Team-BHP
(
https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/)
Mod Note: Team-BHP's Rapid DSG Review is located at this link. Please continue the discussion over on the new thread. Thanks!
Skoda's launching the Rapid now with a new DSG auto box.
This tranny will only be available on the diesel model on the mid Ambition and top end elegance Variant.
The Surprise?
Unlike the Octavia/Superb which come with the 6-Speed DQ250, the Rapid will come with the dry type 7-speed DQ200 DSG Gearbox!
This is possible as the Rapid's figure just cuts the Mustard when it comes to the maximum torque figures that this gearbox can handle (25.5 kgm)
Other Changes
1) Skoda also plans the black edition which will be available only on the top end Elegance variant which adds certain cosmetic upgrades to the exterior of the car.
2) The Diesel engine has now been downsized by 100 cc, but produces the same power and torque figures.
Good move by Skoda I think. It will surely create a buzz among folk looking for a sub 15 lac diesel sedan. The article does not mention a price but indicates a lac over the top diesel manual which I reckon would put it in the 11 to 12 lac region.
Honda could possibly face some heat and might spur them on to bring out a diesel AT city.:)
:eek:
I never thought Skoda would launch this most awaited engine + Tranny combination first.
Good move Skoda. But i am still wondering, How could they manage to extract the same power and torque figures by reducing the engine to 1498 CC from 1596 CC.
Kudos, for not touching the suspension & other parts to retain the same old Handling.
Now this brings an interesting proposition. I am 24 and am looking to buy a small diesel car. I was looking at the polo GT TDi and TSi. Although i wanted diesel, TSi was on cards because of the autobox. Now that Rapid is both diesel and automatic brings out an interesting dilemma.
Is it worth shelling out 3 lacs over polo for the 7 speed DSG. I drive alone or at max with a co passenger, so from practicality front both serve my purpose.
I am big fan of VAG mods and think polo wins there. confusion - confusion.
The issue that Skoda will have to face is that the Rapid is available for about a lakh discount. If the DSG does not have any discount, the difference between the Rapid Manual 1.6 diesel and 1.5 diesel DSG will be in the range of 2.5 lakhs+ which could psychologically trouble buyer's minds.
Quote:
Originally Posted by dipen
(Post 3540190)
The issue that Skoda will have to face is that the Rapid is available for about a lakh discount. If the DSG does not have any discount, the difference between the Rapid Manual 1.6 diesel and 1.5 diesel DSG will be in the range of 2.5 lakhs+ which could psychologically trouble buyer's minds. |
That's a correct observation. I am hoping skoda prices it 50k above elegance that would make it 1.5 lakh more expensive in all. Interesting! fingers crossed :thumbs up
Good move to tackle falling sales and customer satisfaction? Its a tricky move keeping in mind the surprises DSG gearboxes can bring about when its not working well. Hope this gets a thumbs up from customers along with good customer service.
The news is a mixed bag. I am glad that Diesel DSGs are coming down the segment into worthy cars.
But can the DQ200 handle all that torque without trouble? Wouldn't the wet type DQ250 be a better choice?
Is this real? Rapid scores over the Octavia? Yumm!
Aside: How reliable is this DSG - has the technology undergone the fixes needed to make it reliable over longer term?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Equus
(Post 3540289)
Is this real? Rapid scores over the Octavia? Yumm!
Aside: How reliable is this DSG - has the technology undergone the fixes needed to make it reliable over longer term? |
The DSG issue of the DQ200 has been a big reliability concern.
However Skoda claims to have improvised this issue by bringing certain software upgrades and strengthening the mechatronic mechanicals post the launch of the new Octavia which uses this improved version of the DQ200 in its 1.8TSI model.
Now this claim may be true as we hav'int heard that many complaints of mechatronic faliure in the new Octavia. Either that or maybe its still to early to call as its barely been a year since the cars launch and long term still needs to be looked into.
That being said there is a temporary fix for this issue from the car owners end.
Golden Rule: Don't let the car stay in drive for more than 10 seconds when the car is stagnant.
This will prevent overheating of the mechatronic unit and probably may prolong its life. :thumbs up
Cheers!
Starfire
OR
"How to get rid of some excess DSG stock now that you've decided to go back to good old Torque Converters"
Put it on the only volume model you have and call it "Black Edition".
Quote:
Originally Posted by Starfire
(Post 3540084)
Unlike the Octavia/Superb which come with the 6-Speed DQ250 ,
The Rapid will come with the dry type 7-speed DQ200 DSG Gearbox!
This is possible as the Rapid's figure just cuts the Mustard when it comes the minimum Torque figures that this gearbox can handle (25.5 kgm) |
Here in Europe, the Octavia, Golf and the A3 are all available with 1.6L TDI engine + 7-speed DSG.
Quote:
Originally Posted by StarrySky
(Post 3540366)
Here in Europe, the Octavia, Golf and the A3 are all available with 1.6L TDI engine + 7-speed DSG. |
Yes i know that Bro, but those markets can afford that combination as DSG faliures are significantly less abroad because:
1) The running conditions like less stop-go traffic and less environmental temperatures ensures better life of the DSG.
2) Volkswagen have already issued for a global recall to set the gremlim in the box right. Sadly India wasnt on the list of fortunate ones to get the recall.
Cheers!
Starfire
As someone who has had 2 DSG failures on my Superb, all I can say is that so called Golden rules to avoid them are myths. I switch to N at any decently long signal, do not push the car too much by trying to drive predictably et al - but of course can't do anything about the terrible peak hour South Bombay traffic I drive in. The good news is that Skoda seems to be willing to repair DSG failures free of cost - hopefully, they will follow that policy for the Rapid as well. Though why they don't announce a 10 year, 100000 km warranty for the mechatronics boggles my mind.
All times are GMT +5.5. The time now is 19:16. | |