Guys, I finally managed a visit to Driven to get the matter investigated and resolved, but let me respond to some of the things shared on the thread.
Quote:
Originally Posted by low_bass_makker Try any other HU simple !!!!! |
Quote:
Originally Posted by montyguru +1. yeah, its so much simpler. there's a slightly used alpine HU on standby booked by me at driven, ask them to use it and test it out. |
@LBM/Montyguru - Thanks for the advice, I spoke to the guys at driven and they were cool to experiment. While this was an option to confirm if the Titans exhibit some mid bass, the answer in either case wouldnt have helped as much. I wasnt keen on changing the HU for a simple reason it offers damn VFM and for sure drives the rear coax very well. Nothing really to complain about other than front mid bass aberration !
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gilead ...None of the setups were lacking in bass. Sub or mid. I have never heard it powering component speakers on its own so I don't know how it would sound there. |
Gilead ! Yes with an amp, its so easy.. isn't it ?! I don't think I know anyone who has ever tried running the 'Titans' without the amp. But I don't have one and am not yet convinced if one needs it as a mandatory item to drive the front components. I dont think the HU drives them any differently from
the rear speakers in terms of power output from the HU. If the rear works well with the same HU without the amp, so should the front (assuming
we give it proper damping), unless someone here presents a contrapunto to this.
------------------
So I visited Driven this yesterday afternoon after confirming with Gunbir. As the first thing on the list, we got the damping (Stinger) done to the front two doors. The plan was to try and check if damping helps improve matters, if not we'd try out other things. Well the damping didnt quite do any wonders to the mid bass output apart from providing a proper enclosure. It was at best a wee bit of improvement on the existing . Next thing we tried was a change in HU, another brand new kenny (7016) just to check if my particular set (8016) had a problem with mid bass (check for an
isolated case). Well the results with 7016 weren't any different. So hence proved, nothing wrong or out of place with my individual head unit.
Next on our agenda was to try out a different set of front components, with my HU. So we tried Digital Design (CS 6.5) and we immediately
found some serious mid bass with the 8016. I must add here, the damping made a difference to the whole mid bass experience once we found it with
the DD's. The initial impression of the DD's was that high's sounded a bit harsh, but after some expert tuning on the HU by Gunbir, it sounded
damn nice real clean, much...much better! So I spent the next half an hour trying out different songs /settings to see what I like and dislike in DD's.
So I chose DD's over Titans, for a simple reason work pretty well with 8016 and I don't need an amplifier immediately to experience decent mid bass, good clarity and detail, which is the original requirement for initial ICE! I completely understand, when somebody says "get an amplifier!" i.e. to experience the full range that front components tend to offer. I can hopefully now look to wait up, save some, audition a few new and used amplifiers before I make up my mind on the very equipment that I want.
Things we didn't try out:
1. Change the HU to an Alpine or Pioneer
- Well to be honest, the only purpose it would have served is to check whether the Titan are working fine or not. The approach wouldn't have solved my problem of finding front midbass with the current HU, since I am not keen on changing the HU as it is a good vfm HU, does most things right. Infact, I don't know of a better HU, which offers as many features/functionality in sub 20K category.
2. Try putting in the amp to experience mid bass from front components
- It would have been our next step if we would'nt have found mid bass even with DD's.
Some prima facie learnings/observations from the experience:
- Kenwood 8016 doesn't lack mid bass... Period! I think it is pretty significant to be noticed with the right setup/settings. There could be other HU's from Alpine/Pioneer which may offer better midbass experience on just the HU, but that doesnt take anything away from kenwood.
- Kenwood 8016 + Titans - Don't work as well, atleast the combination didn't work for me ! I'm not sure of the exact reasons, considering there's nothing wrong with both HU or the Titans. Is it that Kenwood doesn't
throw enough power for the Titans or is it that Titans have a serious
power requirement to show real performance ? I'm sure everybody has an opinion..to each his own !
- Kenwood 8016/7016 + Titans + Amplifier - Super mid bass exists ! I have no personal experience with it, but many active users (bhpians) of titans have vouched for it, so for sure Titans give a good mid bass experience.
- Damping surely helps in a big way especially when the setup starts to throw out some serious mid bass even on the base HU i.e. without the amplifier.
- What might work for world at large might not work for you, reasons for this could be many, ranging from a different car, different equipment setup, wires to a degree and personal sound bias/ear for detail.
- The mantra on the forum is audition, audition... audition before you buy! But auditioning it in someone else's car has its limitations. Audition-ing stuff in one's own car is the only way to confirm if a particular item works for you or does not. Audition-ing it in a frd's car is hardly an indicator as to whether it will work for you as well unless the comparison is 'apple to apple' (i.e. same car + same setup and audio equipment configuration spec to spec).
- All in all...different strokes for different folks, even more so in ICE !