I purchased a VW Polo 1.6 MPI Highline in September 2011 (
http://www.team-bhp.com/forum/test-d...olo-1-6-a.html), from Downtown Mumbai (Shaman Cars), and have been having my car serviced by them ever since at their Lalbaug workshop. In just a little over 2 years, this car had done about 11,800 kms, when I sent it for its 2nd Service.
I took my car to the Service Centre on the 23rd of September. Apart from the routine 2 year/30,000 km service procedures, I even had a few other issues that I wanted rectified during this visit. One of these was the immensely poor braking power of the car. Off late, the brake pedal really needed to be pushed hard in order to bite sufficiently. This was problematic, worrisome and even dangerous. The Service Advisor acknowledged this problem at the time of trial, and committed to investigating the problem.
After a few days, the Service Adviser called me to inform me that this weak brake problem could be solved by replacing the brake pads, rear brake lining, front brake discs, and brake oil. While this seemed like an appropriate fix to the problem, I was astounded as to why such major brake-component replacements were required for a 2 year old car having done just 11,800 kms. Anyhow, being a solution to the problem, I asked him to go ahead with the necessary work, after he committed to covering these expenses (except brake oil) under my AMC and Warranty.
However, at time of delivery of the car, I was surprised to find that he had slapped a bill of approximately Rs. 6,500 relating to the brake work, of which a significant portion was the cost of inserting new front brake discs (Rs. 4,800). I am extremely disappointed that such a well-established product, from a world renowned brand that is Volkswagen, would require a front brake disc replacement at 11,800 kms! As a man passionate about motor cars, who works with the industry, I not only find a replacement this early rare, but also absurd. Front brake discs are known to last at least 30-40,000 kms, and thus I have no doubt that these brake discs were defective. However, when I attempted to dispute this charge, and claim the replacement under warranty, I was met with an extremely unhelpful, nonchalant, callous, and rude response from both the Service Adviser (who by now is well known to me), and the Workshop Manager Mr. Thomas Chandy.
Without accepting this premature replacement of the brake discs to be due to a defect in the product, they went on to tell me that the occurrence of this is due to the fact that I live by the Sea, and therefore ultimately the fault is mine and not theirs. I was disgusted to have received advice to change my location of residence, which frankly is not their concern. For the record, I have in the past and do own other motorcars that have never given me a problem like this. After a heated argument, Mr. Thomas only left me with 2 options – either pay the damages, or have them take out the replaced parts, and install the old, worn out parts back again, and continue driving a car with shoddy, useless, brakes. It’s amazing how the Manager of a Service Centre can even suggest something as thoughtless as this. With a feeling of unhelpfulness I paid the bill.
This only aggravated my negative opinion about Shaman Cars, as in the past I have only ever had bad experiences with them. Week old service appointments are often denied hours before drop-off, drop-off itself takes an hour to find a Service Adviser willing to take the responsibility of work (or to wait for your assigned Service Adviser till he finishes attending the 10 other customers waiting for him before you), the work itself is almost always delayed to inconveniently long periods of time, picking-up the car also involves a good 2 hours waiting at the Service Centre till the Service Adviser and car is found, paperwork is completed, and car is washed, and almost always the car is returned with newly surfaced scratches and dents, that are acknowledged by them but not worth leaving the car with them for an extra week.
Being the owner of a product of the leading automobile manufacturer in the world, one does not expect to have to deal with such hassles, dis courteousness and insolence. Ultimately the way the brand is represented in the market and to the customers, is in the hands of the dealers. And to that effect allow me to say that in my opinion, Shaman Cars and their team are doing a pathetic job in representing Volkswagen in Mumbai.
I have written to Volkswagen India, hoping to experience the real professionalism and quality of the Volkswagen brand. I hope they take up this matter and respond with some sense of responsibility, by acknowledging that the only reason a motorcar’s front brake discs could wear out within 11,800 kms is if there is a genuine defect in the component.
I would appreciate any advice, thoughts, or comments regarding this situation, and whether it is worth pursuing at a higher level, and if so how that can be done.
Regards,
RTM