Detroit Of India?

Mpower · 1st April 2006, 04:45

Which city in your opinion is the best for setting up a new car plant and why?

Recently we've heard of VW's search for a new plant site for their India ops and they are not able to make up their mind yet.

Let's help them out shall we?

islero · 1st April 2006, 09:41

Chennai please!!!!!

It aldready has Ford, Hyundai, BMW, Enfield, so I think VW should come here too.

man23ish · 1st April 2006, 10:00

1> ARAI is present in Pune.

2> Tata, Mahindra are in Pune (equivalent to GM and Ford, in the US)

Next in line comes kolkata, but the HM unit in Kolkata is sick..

GTO · 1st April 2006, 10:45

Going by the history of instability, I can tell you what should NOT be an option on anyones list - Maharashtra.

GTO

sajo · 1st April 2006, 10:49

Quote:

Originally Posted by man23ish

2> Tata, Mahindra are in Pune (equivalent to GM and Ford, in the US)

Mahindra is in Nashik. But we have various component manufacturers here, as also two wheeler giant Bajaj, and Kinetic. We have upcoming manufacturer Kanda (with their ambitious plans) and DCIL too.

goldie_malhotra · 1st April 2006, 13:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by islero

Chennai please!!!!!

It aldready has Ford, Hyundai, BMW, Enfield, so I think VW should come here too.

Thats a whole lot - and the TN govts also have been very welcoming to them.

Another candidate could be Delhi-NCR - it has the biggest Fish - MUL, and also Honda.
Not to mention, one of the largest metro markets. Plus a huge market in Punjab for luxury cars.

quicksilvr · 1st April 2006, 15:38

I would say chennai...for its strong ancillary industry and govt backing

ksethuram · 1st April 2006, 16:04

TamilNadu has many highly regarded OEM manufacturers like TVS , TI, Ennore Foundaries, Geethanjali, Rane, Talbros, Simpsons, Pricol, Lucas, Delphi, Roots, MRF, L. G. Brothers, India Pistons, Gabriel etc.

All of them are in Chennai, Coimbatore or Hosur which makes them easily accesible.
Manufacturers like TVS, Eicher, Enfield, Ashok Leyland, Ford, Hyundai, HM Mitsubishi are already here.

In addition Chennai has abundance of skilled people with good work ethics.

The government is also too supportive. What else do u need?

For sure chennai is Detroit of India.

Mpower · 1st April 2006, 21:15

Chennai does have a good track record, not to mention its a Port city, which neither NCR nor Pune can boast of.

But the downside could be high labor costs and high real-estate costs.

VW is said to be connsidering setting up in Vizag in AP for exactly this reason. I think this is a slightly risky move because there is no history of automobile manufacture in those parts. Also, I'm not sure how well its connected with highways.

Steeroid · 1st April 2006, 21:23

Chennai, no two ways about it.

hari_rama · 1st April 2006, 22:44

all the above mentioned states is heavily industrialized
here kerala is free & so it is best place for a new car plant

Kochi is a suitable place with the new cargo terminals getting ready

Mpower · 1st April 2006, 23:26

Quote:

Originally Posted by GTO

Going by the history of instability, I can tell you what should NOT be an option on anyones list - Maharashtra.
GTO

Maharashtra got a bad name mostly because of Bombay. Both Mahindra and PAL/Fiat faced the brunt of labour problems. Not to mention flooding! Its now rumoured that FIAT is selling off its plant to developers and moving to Ranjangaon now.

Otherwise Pune, Nashik, Baramati, Aurangabad are all doing pretty well.

hellspawn · 2nd April 2006, 02:10

i think greater noida or gurgaon are good viable options ......they offer cheap land and plus u already have honda and maruti.

greatDrive · 2nd April 2006, 10:59

Quote:

Originally Posted by hellspawn

i think greater noida or gurgaon are good viable options ......they offer cheap land and plus u already have honda and maruti.

Greater noida and Gurgoan is not cheaper anymore..........if you compare it with other metros. specially if you talk about commercial and industrial land.

adya33 · 2nd April 2006, 12:38

Quote:

Otherwise Pune, Nashik, Baramati, Aurangabad are all doing pretty well.

Don't know about Nashik, Baramati or Aurangabad but in Pune

You have no infrastructure at all.
No regular electricity supply.
No regular water supply.
Horrible roads.
Even more horrible traffic conditions.
No public transport which is worthy of mentioning.
Extreme weather conditions Summer almost 40+ deg and winter almost < 5 deg.

Other than that its a great city. (sarcasm)

1st April 2006, 04:45	#1
Mpower Senior - BHPian Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Bangalore Posts: 10,409 Thanked: 1,730 Times View My Garage	Detroit Of India? Which city in your opinion is the best for setting up a new car plant and why? Recently we've heard of VW's search for a new plant site for their India ops and they are not able to make up their mind yet. Let's help them out shall we?
	() Thanks

1st April 2006, 09:41	#2
islero Senior - BHPian Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Chennai Posts: 1,574 Thanked: 13 Times View My Garage	Chennai please!!!!! It aldready has Ford, Hyundai, BMW, Enfield, so I think VW should come here too.
	() Thanks

1st April 2006, 10:00	#3
man23ish BHPian Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Bangalore Posts: 626 Thanked: 18 Times	It has to be Pune !! 1> ARAI is present in Pune. 2> Tata, Mahindra are in Pune (equivalent to GM and Ford, in the US) Next in line comes kolkata, but the HM unit in Kolkata is sick..
	() Thanks

1st April 2006, 10:45	#4
GTO Team-BHP Support Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Bombay Posts: 70,546 Thanked: 300,788 Times View My Garage	Going by the history of instability, I can tell you what should NOT be an option on anyones list - Maharashtra. GTO
	() Thanks

1st April 2006, 15:38	#7
quicksilvr BHPian Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Chennai Posts: 41 Thanked: 0 Times	I would say chennai...for its strong ancillary industry and govt backing
	() Thanks

1st April 2006, 16:04	#8
ksethuram BHPian Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: Chennai , London (now) Posts: 233 Thanked: Once	TamilNadu has many highly regarded OEM manufacturers like TVS , TI, Ennore Foundaries, Geethanjali, Rane, Talbros, Simpsons, Pricol, Lucas, Delphi, Roots, MRF, L. G. Brothers, India Pistons, Gabriel etc. All of them are in Chennai, Coimbatore or Hosur which makes them easily accesible. Manufacturers like TVS, Eicher, Enfield, Ashok Leyland, Ford, Hyundai, HM Mitsubishi are already here. In addition Chennai has abundance of skilled people with good work ethics. The government is also too supportive. What else do u need? For sure chennai is Detroit of India.
	() Thanks

1st April 2006, 21:15	#9
Mpower Senior - BHPian Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Bangalore Posts: 10,409 Thanked: 1,730 Times View My Garage	Chennai does have a good track record, not to mention its a Port city, which neither NCR nor Pune can boast of. But the downside could be high labor costs and high real-estate costs. VW is said to be connsidering setting up in Vizag in AP for exactly this reason. I think this is a slightly risky move because there is no history of automobile manufacture in those parts. Also, I'm not sure how well its connected with highways.
	() Thanks

1st April 2006, 21:23	#10
Steeroid Senior - BHPian Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: N.A Posts: 7,046 Thanked: 2,751 Times	Chennai, no two ways about it.
	() Thanks

1st April 2006, 22:44	#11
hari_rama BHPian Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: Trichur Posts: 270 Thanked: 16 Times View My Garage	all the above mentioned states is heavily industrialized here kerala is free & so it is best place for a new car plant Kochi is a suitable place with the new cargo terminals getting ready
	() Thanks

2nd April 2006, 02:10	#13
hellspawn Join Date: Jul 2005 Location: noida Posts: 1,686 Thanked: 7 Times View My Garage Infractions: 0/1 (10)	i think greater noida or gurgaon are good viable options ......they offer cheap land and plus u already have honda and maruti.
	() Thanks