Updating this thread with details on my latest test drives and the factors I'm considering. I hope this thread would serve as a good resource for someone in the CSUV dilemma.
Current Shortlist
BHPians' gave their overwhelming feedback on taking additional test drives of Nexon and reconsidering the XUV3OO. I did exactly that. And I'm so thankful I did that.
- Tata Nexon XZ+ (S) 1.5D
- Mahindra XUV3OO W8 (O) 1.5D
Car that came close: Kia Sonet GTX+ 1.5 D (yes, a role reversal
)
The Assessment
I shall use the same framework that I used for my first post on this thread. This seemed to work really well to boil down facts while keeping it simple.
Performance: Between the Nexon and XUV3OO, it's really hard to announce a strong winner in this department. While on paper the XUV3OO has better numbers to boast, the power-weight ratio balances things out. In the real world test, I really couldn't spot much difference at least based on my driving style (not sedate, but not pedal to metal). The XUV3OO clearly has an edge in terms of overall refinement. Power delivery felt butter smooth and engine doesn't get loud till ~3000 rpms. As for the Nexon, the engine does sing when pushed a little hard. There is a sound grunt as you rev past 2500 rpm but it wasn't gravelly. I kind of liked that sound - felt like it was coming to life. Like a growl. The XUV3OO had a heavier clutch and would be cumbersome in traffic. Also, because of that massive torque surging past 1500rpm, you'll have to be gentle with the clutch to keep it restrained and not lurch forward every single time. Another slight advantage that Nexon has in this department is on the drive modes - sure the knob is an eyesore, but it is actually functional. City mode keeps things nice and calm with enough power to get you going and overtake snail-paced autorickshaws.
Verdict: XUV3OO = Nexon
Ride Comfort: The Nexon clearly felt to be a more comfortable vehicle to be in. It has a perfect suspension setup to plough through broken roads and provide good highway stability at the same time. The slow speed jiggly ride that I experienced last time wasn't there and this time, it just felt very comfortable to drive. The XUV3OO isn't far behind in this department though. It probably has a stiffer edge to things owing to the 17" wheels, but overall there were no jarring experiences (unlike the Sonet).
Verdict: Nexon > XUV3OO
Handling and dynamics: This was again a very close match between the Nexon and XUV3OO. Both are pocket rockets allowing you to point and shoot into gaps (not advising, just highlighting the capability). They decimate rumble strips and expansion joints with ease. The XUV3OO has a trick up its sleeves with the adjustable steering weight - and this really works. The Nexon gets away with this here because of a perfectly set weight for my liking. The last test drive was a disappointment as the steering felt VERY heavy, which I now think is attributable to the low pressure warning on one of the tyres. This time, the Nexon just felt natural to steer.
Verdict: Nexon = XUV3OO
Interiors, Practicality and Ergonomics: Similar to the "Nexon v. Sonet" saga, the Nexon falls back again here. But things aren't that easy on this department this time around. The XUV3OO feels a lot more livelier and premium thanks to the beige leatherette interiors. The HVAC controls have received a lot of hate online, although personally for me these things don't matter much. What does matter to me are cabin storage spaces and practicality. The XUV3OO clearly wins here. I especially loved the armrest storage with the slot up front; you can safely put your phone inside while it's wired up to use Android Auto/Apple Carplay. Similarly, quite a few easy access stowaway spaces on the front dash makes it a very practical cabin up front. However, things changed a little on the back seat. The XUV3OO seat lies closer to the floor which means you mostly sit in a knees up position (for reference, I'm 5'8"). This can get uncomfortable over long distances, even though you have space to stretch out your legs a bit. Furthermore, the XUV3OO loses out on a rear AC blowers which means in hot/humid places the rear passengers are going to feel a little sultry. The Nexon gets really comfortable rear seats. The seating is long and at the perfect height, giving great under-thigh support. Nexon wins the back seat in my opinion even while lacking a "can't-figure-out-why" idiotic cost cutting of removing rear reading lamps. Why Tata? WHY? I'm not going to the boot, we know who loses that game.
Verdict:
????? Honestly, its a tough call and will boil down to how my wife and I debate this out.
Safety: This section made sense in the "Nexon v. Sonet" match. However, between Nexon and XUV3OO, it's an even game - mostly. The XUV3OO does get 6 airbags, switchable passenger airbag, disc brakes on all four wheels. Heck, I'm going to even count auto-dimming IRVM, physical buttons for ICE shortcuts and a neat place to put the phone as indirect safety features - anything that keeps the driver from getting distracted should be counted(?). Needless to say, both of them are tightly put together and feel strong.
Verdict: XUV3OO > Nexon
The Confusion
Being the marketing guy I am, I tried writing one-line positioning statement for both XUV3OO and Nexon based on my test drives and what they offer.
XUV3OO Quote:
For the young adventurous couple who don't want to have any compromises while they explore the world, XUV3OO is the perfect road companion.
|
Nexon Quote:
For the family who wants a safe way of getting around from one destination to another while being pocket friendly, the Nexon is the car to be in.
|
The XUV3OO is a perfect car for a couple (+1 child). You get dual zone climate control, very practical cabin and heck, even vanity mirrors WITH LIGHTS for both driver and front passenger. However, it's designed as an upgrade car of sorts due to the limited boot space, not so comfy rear seats etc. As the family grows with someone needing to use the rear seat more regularly, the XUV3OO will start showing its troubles. Whereas, the Nexon is an all-rounder which can be kept even for 10 years without ever feeling a "practical" need to upgrade by just giving it a few mid-life updates to spruce things up. However, it comes at the cost of being in a car where a few compromises have to be made for the first 3-4 years or so.
This is a debate my wife and I are prepared to have in the next few days. Hopefully, by this weekend I'll have a verdict in place.