Swift Dzire or Hyundai i20 ???

danychris · 22nd March 2012, 02:29

Hi,

Even I was in a dilema whether to go in for Swift or i20. But the moment when I took i20 diesel for a test drive, I was impressed with it soft clutch and soft steering (though many of them say its a dead steering I personally like it for city drive), I was amazed by its pulling power when it reaches 1900-2100 RPM. In 3rd gear at around 2100 rpm it pulls like a jet. In top gear it reaches 80 to 130 with ease and I was stunned when the gorgeous took me at 160 KMPH. It was full of thrill in the test drive. Where I booked my i20 at spot imdtly without any thought after the test drive.

My car was delivered on the 10th day of booking and i have driven 5500 kms in 45 days.

On the negative note:
Above 120 - 130 kmph, car is less stable on applying brakes (especially you have to very careful on braking on curves/turns on these speeds literally lost balance once, it was a lucky escape for me)

Soft suspensions crank with loud noise on sharp bumps.

On the Positive Note: Apart from the points mentioned above, i20 is a fabulous car to drive in all conditions.

Though the model is hatch, it is of sedan class and that is what it will be printed in RC.

My suggestion is to go for i20 which will be released with facelift in April 2012.

baxikunal · 25th March 2012, 09:45

I agree with danychris.... i20 feels nothing less than a hatch..jet... I have done 5,500 Kms on my i20 CRDi Sportz.... in terms of speed and performance, i guess, none can beat it (hatchback segment). Same applies for the interiors. Complete European design with plush and comfort.... Only one drawback.... Jealous neighbors and other hatchback owners....

Quote:

Originally Posted by danychris

Hi,

Even I was in a dilema whether to go in for Swift or i20. But the moment when I took i20 diesel for a test drive, I was impressed with it soft clutch and soft steering (though many of them say its a dead steering I personally like it for city drive), I was amazed by its pulling power when it reaches 1900-2100 RPM. In 3rd gear at around 2100 rpm it pulls like a jet. In top gear it reaches 80 to 130 with ease and I was stunned when the gorgeous took me at 160 KMPH. It was full of thrill in the test drive. Where I booked my i20 at spot imdtly without any thought after the test drive.

My car was delivered on the 10th day of booking and i have driven 5500 kms in 45 days.

On the negative note:
Above 120 - 130 kmph, car is less stable on applying brakes (especially you have to very careful on braking on curves/turns on these speeds literally lost balance once, it was a lucky escape for me)

Soft suspensions crank with loud noise on sharp bumps.

On the Positive Note: Apart from the points mentioned above, i20 is a fabulous car to drive in all conditions.

Though the model is hatch, it is of sedan class and that is what it will be printed in RC.

My suggestion is to go for i20 which will be released with facelift in April 2012.

akshay380 · 30th November 2013, 18:20

Guys,

A friend has shortlisted i20 Sport Petrol over Swift ZXi. Good decision? He is happy with i20 package, I was just concerned about petrol motor of i20.

IshaanIan · 13th December 2013, 01:46

Quote:

Originally Posted by akshay380

Guys,

A friend has shortlisted i20 Sport Petrol over Swift ZXi. Good decision? He is happy with i20 package, I was just concerned about petrol motor of i20.

The only reason that one might buy an i20 over the Swift ZXi, is if he/she is attracted to the host of features and extra space

There is no problem with the petrol mill in the i20 offers decent driveability in the city too.

Do note that the facelifted Swift will be launched in March and the ZXi variant is said to have an updated map (let's see how it changes the performance/driveability/efficiency), DRLs, cruise control, keyless entry, start/stop ignition, bluetooth and, though I'd take this one with a pinch of salt; 16inch wheels!

Now with all those added features, cheaper bills at the service center and brilliant dynamics, perhaps it would be worth a rematch to your friend?

mints21 · 13th December 2013, 06:57

I had driven Swift Dezire for three years and then bought an i20 Asta(o). Between the two of them, I feel i20 is anyway a better choice. Not only in terms of features but also in terms of quality. The build is also solid and fit and finish is excellent. While, in Swift routine rattles come like a package. I20 is a soundproof car.

akshay380 · 13th December 2013, 07:30

Quote:

Originally Posted by IshaanIan

The only reason that one might buy an i20 over the Swift ZXi, is if he/she is attracted to the host of features and extra space

There is no problem with the petrol mill in the i20 offers decent driveability in the city too.

Do note that the facelifted Swift will be launched in March and the ZXi variant is said to have an updated map (let's see how it changes the performance/driveability/efficiency), DRLs, cruise control, keyless entry, start/stop ignition, bluetooth and, though I'd take this one with a pinch of salt; 16inch wheels!

Now with all those added features, cheaper bills at the service center and brilliant dynamics, perhaps it would be worth a rematch to your friend?

Thanks. However he booked i20. Was supposed to take delivery in Jan 14, but being his first car, he became restless and is taking delivery next week itself.

shankar.balan · 3rd January 2014, 18:43

I endorse this view. We needed to change my parents Indica DLG Turbo V2 this year after 8 years and around 52k kms.
The main reason was that we wanted a modern petrol driven vehicle with first class safety features and general driveability etc.

The choices were narrowed down to Swift Dzire Zxi and I 20 Asta 1.2 Petrol.
The I 20 has won, simply on account of its quality, class, space, versatility, comfort and class-leading convenience feature list.

The Swift Dzire is a great car yes. But that stuck on boot and non-foldable rear seats just do not quite cut it from our requirement perspective.

We will take delivery of a brand new I 20 in the third week of Jan 2014.

22nd March 2012, 02:29	#76
danychris Newbie Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: Chennai Posts: 18 Thanked: 7 Times	Re: Swift Dzire or Hyundai i20 ??? Hi, Even I was in a dilema whether to go in for Swift or i20. But the moment when I took i20 diesel for a test drive, I was impressed with it soft clutch and soft steering (though many of them say its a dead steering I personally like it for city drive), I was amazed by its pulling power when it reaches 1900-2100 RPM. In 3rd gear at around 2100 rpm it pulls like a jet. In top gear it reaches 80 to 130 with ease and I was stunned when the gorgeous took me at 160 KMPH. It was full of thrill in the test drive. Where I booked my i20 at spot imdtly without any thought after the test drive. My car was delivered on the 10th day of booking and i have driven 5500 kms in 45 days. On the negative note: Above 120 - 130 kmph, car is less stable on applying brakes (especially you have to very careful on braking on curves/turns on these speeds literally lost balance once, it was a lucky escape for me) Soft suspensions crank with loud noise on sharp bumps. On the Positive Note: Apart from the points mentioned above, i20 is a fabulous car to drive in all conditions. Though the model is hatch, it is of sedan class and that is what it will be printed in RC. My suggestion is to go for i20 which will be released with facelift in April 2012.
	(1) Thanks

30th November 2013, 18:20	#78
akshay380 BHPian Join Date: Sep 2011 Location: Goa Posts: 968 Thanked: 1,293 Times	Re: Swift Dzire or Hyundai i20 ??? Guys, A friend has shortlisted i20 Sport Petrol over Swift ZXi. Good decision? He is happy with i20 package, I was just concerned about petrol motor of i20.
	() Thanks

13th December 2013, 06:57	#80
mints21 BHPian Join Date: Nov 2013 Location: India Posts: 840 Thanked: 1,409 Times	Re: Swift Dzire or Hyundai i20 ??? I had driven Swift Dezire for three years and then bought an i20 Asta(o). Between the two of them, I feel i20 is anyway a better choice. Not only in terms of features but also in terms of quality. The build is also solid and fit and finish is excellent. While, in Swift routine rattles come like a package. I20 is a soundproof car.
	() Thanks

3rd January 2014, 18:43	#82
shankar.balan BANNED Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Bangalore Posts: 11,368 Thanked: 23,149 Times View My Garage Infractions: 0/2 (8)	I endorse this view. We needed to change my parents Indica DLG Turbo V2 this year after 8 years and around 52k kms. The main reason was that we wanted a modern petrol driven vehicle with first class safety features and general driveability etc. The choices were narrowed down to Swift Dzire Zxi and I 20 Asta 1.2 Petrol. The I 20 has won, simply on account of its quality, class, space, versatility, comfort and class-leading convenience feature list. The Swift Dzire is a great car yes. But that stuck on boot and non-foldable rear seats just do not quite cut it from our requirement perspective. We will take delivery of a brand new I 20 in the third week of Jan 2014.
	() Thanks