Getting into EVs - Mahindra e2o Pplus
In January 2018, I was in the organic retail business. I was naturally attracted towards minimalism and environmental issues, following e-mobility in the US and Europe, Tesla's progress, renewables, sustainability etc. I was on a road trip from Tirupur to Kolhapur to visit many organic farmers in various parts of North Karnataka and South Maharashtra. On that trip, while returning via Bangalore, I decided to buy a used Mahindra e2o for my local use. That was the only EV available at that time. But once we visited the used car dealer, he insisted that I buy a new car instead. I had taken the test-drive, was fully satisfied and booked two new cars in Bangalore for myself and my friend Karthic.
Bangalore to my home was 310 km and the new e2o had a range of only around 110 km. Instead of taking delivery by truck, I decided to drive it all the way. It wouldn't support fast charging. My first charge was after Hosur, at a fuel station. I charged it with a 15A socket for around 5 hours. The second stop was at Alps Hotel, Krishnagiri, where the manager charged me Rs. 2,000 for charging alone and extra for accommodation. I charged it for 7-8 hours. The third charging was near Omalur, in a local workshop where there was no proper earthing and the charger was busted and fried. It was a total flop, but I was happy nothing happened to the car. I arranged a truck and brought the car home safely. I still remember, while I was coming in the truck, I was dreaming that these places where I had tried to charge my EV will be ideal locations for fast chargers in the future for future cars. This experience changed my destiny and it is a different journey altogether as a CPO at present.
Likes
- From February 2018 to May 2023, I had driven 51K km
- In the initial days, I was driving around 110-120 km with a full charge
- It was too good to drive in city and traffic conditions. Enjoyed it very much
- Maintenance cost was very low
Dislikes
- I think there was no suspension in that car. It was too hard. Really bad to drive on bad roads
- Service was too bad and getting spares was a headache
- After 2 years the range dropped quickly. After 5 years of usage, it was practically giving only 70-80 km for a full charge and that too would suddenly stop as if it's below 30%
- Safety standards were low
MG ZS EV 2020
After driving the Mahindra e2o of 2 years, I decided I could drive only EVs and there was no other option. I had to wait and buy. In February 2020, we had 3 new EV models available in the Indian market - Hyundai Kona, Tata Nexon Prime and MG ZS EV. Again, I travelled to Bangalore to test drive all these cars and selected the MG ZS EV. After the Covid lockdowns, I took delivery in October 2020.
- Now after 3 years and one month, I had completed 1,00,000 km
- Maintenance cost so far is Rs. 57,000
- Changed the tyres twice at 45K and 90K km
- True range at the beginning was 270-280 km. Even now there is not much of a drop in range
- SOH is 98.5%
Likes
- Value for money. I bought the top variant for Rs. 23 lakh
- DC charging speed is too good. Nowadays it just needs a 2 x 30 minute top-up charge (while having food breaks) when I am driving from Tirupur to Chennai (460 km)
- Amazing to drive on good highways
- After 3 years, I still feel it's a new car
- Service response is very good
- No issues with DC charging - no bugs/errors (compared to Tata cars)
- Panaramic sunroof - My kids enjoy a lot on drives to hill stations
Dislikes
- Headlights are the worst
- Suspension - wobbling on bad roads is really bad
Nexon EV 2021
In November 2021, I bought a Nexon EV Prime. It was just before the Max was launched. Mostly, this is for local usage and not for driving more than 200 km.
- 55,000 km driven in two years
- Maintenance cost - around Rs. 25,000
- Yet to change tyres. They may last for another 20K km
- True range of 200-220kms
- SOH 96.5%
Likes
- Seating/driving comfort
- Suspension
Dislikes
- Charging speed too slow. AC charging only with 3 kW and DC charging only with 21 kW
TVS iQube 2022
I bought it in February 2022 and it has totally satisfied me so far with no issues. It's mostly used by my father. It's a simple model from a trusted brand. There is no need to research too much for me. I've riden it for 16,000+ km.
Long journeys
My first long journey was in November 2020.
Day one - From Tirupur to Chennai (460km). At that time there was only one fast charger available (in Sangagiri). From Sangagiri to Chennai, it was 370 km and my new ZS can practically give only around 280 km per full charge, if it is driven at around 60-70 km/h, sometimes without the A/C, hypermiling behind a bus or truck. I slow charged it for 3 hours at Aiswarya Bhavan Tindivanam, and reached Chennai comfortably. It was fun compared to today’s charging infra.
Day 2 - Chennai to Bangalore. There were no fast chargers in between. I had to charge at a Relux 7 kW Type 2 charger that was available in Ambur two-wheeler workshop and reached Bangalore. There were Bescom chargers available in Bangalore.
Day 3 - Bangalore to Yediyur to Mysore. There was no issue.
Day 4 - Charged overnight fully using a Type 2 charger available at an MG showroom in Mysore and reached Mangalore. Charged fully at an MG showroom in Mangalore using a fast charger.
Day 5 - Drove from Mangalore to Kozhikode and charged again using a Type 2 charger at an MG showroom overnight in Kozhikode.
Day 6 - From Kozhikode to Tirupur.
That's around 1,700 km and there were hardly any fast chargers at that time.
In the last 3 years, I have driven to almost all parts of Tamil Nadu, Kerala and South Karnataka. I've done a Tirupur - Bangalore - Hubli - Goa - Udupi - Coorg - Tirupur trip with my family and many more long drives. There are plenty of fast chargers available now compared to 2020.
Long journey tips
- Make sure to fully charge at home before you start long trips.
- Don’t forget to take a portable charger.
- Make use of the Plugshare app to plan where to charge. There is a trip planner on the Plugshare website.
- Try to select reliable chargers with amenities. Check the last 10 check-ins.
- Download and top-up the wallet before you start.
- Plan your food breaks while the car is charging (in my case, most of the time, the car will charge quickly and there is no time wasted for charging)
- If you want to charge twice, try to plan for 3 charges with quick top-ups on a long journey. Don’t waste time charging up to 100% at fast chargers. Generally, the charging speed will drop after 80%.
- Don’t go with too low SOC. Rarely, there might be power cuts or a queue on holidays and weekends. There should be enough backup to reach the next charger.
- Elevation also matters. In the hills, you might need 1% for 1 km and downhill, you will get regen. Always try to have a 20% buffer to avoid range anxiety.
- Initiate conversations with fellow EV owners who come to charge and help them by sharing knowledge.
- Try to give ratings for charging stations on Google and Plugshare so that it will be helpful for others.
- Make use of destination charging. For example, if you are staying at a hotel, try to talk to the manager or electrician in advance and ask for a 16A socket to charge overnight. Try to share an image/video of the car charging, using 16A socket.
- Getting RFID or Autocharge features will also help in saving time to initiate charging at fast chargers.
Takeways
- 90% of time, our cars will be charging at home or office. There are plenty of public chargers available in Kerala and Tamil Nadu. So no need to worry about charging. Charging an EV is like charging mobile phones. You can charge anywhere.
- Apart from personal use, all my office two-wheelers and cars are EVs only.
- There will be 8 years of battery warranty and even after that, it is most likely that the battery will last for another 7-8 years. For 12-15 years we can use EVs in my opinion. There will be a negligible drop in range after a few years.
- Drive in Sport mode and enjoy to the fullest. No need to drive without A/C or limiting the driving speed to 60-70 km/h. Driving EVs is really fun. No need to compromise.
- No need to download 100s of apps for charging. You just need Plugshare to plan. Zeon, Tata, Relux and Jio are more than enough if you are in South India.
- With solar power at home and office, my local running costs are negligible.
- Make use of personal tax saving options. If it's in the company's name there is 40% depreciation on EVs.
- Running and service costs are very low. That makes the cost of ownership far lower than ICE cars. I had saved more than Rs. 15 lakh in comparison.
Once EV, always EV