Quote:
Originally Posted by pgsagar Nice thread, Altimaed. For the benefit of readers here, I would request you to share your experience, positive or negative, with AMT gearbox. Because, we have a thread here running concurrently over Maruti AMT woes. Going by your thread, I'm sure you had no issues with AMT at any point during your trip. It's just as well, too, because Dzire diesel has good torque and therefore, I'm sure you experienced none of the issues which some of the Alto/Celerio AMT users had. Then again, it helps to get some feed back from actual user. I'm contemplating buying a Nexon or TUV300 AMT myself and needless to say your views would be much appreciated. And, I'm sure there are many out there like me weighing AMT options. |
Sir, having driven automatic transmission vehicles in the Middle East (the entire range of Nissans (excluding the GTR), since I was working for a Nissan Retail Company), having been allotted Nissan Sunny (the only manual transmission car I used there), followed by Nissan Tiiida, Renault Safrane and Nissan Altima for my use, over the years, I honestly realized how comfortable an AT was, over an MT.
The Tiida and Safrane were the conventional torque converter box. People may tend agree to agree or not but when shifting from an MT to an AT (torque converter), one has to change ones driving style and it takes a couple of kms / weeks to perfectly make that gearbox work in harmony with the pressure applied by the right foot.
The very same thing applies when one moves to a CVT. Once has to learn the way the CVT responds to the right foot, which definitely is different as compared to a slush transmission.
When I repatriated to India in 2006, circumstances made me settle down at Kolkata (though I am from Delhi), I knew it was automatic for me. Also it had to be diesel as I intended to a lot of long distance travelling. On evaluating my usage pattern, I realized that I shall be driving bumper to bumper for 3 to 4 months and then that one long distance drive, which again froze the automatic intent.
We are a family of three, my wife, myself and my 3 and a half year old son. I am 6 feet one and a half inch tall with a built that shows I am a hard core foodie.
Went to the VW showroom to take a test drive of the Vento. Tried my level best to squeeze into driver's seat with some embarrassing body movements, managed but if I have to do this three to four times a day, not at all a pleasing experience. Loved the DSG (a first for me), loved the power, yes this is my car, but no, hang on, I have to come out of the driver's seat, which was again a coordinated body movement which could be avoided if I wanted to be in my comfort zone. I told the 'very enthusiastic sales person', this is the car for me provided I can get in and out of it comfortably, to which he replied 'Sir, once you buy the Vento, in a day or two, you shall develop the skill on how to enter and exit the car', I was like
Took three test drives of the Dzire AMT. I reiterate the fact here, one has to has to adapt to the way the AMT behaves. Getting in and out of the Dzire was a breeze. Price well within budget, MUL service backup, meets my usage requirement, took the plunge.
Apart from 'head nodding' during heaving acceleration, that only from gear 1 to 2 to 3 I have not seen any other disadvantage. In city driving, head nod is observed, but within acceptable limits. The only time I had to use the manual mode is when I was going uphill the downhill the Kailashgiri (Vizaq) road.
I have not yet taken my Dzire to the hills, so cannot comment on its behavior in those conditions.
Must mention, on a recent 325 kms round trip, for the first 150 kms the MID showed 29.2 kmpl.
Car purchase date 14th July 2016, done 22356 kms as on date.