Quote:
Originally Posted by Mpower Jat, you are right about the compressor and that it should always operate to the right of the surge line, but the point I am trying to make is that there is no cause for surge when the foot is lifted off the throttle. The excess air simply flows through the engine. The amount of air dosent matter in a diesel because its the amount of fuel that determines the torque produced.
The bottom line is that diesels dont have a BOV, surge or no-surge. I suggest you get hold of a service manual and see for yourself. |
Oops, messed it up again. Sorry for that.
You are right, BOV is not found in dieselcar or for that matter in normal petrol car (only the rating is high then you will find BOV along with other factors, just think about a 1.5 L diesel producing about 120 PS) because the turbos performance is kept much below than maximum possible as engine opertion is not going to be montiored by trained personnel.
What I was trying to explain was about the fundtion of BOV and EGR.
And you are right about amount of air doesn't matter whether it is diesel or petrol when fuel is cut off. But when you apply brakes suddenly without disengaging clutch, then what happens. Surge does not occur all the time, but only for a short time (from a fraction of a second to few seconds) when the speed change is there. After that it is back to normal. It is difficult to go over the entire air dynamics to explain the surge but to realise what I am talking about, try to visualise what happens when you reduce the engine rpm RAPIDLY or SUDDENLY STOP ENGINE FROM A FULL LOAD (where the inertia effect is maximum) at 0.01 seconds interval (FEA - right) because the whole imbalance is over in say 0.5 to 2 seconds. The rpm is reducing. But air flow is same. Turbo goes over the surge line. Air flow reveral takes place - your 0.02 seconds is over. Balance is restored. Air flow shoots up bur engine rpm is still going down. You hear the first BOOM. The cylcle starts again as engine rpm is still not stabilized. 2nd BOOM. After 1 second, rpm has stabilized. You have already heard 50 BOOMs which means a sound frequency beat with natural frequency of turbo system at 50 Hz for just 1 second.
(In bigger high performance engines, the noise or exlosion type sound can give a real shock, if you are anywhere near the engine and under certain conditions you can really feel the air pulsation if you are very close to turbocharger air inlet).
Please note that this is only explaination for surge with RAPID CHANGE IN RPM and please do not mix with diesel or petrol or turbo or surge due blockage or air passage etc.
RK |