. I am assured of a fuss-free 5 year journey with this and also is fun to drive. Though the steering and driving dynamics are top-notch, the engine is not like that of a XUV 300. Honestly, I don't see any major issues with this vehicle, this was my first choice until I drove the Rapid TSI. High ground clearance also makes it easy to drive on bad roads. But in today's times, is this really an enthusiast's car? What other issues can I possibly face with its ownership?
Honda City (5th generation): Everything about this car seems to be made like it's non-negotiable for Honda. It also comes at a non-negotiable OTR of ~13 lakhs. Though my budget can stretch to ~13 lakhs, is it worth shelling out that much for a petrol sedan whos 1.5 NA engine is almost 10 years old? Is paying around ₹4 lakhs more than for a Rapid justifiable just for a fuss-free ownership and it's reliability? Would I end up spending 4 lakhs on the Rapid over 5 years to fix it's niggles (apart from the regular servicing costs)? A high OTR price also means that I would be shelling out more for the insurance every year. Does the City really deserve the extra bucks?
XUV 300: Everything about this vehicle ticks the box except it's steering and driving dynamics. It feels like a Hyundai. I don't like how Hyundai's drive especially on highways. There is practically no steering feedback. Doesn't feel like I'm one with the vehicle and totally involved. Is there anything that can be done to fix that? An ECU remap or something?
I am not looking for a Maruti or Hyundai car only because I don't feel safe in them. Tata Nexon is another great product but I would rather get the EcoSport and have fun on the wheels than save ₹50,000 - 75000. Had Tata been offering the Altroz Diesel in the same state of tune as that of the Nexon, I'd have surely considered that too.
Wildcard entry - Tata Harrier (base varient): This is something which my mom would want me to buy. It's comfortable, it's safe, it's a diesel, I haven't driven it, but from what I've read and seen, the 2020 update seems to have ironed out the issues pertaining to its vague steering feedback and NVH levels. To be honest, I'm pretty blank about this product. I have only read great reviews of the 2.0 litre Fiat engine in it. The only gripe I'd have is shelling out ₹16.5 lakhs for this product (I'm not trying to say it's not worth it, just that it may be little stretched considering my budget). If anyone can convince me that the product would be worth every single buck spent on it and that I'd have a fuss-free ownership for at least 7-8 years (100000 kilometres), then surely I'm going to consider this too.
Thanks in advance
Last edited by ampere : 26th July 2020 at 15:15.
Reason: removed non-forum emojis.
|