Go Back   Team-BHP > BHP India > Commercial Vehicles in India


Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 19th June 2009, 20:02   #1
Senior - BHPian
 
sidindica's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: India
Posts: 4,538
Thanked: 2,073 Times
Default

Tested: Bajaj Auto CNG RE 4 stroke.

Date: June 20, 2009, 7:30 AM.

Pics: Not taken as it is a common sight.

Colour: green with yellow top.

What works:
  • monocoque frame
  • longer wheelbase than an omni.
  • unlimited "dhinchuk" customisation possible
  • more/ comparable ground clearance than some CUVs.
  • taller than a Wagon R/ Nano.
  • push button start not present even in S class.
  • cheap thrills of a rear engined, rear wheel drive "auto" mobile.
  • world's cheapest convertible with removable canvas top for that "wind in the hair" experience.
  • car-like features like a wiper/washer, rear bumper, rear seating for 3.
  • safe and reliable CNG mechanism, at least on paper.
  • A vehicle which serves as a wage earner to breadwinners to many families in Delhi/NCR (approx more than 2 lakh and counting).
  • easy to dart between traffic.
  • shortest turning radius.
  • low emissions and environment friendly if properly maintained.
  • standard LHS and RHS rear view mirror inside to prevent hitting from cars in bumper to bumper traffic, features absent in 4-wheeled cars.
what needs work:
  • engine shuts down mysteriously in floods and monsoon seasons.
  • poor pickup as compared to RE petrol 2 stroke.
  • cannot drift or drag or perform burnouts as in RE petrol 2 stroke.
  • expensive maintenance costs and overpriced spare parts.
  • engine wheezes on highway at speeds above 30.
  • fragile front shockers which can break apart from wheels leading to accidents.
  • pathetic stability and susceptible to crosswinds.
  • some bajaj bikes have more power from less capacity 150 cc engines as compared to its 175 cc engine.
  • Openly not available freely. Actual cost is Rs. 1,44,000 on-road but in Delhi black marketing with respect to issue of permits means, it is available for nothing less than Rs. 4,20,000.
  • tiny wheels with nylon tyres.
  • topples over easily if turned at a high speed, a major safety concern.
  • absence of doors at all sides, means hot in hot whether, cold in cold weather and wet in rainy season for passengers.
  • canvas top is not water proof.
  • body structure can bend horribly if hit by a speeding car/ truck.
  • poor after sales service by Bajaj auto.
Verdict:
  • A good concept let down by poor execution due to unreliable engine and expensive maintenance costs of CNG engines. I will take the traditional RE 2 stroke petrol, please.
  • Or else, the RE GDI direct injection petrol is a better bet but is not available in Delhi.
overall rating: **1/2.

Bajaj auto has been synonymous with producing 2 and 3 wheelers since the past 50 years and crores of them are found plying in the Indian roads since independence.

The concept of a 3 wheeled auto rickshaw is simple: Smallest footprint, 2 rear and 1 front wheel, controls like that of a scooter, commercial registration for many people to earn their livelihood, easy to drive, park, cheap to purchase, run, own and maintain and hence, acts as a boon for many of the commuters who cannot afford to take private vehicles and are fed up of daily dhakka-mukki of local train/ bus run by state transport corporations.

Bajaj earlier had competiton from the venerable API 175 diesel manufactured by kerala automobiles limited, tempo minidor 3 wheeler, and now from piaggio ape diesel throughout India.

It initially manufactured front engined 2 stroke 100 cc autos with engines placed directly under the driver's seat driving the rear wheels with the help of a 3-speed manual gearbox.

Feedback from drivers, passengers and stricter emission norms coupled with demands for a faster, smoother and reliable autos made bajaj to act accordingly and make a complete redesign of its 3-wheeled lineup. First came the RE (rear engined 2 stroke, sill in production in non metros) and now bajaj offers a whole lot of varients in petrol, CNG and LPG and it even offers an auto with a direct injection petrol engine (GDI).

Delhi/NCR had made drastic changes to its public transport system to make it more eco-friendly and to comply to the then euro-2 norms in april 2000.

Shiela aunty decided to convert its entire fleet of PBTS to CNG (from diesel buses and petrol RE 2 stroke autos.

Operators cried foul, autowallas more so, claiming that how is it possible to convert its entire PBTS to CNG overnight? CNG filling stations have to be built, new engines and vehicles have to be purchased, old ones have to be phased out or transferred, zero infrastructure to support these vehicles etc.

Moreover, autos plying in Delhi are now 4 stroke means that time to burn fuel is going to take longer, and added weight of the 4 kg cylinder, lower power due to CNG and expensive maintenence costs meant that drivers have to bear the brunt of government's measures resulting the already expensive auto fares more expensive, as demanded by the drivers. ore on that later.

The biggest drawback: Bajaj's absolute zero expertise in CNG vehicles meant that the first lot of CNG autos were unreliable, prone to frequent breakdowns, high on maintenance with poor dealer attitude, long wait for spares etc, coupled with long queues for CNG on stations.

As the years progressed, CNG was widely available, (though still long queues are a common sight for more than 85,000 autos currently plying in Delhi), reliability improved and today's autos (DL 1R L onwards) are much improved as compared to their predecessors.

The auto driven by me today had the number starting from DL 1R L and was registered on February 2009, brand new ad it has covered 15,675 kms since.

Looks and styling: ****


Yes, 4/5.
I won't comment on how it looks but on the way it is designed. It looks cute, understated from the front with that curvy 3 pointed windscreen topped with a visor and that headlight popping up from the front mudguard looks pretty cool.
The side, with its frameless design due to absence of doors make the cabin airy and appear spacious, even though rear legroom is in short supply. The no-frills contours give it is own identity and should I say, when beefed up with all types of dhinchak stuff, it does have street presence that would make a premium car owner feel jealous!
The rear is flat without any contours but gets some design language due to its 3-way placed canvas top which looks superbly integrated with the body. Small taillights also add to the looks.

Now comes its best part: It also acts as a proper cabriolet on 3 wheels, in fact, it is the cheapest convertible in the world. Just remove the top, an enjoy the thrills of open air motoring.

If you notice the top is held together with a bar above the drivers seat placed in the middle top of the "roof".
It also acts as a rollover bar for safety.

Stock Interior design: **.

Actually I have been a bit harsh in rating this because there really is no proper interior. Only 2 seats (1 front and 1 rear) and a small dashboard with the handle propping out are "carlike" features. At least the rear is a proper bench which is pretty comfy.

Customised interior design: ****.


Now, how to rate the interior from 2 stars to 4 stars? Go for customisation with bollywood posters, ferrari printed seats, funky seat cover colours, build anew dashboard to accomodate the music system with 2 big speakers at the rear to make passengers deaf with" stereophonic" sound speakers, add fans, lights etc and now you have a car-like feeling inside. In fact, his is the only vehicle where customisation possibilities are endless.

Interior Functionality: **

Actually, where do you place your baggage? at your back with constant threat of your head hitting it since the rear place behing the seat is only a "parcel tray". But in our country, "innovative possibilities" are endless. The driver will happily carry 4 suitcases and 5 persons happily (2 suitcases under his leg, 2 at the back, 1 person sitting at the front, 3 at the rear, 1 at the handle near the right "door" etc. Or even 8 persons.
(NOT INCLUDES THE VIKRAMS WHICH RUN IN GHAZIABAD AS THEY ARE BIGGER AND ARE FACTORY BUILT 6 Seaters).

Interior Space:

  • Front legroom: *1/2
  • rear legroom: **1/2
  • Front headroom: ****.
  • rear headroom: ****.
The driver sits in a 90 degree knees up position as there is no front and rear head or neck restraints only back support with padding over the plywood. Legroom is woefully short with legs in upright position making it too uncomfortable for the driver to drive it for long hours. In fact drivers sometimes drive by sitting in half cross legged position or putting up one of their legs on top of the dashboard.

If only one passenger sits, then it is okay since he can stretch his legs on the seat itself by sitting in different direction facing sideways. Otherwise, 2 or even 3 up, legroom if woefully short with passengers having to sit in knees up position, often meaning that passengers resorting to tactics like putting up legs on the partition bar behind the driver's seat where it is written "kripiya pair upar rakh kar na bathen".

However, headroom is terrific due to its taller height and even taller persons can sit with their heads not banging the roof.

There is a pull down privacy curtain on the rear right side for protection from heat, rains and cold etc but it only works with the minutest of positive outcome. The passenger on the right benefits, whereas his poor girlfriend/ her poor boyfriend sitting on the left suffer from weather conditions. A left curtain is highly recommended but the law prevents from it being implied it to, "to prevent crimes", similar reasons as cited for tinted glasses on cars.

CNG engine and performance: **.

This engine is a version of pulsar classic's (non DTSi) 180 cc motor designed to run on CNG.
It starts at a flick of a button (standard from post 2004 models, early ones had a key start) but the crank sounds like a drunkard coughing repeatedly.
It is noisy, more so as compared to 2 stroke RE petrol motor and the more speeds increase, the more noise and vibrations persist and it wheezes like hell, more so than a politician being asked to tell the truth.

I touched 0-40 at a tantalising 32 seconds, and it takes another 60 odd seconds to go from 40-55 as the engine whines and cries "enough!". Top speed is claimed 65 kmph.

In comparision, I recall that the 2 stroke RE petrols were fast and smooth, in fact, they could easily keep up with carburatted M 800s!
The CNG is not so.

Gearbox: **1/2.

It has 4 speed gearbox and 1 reverse (4F+1R), 1 down, 3 up pattern on the left handle bar.

Shift actions are baulky, sometimes the box being hesitant to shift to 4th. Actually, when I shifted to first and depressed the clutch quickly, the front wheel jumped off the road, as I expected it to.
But the 2nd, 3rd and 4th gears are not-so smooth shifting and suffer from whine at speeds above 30. 1st and 2nd ratios are short, but there is a wide gap between the 3rd and 4th gears, the main reason for the engine's wheezing performance in interests of gas mileage.

Driver appeal: ** (from the point of view of auto driver)


Comparision with RE 2S petrol is all but inevitible. The drivers really enjoyed driving that TSR as it was peppy, efficient, smooth and reliable with good speed. It also handled like a dream.
Compared to that, this is exactly opposite as the engine suffers from noise, vibrations and to make matters worse, added weight of CNG cylinder and tougher emission norms means it is no longer a performer, with the engine calibrated for maximum efficiency at the cost of driveability. Also, handling this one is tricky as all the weight is unevenly distributed (the CNG cylinder is placed diagonally), and at high speed it is prone to topple.

Braking:***.

The new hydraulic brakes (drums all round) with tandem master cylinder provides decent and reliable braking as compared to earlier ones. However, it requires frequent maintenance too. Rear wheels lock easily and the vehicle has the tendency to lose composure due to skidding on wet surfaces, as observed by me on earlier rides before.

Ride:

**1/2 with stock,
*** with upgraded tyres.


Remember: It runs on puny 8 inch wheels with 4 ply rating cross ply tyres and is equipped with oil filled shockers. Ride had to be bone jarring and it is. However, it deteriorates and gets skittish as the speeds increase and you fear of your head hitting the roof or being shaken and stirred due to absence of seat belts. Moreover, the poor design and quality of shockers, especially front ones, means that you suffer throughout the journey. Low speed ride, however is decent.
Now, most of the auto drivers upgrade their tyres to 6 ply from 4 ply and the ride improves by at least 20%, making it tolerable.
Still, it is not as comfy as a bike with SNS (spring in spring) suspension.

Build quality: **.

Built with tissue thin sheet metal with canvas top is crude, and it won't earn any brownie points form safety either. But, for a basic commercial vehicle that costs 1.25 lakh, don't expect top class build.

Fit and Finish: ***.

Paint finish is good, other components don't give you that upmarket feel, but who cares for a vehicle that has to be abused every now and then?
All that matters are engine and seats, nothing else.

Body Durability: ****.

They may be built crude, but decently maintained autos have withstood Delhi's roads for more than 3,00,000 kms and some are still going strong.
Actually, based on the feedback from drivers, the first CNG autos that came between 2000-2003had better body durability as compared to the ones today and often command a high resale value.

Purchase price (VFM):

***1/2 (from bajaj)
ZERO OUT OF 5 (if purchased in black from Delhi dealers)


As mentioned, the price of appox Rs. 1,25,000 is bang on in the nano non AC territory but for a CNG commercial vehicle, I think it is reasonable.

HOWEVER, there is a big mafia in Delhi which is active in issuing permits and also replacement autos with new ones every 3-4 years, due to which anyone who wants to buy a new auto cannot do it freely without the help of dalals.
In this case, all the the autos you see in Delhi cost a whopping Rs. 4,20,000! A total rip off! Thats even more than some bare basic sedans!

DELHI GOVT! WAKE UP!
STOP BEING CORRUPT and give us a clean and efficient PBTS.

Ownership and maintenance costs: **.


Buying it may be cheap, but since bajaj almost has monopoly in Delhi, many parts are prohibitively expensive and servicing them at authorized service centers costs a bomb.
Moreover, dealer attitude itself is pathetic towards these drivers/ auto owners and often taxes and labour are heavily charged with poor quality of work done, often causing utter dissatisfaction to drivers and cry foul over the company. The situation is improved as compared to the year 2000, but only slightly.
A large number of TSR drivers do not go to the ASC to get the work done, rather than go to roadside mechanics and independent workshops where work is done pretty decently and also saves cost by about a whopping 50%.

Mechanical reliability:**.

From the beginning, the engine suffers from technical problems like shutting off mysteriously when the auto is driven in monsoon season on flooded roads, poor quality pistons and crankshafts being installed leading to premature crank and bearing failures, in addition to the pathetic quality of front shocker design which often breaks apart, even in some new vehicles, leading to accidents like tyre bursts, toppling over, windshield cracks etc.These problems persist even today.

Summing up:**1/2.

As a product, the RE 4S provides cheap eco-friendly and easy to drive commercial transport for lakhs who depend upon it for their livelihood.
I am reviewing it not as a car reviewer, but by putting myself on the shoes of a typical auto driver and in this count, if it was an RE 2 stroke petrol, I would have given it 3.5-4 stars out of 5.
However, this product is a good concept let down by poor execution due to the aforementioned pros and cons. Yes initially in april 2000 bajaj had very limited time and pressure to bring this auto in the market but after the launch they also had ample time, 9 years to be precise, to improve from their earlier offerings and make improvements. Those improvements to the design and technology are there, and it is commendable.
But, to save costs, the quality of spare parts has deteriorated, even after the rates have been increased every 2 years and maintaining it is a big hole in the pocket and the autowallahs are still not happy with the product per se, the dealer service attitude and the mafia thats prevailing in Delhi controlling the costs of buying the autos and permits.
Autowallahs still swear that the earlier RE 2 stroke was infinitely better and more reliable and cheap to maintain and gave decent petrol mileage.

For this, we have to change the system. What Delhi needs is cheap, efficient and clean maintanance free PBTS which is environment friendly and also to bajaj to improve its product design, quality and A.S.S. to make its customers more satisfied because many of the drivers earn their livelihood with this profession. With rising auto fares, passengers are getting more finicky and go to other ways to save money, also the introduction of AC buses by DTC are giving good competition to autos.

It takes only 1 big change to unsettle bajaj autos from delhi-PIAGGIO APE which has doors all round, has a stylish and safe metal body, comfy seats, twin headlights instead of one, and also coming in CNG.

But, due to mafia, bajaj easily enjoys monopoly in delhi, ripping its customers and drivers in the name of poor quality CNG prosuct and expensive running costs.

Wake up bajaj, before it is to late.
Attached Images
 

Last edited by GTO : 6th August 2014 at 16:38.
sidindica is offline   Reply With Quote

Old 19th June 2009, 20:13   #2
BHPian
 
nipunkul's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Bangalore
Posts: 118
Thanked: 12 Times
Default

we have come to expect great things from you. Perhaps a ferrari?

(hope its not a scooter )
nipunkul is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th June 2009, 20:17   #3
BHPian
 
SilentEngine's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Mangalore-Bangalore
Posts: 836
Thanked: 38 Times
Default

Bajaj Auto?
The image points to that
SilentEngine is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th June 2009, 20:26   #4
Distinguished - BHPian
 
wildon's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Bangalore
Posts: 2,401
Thanked: 921 Times
Default

Yes its the RE2S CNG Auto from Bajaj
Attached Images
 
wildon is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th June 2009, 20:37   #5
Senior - BHPian
 
sidindica's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: India
Posts: 4,538
Thanked: 2,073 Times
Default

yes, its going to be a Bajaj RE 4 Stroke CNG "auto" mobile. Coming tomorrow.
sidindica is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th June 2009, 20:38   #6
Senior - BHPian
 
frankmehta's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Mumbai
Posts: 3,425
Thanked: 530 Times
Default

is it any different from the other CNG autos running in Mumbai or any other cities??
frankmehta is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th June 2009, 21:04   #7
Distinguished - BHPian
 
greenhorn's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: LS11
Posts: 6,198
Thanked: 485 Times
Default

another first for sidindica
greenhorn is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th June 2009, 21:18   #8
Senior - BHPian
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Kochi
Posts: 2,146
Thanked: 137 Times
Default

Ah. Now, sidindica is going review an "unguided missile", as it was referred to by some novelist.
BaCkSeAtDrIVeR is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th June 2009, 22:01   #9
Distinguished - BHPian
 
jkdas's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Thiruvananthapuram-Shertalla!
Posts: 9,269
Thanked: 875 Times
Default

TVS one, not the Bajaj one

mail4ajo: new ones have hydraulics and works on both front and rear.

Last edited by jkdas : 19th June 2009 at 22:12.
jkdas is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th June 2009, 22:03   #10
Senior - BHPian
 
mail4ajo's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Chennai
Posts: 1,599
Thanked: 87 Times
Default

I am going to like this. I like driving autos, quite tough at higher speeds, but lots of fun. Literally no brakes.... I heard the new ones comes with hydraulic brakes and activates both front and rear.

My friend had a pvt auto for transporting stuff and we used to have a blast.
mail4ajo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 20th June 2009, 10:32   #11
Senior - BHPian
 
sidindica's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: India
Posts: 4,538
Thanked: 2,073 Times
Default

Bajaj RE 4 stroke CNG technical specifications and features
Attached Images
   
sidindica is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 20th June 2009, 11:46   #12
Senior - BHPian
 
tanwaramit's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Dilwalon ki Dilli
Posts: 1,717
Thanked: 127 Times
Default

sid, is this an autorickshaw you are talking about ? Is it any different than the ones currently running in Delhi (dont know, just asking)
tanwaramit is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 20th June 2009, 13:06   #13
BHPian
 
SAHIR.KITTUR's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Belgaum / Doha
Posts: 290
Thanked: 70 Times
Default

Sidindica,

Please dont forget to mention the offroad capabilities too.
SAHIR.KITTUR is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 20th June 2009, 13:09   #14
Senior - BHPian
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Kochi
Posts: 2,146
Thanked: 137 Times
Default

@tanwaramit - I guess sidindica is reviewing a 4 stroke rick with factory fitted CNG. CNG ricks currently on road are retrofitted.

BTW I distrinctly I remember that 4 stroke (petrol only) ricks from Bajaj had several problems, and teh rules were amended to accomodate Bajaj RE 2 stroke vehicles.

I guess even new ricks from Bajaj are 2 stroke. Am I right?
BaCkSeAtDrIVeR is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 20th June 2009, 13:55   #15
BHPian
 
SAHIR.KITTUR's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Belgaum / Doha
Posts: 290
Thanked: 70 Times
Default

let me add something,

NO JACK is required to change a flat tyre. !!!
SAHIR.KITTUR is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Auto Rickshaw Menace para_7k Street Experiences 98 30th August 2014 14:32
Auto Rickshaw as personal transport Subbu The Indian Car Scene 36 6th August 2014 12:35
Bajaj bringing back 2-stroke bikes? shortbread Motorbikes 12 1st November 2012 23:13
Test: New Improved Bajaj RE CNG Auto 4 stroke sidindica Test-Drives & Initial Ownership Reports 9 25th July 2009 10:50
Tried Tested CNG fitment centre in Delhi hbaruas Modifications & Accessories 3 18th June 2009 10:13


All times are GMT +5.5. The time now is 17:38.

Copyright 2000 - 2014, Team-BHP.com
Proudly powered by E2E Networks