Review: Netgear PTV3000 Miracast Backgroud
I visited my cousin couple of months back. He had got a new TV Sony Bravia
W700B (IIRC). I was going through the features, settings etc and happen to hit the "Screen Mirroring" option.
I had heard about this but never really experienced it. I was carrying my Galaxy S3 and Nexus 7 (2nd Gen) and it was a time to test the mirroring feature.
Now each brand has a different name for essentially the same feature based on "Miracast" standard where we are mirroring the contents on the device (both the screen and the audio) to the receiver.
S3 calls it "Screen Mirroring"
Nexus 7 (2nd Gen) calls it "Cast Screen".
Both devices worked flawlessly. I was streaming full hd wirelessly!!!
Swiping home screens, browing web, flicking images in the gallery all worked fine.
There was a very slight lag (may not be noticiable to many people). But otherwise it was perfect.
Streaming movies is made all the more convienient.
Bought Netgear PTV3000
Now i liked the concept and wanted it on my tv as well.
I have a 2010 Panasonic Plasma V20D model which doesn't support miracast out of the box.
Obviously i had to purchase a Miracast dongle to enable this.
I searched for dongles and came across few options like EZCast and some more cheap products and then there was Netgear Ptv3000 which was at a premium
compared to others.
I somehow didn't like EZCast as i looked at reviews which required a specific app to be installed on my device to work. Moreover i was not very sure of the
support or firmware updates.
I had made up my mind on PTV3000. Looked at couple of reviews which were mostly positive and with a known brand like Netgear, support was less likely to be
an issue.
So took the plunge.
Got the device from ITDepot for Rs 4600.
The box contains:
1) Miracast receiver
2) HDMI cable to connect to the TV
3) USB charge cable to power up the device (this can be connected to the USB port on TV or a dedicated charger, the TV's USB port worked fine for me).
Performance
The first thing after setup was to check and install the latest firmware.
Nexus 7
Cast screen option is shown in the settings pull down menu.
Once you hit "Cast screen", it searches for Miracast adapters, Found my PTV and selected.
After few seconds the device connected and whoa my wireless mirroring was working.
Performance is smooth as i had experienced on my cousin's sony tv.
Galaxy S3 (i9300)
Things aren't so great with the S3. Video playback through the video player is fine.
But the usual interactions like swiping home screens, browing web, scrolling through the UI in general is choppy.
I guess I need to await a firmware update for a fix.
Dell XPS 15 (L502x) + Windows 7 64 bit
There's a pre-installed app "Intel Widi" which should theoritically work with PTV3000 but somehow i couldn't get it to work.D
So basically it worked on 1 of the 3 devices i tried it on. Sounds like a downer but the stuff i want to stream is present on the tab so not really an issue for me. Also Windows 8.1 has much better support for Miracast but i don't have windows 8.1 so couldn't test this. Netgear PTV3000 is officially supported on 8.1 though so it should work fine. |