F1 experts rate the drivers - Half Season.

ranjan united · 12th July 2006, 01:21

Source: F1 Magazine - July 2006 / These F1 experts are, well there are 30 of them so i'll put down some of them, Ross Brawn, Nick Fry, Patrick Head, Christian Horner, Max Mosley, Dave Richards, Peter Sauber, Paul Stoddart, Pat Symonds, Mario Thiessesen, Jean Todt. All 11 teams have atleast one juror (ferrari obviously has 2).
23. Yuji Ide
22. Franck Montagny
21. Cristijan Albers
20. Tiago Montiero
19. Takuma Sato
18. Scott Speed
17. Tonio Liuzzi
16/15. David Coulthard
15/16. Christian Klien
14. Jarno Trulli
13. Rubens Barrichello
12. Nick Heidfeld
11. Jaque Villneuve
10. Michael Schumacher
9. JP Montoya
8. Ralf Schumacher
7. Mark Webber
6. Giancarlo Fisichella
5. Nico Rosberg
4. Jenson Button
3. Felipe Massa
2/1. Kimi Raikonnen and Fernando Alonso

Note:1. The 30 man jury was split on positions 15/16 and 1/2.
2. Michael Schumacher was 3rd, but was dropped to 10th after cheaing at Monaco. He will also be docked 5 places at the full season ratings.
3. Races considered: Bahrain to Monaco.

Rated Best Test Driver and Hot Talent: Robert Kubica (BMW)

killjoy · 12th July 2006, 21:09

Quote:

Originally Posted by ranjan united

2. Michael Schumacher was 3rd, but was dropped to 10th after cheaing at Monaco. He will also be docked 5 places at the full season ratings.

how sure are you of the news that he will lose 5 places at the end of the season? or are you just talking about the experts who rate them here?

ranjan united · 13th July 2006, 01:02

only talking about the experts. If it was just me, I wouldn't dock him anything else. He was punished by the stewards and thats enough. docking him 5 places in the end is not quite just fair.

sujaylahiri · 13th July 2006, 07:11

According to me, Webber and Fisichella should have been ahead of Button. And Coulthard a couple of places higher.
But in the end, Kimi rules!!!

killjoy · 13th July 2006, 10:24

think the top drivers dont really bother about who rates them where. all that matters for them is where they finish. maybe to a rookie an expert opinion of him might make some changes but i dont think it makes a difference for the top drivers. just my two cents

12th July 2006, 01:21	#1
ranjan united BHPian Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Windsor, Canada... But still a Bombay-Boy at heart !!! Posts: 409 Thanked: 3 Times	F1 experts rate the drivers - Half Season. Source: F1 Magazine - July 2006 / These F1 experts are, well there are 30 of them so i'll put down some of them, Ross Brawn, Nick Fry, Patrick Head, Christian Horner, Max Mosley, Dave Richards, Peter Sauber, Paul Stoddart, Pat Symonds, Mario Thiessesen, Jean Todt. All 11 teams have atleast one juror (ferrari obviously has 2). 23. Yuji Ide 22. Franck Montagny 21. Cristijan Albers 20. Tiago Montiero 19. Takuma Sato 18. Scott Speed 17. Tonio Liuzzi 16/15. David Coulthard 15/16. Christian Klien 14. Jarno Trulli 13. Rubens Barrichello 12. Nick Heidfeld 11. Jaque Villneuve 10. Michael Schumacher 9. JP Montoya 8. Ralf Schumacher 7. Mark Webber 6. Giancarlo Fisichella 5. Nico Rosberg 4. Jenson Button 3. Felipe Massa 2/1. Kimi Raikonnen and Fernando Alonso Note:1. The 30 man jury was split on positions 15/16 and 1/2. 2. Michael Schumacher was 3rd, but was dropped to 10th after cheaing at Monaco. He will also be docked 5 places at the full season ratings. 3. Races considered: Bahrain to Monaco. Rated Best Test Driver and Hot Talent: Robert Kubica (BMW)
	() Thanks

13th July 2006, 01:02	#3
ranjan united BHPian Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Windsor, Canada... But still a Bombay-Boy at heart !!! Posts: 409 Thanked: 3 Times	only talking about the experts. If it was just me, I wouldn't dock him anything else. He was punished by the stewards and thats enough. docking him 5 places in the end is not quite just fair.
	() Thanks

13th July 2006, 07:11	#4
sujaylahiri BHPian Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: North America Posts: 960 Thanked: 6 Times View My Garage	According to me, Webber and Fisichella should have been ahead of Button. And Coulthard a couple of places higher. But in the end, Kimi rules!!!
	() Thanks

13th July 2006, 10:24	#5
killjoy BHPian Join Date: Jun 2004 Location: Bangalore Posts: 753 Thanked: 317 Times View My Garage	think the top drivers dont really bother about who rates them where. all that matters for them is where they finish. maybe to a rookie an expert opinion of him might make some changes but i dont think it makes a difference for the top drivers. just my two cents
	() Thanks