Buying a Tata (Indica Vista Aura ABS) -Leap of Faith It was inevitable. Time to bid goodbye to my beloved ‘Silver Dart’ – Maruti 800 AC (2006 December) with aftermarket LPG Kit (Lovato). She had served me exceptionally well for more than three years without a squeak or groan in three cities (Hyderabad, Chennai and Mumbai) as I got transferred and moved up the corporate ladder. My daughter had now started complaining of the discomfort in the back seat on out of town trips and switching the AC off (for power) in Mumbai’s bumper to bumper traffic and inclines in hot-humid weather was getting tiresome for me. But the bond between man and faithful machine takes time to break. I resisted for eight months, begged my wife to learn driving so that I could still have an excuse to retain my Silver Dart as a second car. But my wife’s reluctance to drive in Mumbai and parking space constraints forced the decision – there was no way I would park her on the road and let the dogs piss on her or the urchins scrawl on her impeccably maintained body. She had to go.
But which car would I choose to replace my Silver Dart ? It had to be a hatchback, I couldn’t afford a ‘proper’ sedan. Lower end sedans in the market are just hatches with a boot. Moreover, it never made sense to me – lugging extra weight in the form of a boot you’d rarely use. I had to think about parking space too.
My daily commute is about sixty kilometers with some trips to Pune thrown in. I love to drive and wanted to go on occasional longer trips but the Maruti 800 isn’t exactly the most comfortable car to do a Mumbai to Goa trip. So diesel seemed sensible option.
My requirements were comfort, space, fuel efficiency, reliable performance and reasonable *** and network and ABS was a must have on Mumbai’s slippery monsoon roads.
After a lot of surfing, reading reviews on Team BHP and I shortlisted the Maruti Swift VDI ABS, Ford Figo Diesel Titanium and the Indica Vista Quadrajet Aura ABS – the Punto Diesel was beyond my budget.
I test drove the Vista QJD first. True to what members on Team BHP had described, the space was humongous, comfort was great, looks not so great, fit and finish disappointing. The ICE was pretty bad. I’d read on this forum that the boot space is too small – actually I thought it was pretty decent, comparable to the swift – enough for a family of three and an extra passenger. I think four large soft bags would fit in – that’s not too bad. The engine seemed refined enough and the damping quite good. I’d also seen on the Manza what a breathtaking difference a tuning kit would make to the performance of this engine.
I moved on to the Swift VDI ABS and was immediately put off by the uncomfortable seats, including the drivers seat. Leg space in the rear is terrible. The engine however feels quite peppy. The suspension is too hard for my liking and the car I test drove was old and had the classic Maruti rattle of body parts. I think they should copyright the rattle..my 3.5 years old Maruti 800 produced the same rattling sound. The swift was quickly off my list ( but I must add that the petrol swift I test drove –just for kicks – has a great engine – very very impressed).
Next on the list was the Ford Figo Diesel Titanium. A very good package. Looks good, decent space, good pick up. The diesel engine felt a little noisy and much less refined than the Fiat QJD in the Swift and the Vista. My hunch is that the aged Figo Diesel engine is a stop gap arrangement – borrowed from the Fiesta. I’ll bet they will replace the engine shortly. Was also disappointed they have the ABS only in the top end Titanium.
For their *** and network and my previous experience with a Maruti 800, I would have blindly gone for a Maruti-Suzuki but they didn’t have a suitable product. Tata scored over Ford on this count. Ford have announced that they’ll expand their network, but I reckon it won’t happen that soon. I wouldn’t want to be stuck somewhere on the west coast with no Ford support for hundreds of miles.
Tata’s notoriety on the bad *** and build quality front was nagging me incessantly, but they scored over Ford on service network. A few friends who drive Tata vehicles assured me the quality has improved. The Vista QJD ABS had the best package on offer in that price range. The only negative for Tata was the perception of bad ***. I am not very much into ‘image’ – I just stick to hard facts. I’ve heard snide remarks against the Tata “Chee – Taxi”. I have only one answer for these people. If you’re looking to flaunt your money do it properly – with a Toyota Camry or Skoda Superb at least. If you can’t afford that, at least don’t try to “show off” your economy sedans as is they were worth flaunting.
The substantial difference between the price of the Ford Figo Titanium and the Indica Vista QJD Aura ABS in Mumbai (including discounts) is about sixty four thousand rupees. I calculated that as about two years worth of Diesel..too good to ignore. That was probably the clincher. If Ford officials are reading this, I’d like to say I’d have gone for the Ford Figo if they had the ABS in the lower versions – safety should be affordable and not a luxury.
So I decided to take a leap of faith and opt for the Indica Vista QJD Aura ABS and booked it (silver again. My wife and kid gave me a wide choice; any colour as long as it is silver). I’ve parted with my beloved Maruti 800 after driving her back to Hyderabad where she was registered ( posted in the Travelogue section “Mumbai to Hyderabad in a Maruti 800”). I’ll miss her.
Just got delivery of the Vista from Wasan Motors-Borivli. Looking forward to a new love affair with my Vista Aura ABS.
I recalled a few lines from the song ‘Clementine’ – “How I missed her, how I missed her, how I missed my Clementine ; so I kissed her little sister and forgot my Clementine”.
Initial ownership report and photos will follow shortly.
Last edited by bblost : 23rd April 2010 at 12:39.
Reason: Font Tags Removed, Please do not copy paste from any editor except notepad. Thanks
|