Esteem brake issues - replace or keep? Recently got my Esteem's oil changed at an MASS. While the car was on the ramp, I noticed the rear left wheel wasn't rotating freely. Pointed this out to the supervisor, and he asked the mechanic to open the wheel assembly. On opening, one of the drum brake shoes was found to be binding.
The reason for the bind was that the brake cylinder had jammed. They also pointed out that the brake drum had many grooves on it. They asked me to change the whole wheel assembly including the brake cylinder. That would also involve bleeding the brake fluid and replacing it.
Since it was late in the day, and the job would be time consuming, they asked me to bring the car the next day for the job.
Meanwhile, I went to another MASS for some other job. Asked them to look into the above matter. They opened the assembly again but this time the supervisor told me that only the brake cylinder may be replaced. He said the grooves on the brake drum will not affect anything and need not be changed. However, they did not have the parts and hence they said we will try to fix it without replacing anything. The mechanic just removed the rubber casing around one of the brake cylinder pistons and dabbed a rag soaked in KBX brake fluid, and then just tapped the piston with a hammer. The piston was rendered free without much effort. I was told that it was working fine now (I checked myself too), and its not really necessary to change the brake cylinder. While on the ramp, the wheel was now rotating freely and the wheel stopped rotating as it should, when brakes were applied.
My question is do I really need to replace the brake cylinder AND drum? Or would it be safe to continue using it, since everything seems to be alright? Is it likely that the cylinder that was tapped with a hammer may start leaking and lead to loss of braking? And is it ok to keep using the drum which has grooves etched on it? Will this cause premature wear of the brake shoes?
Hoping for advice from those who really know, as brakes is a serious issue and I'm getting conflicting advice from both the service centres. I'd rather not open everything again and spend more, unless of course safety/component life/efficiency is involved.
Thanks a heap in advance. |