Quote:
Originally Posted by shashank.nk So after a lot of delays and negotiations, my Polo has been sold,well atleast buyer has made a token advance I'm back in the market looking for a new hatchback/hatchback on stilts |
Wonderful news, so the hunt has finally begun! Ironically, exactly a year ago I was in the hot seat and you were in the advisory board when I was deciding on the Swift replacement (I was just going through the previous 5-6 pages and recollecting memories). Roles reversed this year, eh?
.
Quote:
My requirements/usage are:- Car will be used 80%in bangalore traffic,20% on the rare weekend outings typically in and around bangalore
- Need a dynamically sorted car
|
Automatically rules out non-Europeans
. Swift is an exception though.
Quote:
I TD'd many cars now and here are my impressions of the top 3 contenders (hatchbacks): Suzuki Swift
TD car had 25k on the odo Likes:
The only car which can give me a niggle free ownership experience
|
I'm not too sure I agree on that, being a Swift owner for ~7 years. The car is not as niggle-free as the rosy image painted everywhere. I've had quite a few things failing every now and then - brake lights, tail lights, headlight bulbs, horn, power window switches, starting issues and things like that within the first 2-3 years of ownership. Maruti does a lot of penny pinching with its component suppliers, so the component quality has to show up somewhere later given the very low cost of spares. It is just that Maruti spares are cheaper, easily available and fixing the niggles with Maruti A.S.S network is much easier than fixing niggles on European cars and their non-existent/incompetent network. The Swift is no angel otherwise!
The cost-cutting and cheap finish do show their ugly faces sometimes in the form of rattles. The interiors start to rattle in no time (I had rattles from as low as 2k km on the odo with just regular city usage); the interior build quality (in addition to exterior build) is no match for Europeans in terms of durability. Do consider this point about the Swift if you are particular about quality.
Quote:
Fiat Punto 90HP
I have a soft corner for this car despite what all the haters might say, but despite taking 2 TD's I was left very disappointed. Both were 2013 TD cars and had less than 1k on the odo, I know Fiats feel better with more on the odo but how much better really ? I'm not expecting a drastic transformation!
|
Generally they open up as you approach 5k kms on the odometer, both in terms of power delivery and engine refinement.
Quote:
Dislikes- Doesn't feel like its got 90 horses at all,especially in the first 2 gears. My Polo felt much better
- Horrible gear ratios and rubbery gearbox, for a 90HP car I was expecting the engine to be far more relaxed at high speeds. Nada! Its the same as in my Polo,2500 rpm at just 100 km/hr!
|
totally agree with these 2 observations, but with a slight difference of opinion on the first point. The second gear is ok, I don't find anything wrong with 2nd and upwards, but the first gear is way too short - this is what hampers the experience when starting off from low speeds everytime. They ought to have mended the ratios on this car, no 2 ways about that. No hope of any improvement in this regard until the Evo comes out next year.
Shashank, is there a definite date for the launch of the Polo GT TDI?? the speculations and scoops are still in the early stages. Might be a while before that comes out. If they make it 1.5L / 90PS, it may not be as much of a rocket as that 1.6L mill in the Vento. They should really get that same state of tune (105 PS) in the Polo. It will be a blast to drive.
I'm going to confuse the petrolhead in you some more now *winks* - You didn't mention about your preference of fuel. If you're okay with petrol, you could check out the 2 new turbo petrol cars on the block: Polo GT TSI for hatchback option (seems like the best option for you from my view) or Linea T-Jet if you want a manual box and can compromise on the extra long body.
P.S - Personally I would wait for the Ecosport to launch, just to take a look. It does sound like a promising product and will be something different from the current crop of cars.