Team-BHP
(
https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/)
-
What Car?
(
https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/what-car/)
Which car under 12 lakh is most comfortable for taking up long journeys with family (journeys of more than 8 hours)? We are a family of 4 (my parents, wife, self, our heights are between 5.5 and 6ft) and my kid.
Last time we did a journey of 9 hours in my Getz, my wife was not happy and said she prefers to travel in train. While I dont disagree (do I have a choice?) I like to drive and when I upgrade to another car I will try to go for one that keeps us most comfortable. I would like to hear suggestions.
Mods: I searched but could not find any similar thread. If there is one, please delete this and point me to the relevant thread/posts. thanks!
Hi, as per your requiement i would say Innova will be the best suited for you. Third row seats arent anything to talk much about but then that is the case with most vehicles. Also I guess you can consider Scorpio Vlx. But guess as long as your drive is mostly on higways may be Innova is the better choice.
Eventhough I love Safari, I'd say Innova fits the bill best. Get the version with 2+2+3 seating configuration. The middle row having captain's chairs makes the car feel more roomy and allows people in the third row to feel connected with the rest.
Having said that, I wish Innova's ride is better and seats a shade more supportive for the under-thighs. Safari is better in that aspect. But Safari does not have a usable third row.
Budget - Fits in
Looks - Royal
Power - Ample
Space - Ample
Usable Space - Good enough (for 4 Adults+ 1 Kid)
Handling - What's that??
Ride Comfort - The *Best*; Unmatched by any other MUV/SUV in its class:cool:
Yes, the i am taking about this whale of an SUV - Safari
Innova! End of story! :D
Nothing like the Innova. Amazing road presence, control grip and comfort. But yes one also needs a second car, which one can more often in the city. Although if you drive distances in Bangalore, Innova can serve you well there as well !
Test drive Innova, Scorpio and Safari and pick what you like. They all suit your need of seating 5 in comfort over long distances. If you prefer refinement and reliability over other attributes, buy Innova. There is lot of information/ownership reviews about these vehicles on this forum. Check it out.
Thanks a lot guys. Innova seems to be the most preferred, as some other friends also favored it. Among the three (Innova/Scorpio/Safari) my personal preference is Innova. Isnt there any Sedan that comes close to this?
Quote:
Originally Posted by mohan41
(Post 1530647)
Thanks a lot guys. Innova seems to be the most preferred, as some other friends also favored it. Among the three (Innova/Scorpio/Safari) my personal preference is Innova. Isnt there any Sedan that comes close to this? |
Ahem!
Buddy, The present Innova has undergone more facelifts off late.
It is showing its age presently, dont be surprised if Innova is replaced with a different model.
http://www.team-bhp.com/forum/indian...muv-india.html
Suppose to cost beyond 14 lacs ON-ROAD, and replaces the Innova all the way :)
And long distance drive does not mean Innova will help, its equally bad over bad roads.
Comfy Cruiser for 5 over longest of distances you can think of, Best in Driving comfort, great silent and powerful engine, economical SUV and with off-roading capabilities, None can beat the Safari.
Arrive at a decision after doing TD's and later decide.
Quote:
Originally Posted by mohan41
(Post 1530647)
Thanks a lot guys. Innova seems to be the most preferred, as some other friends also favored it. Among the three (Innova/Scorpio/Safari) my personal preference is Innova. Isnt there any Sedan that comes close to this? |
Dear Mohan,
Looks are subjective. If you find Xylo OK, you could have a look at it too! You would save some lakhs for yourself. Maybe, you could give it a thought.
Cheers,
Deepak
the xylo with the constant bobbing can prove disorienting on long runs
Quote:
Originally Posted by mohan41
(Post 1530647)
Thanks a lot guys. Innova seems to be the most preferred, as some other friends also favored it. Among the three (Innova/Scorpio/Safari) my personal preference is Innova. Isnt there any Sedan that comes close to this? |
None have the space/comfort that you are looking for. Innova really is a perfect car for the families and will last forever.
Mitsubishi Lancer. Excellent car to drive. Good rear seat. get a diesel, and enjoy the journeys. Even the Cedia I hear is good to drive, though the back seat is not as great as the lancer.
Hyundai Verna and preowned Elantra ??
Even the Logan has a very good ride, and sufficient seating. the FE is a big Plus.
cheers!
INNOVA all the way.
Scorpio = seasickness worse than a tummy upset.
Safari = ok but still tall will not be as comfortable as INNOVA
Tavera = Same as above bad road presence/looks
Xylo = Slightly better than Scorpio still tall so rolls like a fat lady
Driven all cars on extended roadtrips and INNOVA beats them all on comfort. I like the safari looks but willing to lump it all for comfort therefor continue to retain my INNOVA. Regarding comments about new model from Toyota I am sure I will be a great great great grand father before that happens = not for another minimum 2 years if you are an optimist (going by Fortuner record crazy).
Oh by the way I hated the INNOVA look when I bought her in 05 but to date don't regret the call
All times are GMT +5.5. The time now is 01:33. | |