Global NCAP: 3 stars for the SA-spec Suzuki S-Presso Global NCAP has published its latest round of #SaferCarsForAfrica crash test results.
The Suzuki S-Presso achieved three stars for adult occupant protection but reached only two stars for child occupant protection.
In the frontal impact at 64km/h into an offset deformable barrier, the driver and front passenger's heads and necks showed good protection. Dummy readings of high chest compression and an unstable passenger compartment caused driver chest protection to be rated as weak, which also rendered the car ineligible for scoring points for front seatbelt reminders. Suzuki were unable to demonstrate that structures behind the fascia would not pose an increased risk of injury to the knees of occupants of different sizes or those sat in different positions. Although pedal movement was limited, the footwell ruptured and protection to the driver's feet was penalised.
Suzuki refused to select child restraints for the test so the S-Presso was not awarded dynamic points for child occupants. Using the child seats selected by Global NCAP, head excursion of the three year-old dummy exceeded the maximum permissible 55cm limit, and dummy readings indicated excessive chest deceleration. The 18 month-old dummy's head was contained but dummy readings indicated high chest deceleration. The S-Presso does not offer ISOFIX anchorages and has a static lapbelt in the rear-centre seat, incapable of accommodating a universal CRS. Press Release Technical Report: Suzuki S-Presso + 2 Airbags Quote:
Global NCAP and the Automobile Association of South Africa launch the last result for the #SaferCarsForAfrica campaign under its current test protocols today (29 June), with the welcome support of the FIA Foundation and Bloomberg Philanthropies. As from next month the assessment protocols will be updated to include side impact, Electronic Stability Control (ESC) and pedestrian protection requirements.
The Maruti Suzuki S-Presso is manufactured in India and scored three stars for adult occupant protection and two stars for child occupant protection.
The model was previously tested by Global NCAP for the Indian market in 2020. It scored a zero star rating for adult occupant protection and two stars for child occupant protection. Following reports that the version of the car sold in South Africa had a better safety performance, Global NCAP decided to put the claims to the test.
The S-Presso in South Africa is fitted with two airbags as standard. During the assessment the S-Presso structure demonstrated an unstable performance and the driver’s chest showed a weak protection level, marginally avoiding a two star rating. Levels of child occupant protection showed the same performance as the version sold in India. The lack of ISOFIX anchorages, lack of a three point belt in all seating positions and the decision of Suzuki Maruti not to recommend a Child Restraint System (CRS) explain this poor child occupant protection score
Alejandro Furas, Secretary General of Global NCAP said,
“The safety performance of the S-Presso in South Africa has been far from satisfactory and claims of improvement are not reflected in levels of child occupant protection which remain the same as the Indian version we tested in 2020. There has been significant progress with vehicle safety in the Indian market with a welcome requirement for the fitment of six airbags as standard. We hope that Maruti Suzuki will not apply a double standard for the vehicles they sell in Africa compared to those sold in India.”
David Ward, Executive President of the Towards Zero Foundation said,
“As our current test protocols come to an end in Africa it is important to see manufacturers continue their commitment to high standards of vehicle safety. Some continue to do well but we remain disappointed with others. Sadly, Maruti Suzuki fall into this latter category, where the rhetoric on safety is simply not matched by the reality.”
Willem Groenewald, CEO of the Automobile Association of South Africa said,
“While the adult occupancy result for the S-Presso is encouraging there is room for improvement, especially in relation to the child protection rating. The safety of motorists in South Africa is critical and we welcome the visible efforts by manufacturers in this regard and urge them to continue investing in this important facet of their production.”
|
Child restraints:
3 year-old: Britax Duo Plus, forward-facing
18 month-old: Britax BabySafe, rearward-facing
Global NCAP's frontal offset test takes place at 64km/h with 40% of the width of the car crashing into a deformable barrier, with two average male adult dummies in the front seats, and 18 month-old and 3 year-old dummies in the rear seats in child seats selected by the vehicle manufacturer. The test represents two similar cars, both travelling at around 55km/h, crashing head-on with half their widths overlapping. 'Good protection' indicates dummy readings of less than a 5% risk of serious or worse injury, with additional criteria for robustness of performance.
Last edited by ron178 : 29th June 2022 at 20:07.
|