Re: Bus Rapid Transit Systems- Can it save our cities? Quote:
Originally Posted by sourabhzen 1. I don't have an answer now will search for it.
2. So that a vehicle carrying 15 times more commuters than a car or SUV can move in peace. How much time will it take to procure buses. The BRTS will remain for a lifetime.
3. Check Ahmedabad system. it runs on similar system. We will soon be able to use our DMRC card on DTC buses. Systems are improving.
4. It is not a total waste of public money. This money is being used for more needy public. It is not possible to get things right the first time. Give BRTS time to become effective.
5. Even DMRC faced oppsition before its inception in Delhi. Look at it now, one can not imagine the fate of Delhi roads without Metro.
6. Delhi Transport minister opposed (with huge public support) the conversion of public transport to CNG. SC forced him to comply and trust me it made a huge impact on pollution levels.
7. These reforms are for greater public good and they will take time to reach perfection. We shall not write them off just because our cars find it difficult to move. Not everyone can afford expensive private transport. |
1. I think I can answer it. If you contruct BRTS lanes on left - how will you allow other vehicles, which are on right, to exit the road?
2. Yes. The real reason why BRTS lane is empty is simply because the city administration doesn't have the buses yet.
They don't have the buses yet! This is the most elementary and basic of all requirements. You don't have buses, you cannot ply passengers comfortably.
Agreed, this takes time. Do you know how long I have been living in Pune? 6 years. BRTS exists right next to my house (well figuratively). In these last 6 years - I have not seen any increase of bus frequency on this route. I have not seen any increase in introduction of truly world class buses worthy enough to use the BRTS lanes. I have not seen any bus stop which has world class conveniences that can make this system stand apart.
3. I think I did post the Ahmedabad BRTS station picture to illustrate what Pune BRTS (and "hopefully" rest of India BRTS) is lacking.
4. In fact I acknowledged that BRTS system is better and more economical than the Metro Rail system. But the thorough idiocity in implementation in this country coupled with the ultra corruptness and citizenry's mute spectation leads to wastage of trillions of rupees. Whose rupees? Public's. The mute spectators who don't question anything.
5. Do you know what was the cause of opposition to DMRC? Is the same even applicable for BRTS?
6. I was present in Delhi during the CNG fiasco. The truth behind the matter is that Delhi govt was given about 2-3 years time to convert the public transport to CNG based system. The similar govt machinery that you defend today. These idiots were sitting on their haunches till the deadline came. Supreme court was adamant and this adamancy lead to govt machinery gears moving which finally lead to change over to CNG.
7. I am not opposed to ANY public transport system. What I am opposed to is the idiots at the helm, who device schemes ONLY to funnel the public money into their accounts, and in doing so - they are successful in making a complete mockery of a great idea.
Last edited by alpha1 : 15th March 2013 at 11:32.
|