|
Search this Thread | 23,529 views |
21st March 2024, 10:42 | #1 |
BHPian Join Date: May 2021 Location: Kolkata
Posts: 27
Thanked: 238 Times
| 3rd-gen Honda City Review | Why I think this generation is an absolute gem At the outset, I feel it is imperative to address my biggest apprehension in penning down this review, reminisce, love letter or whatever this turns out to be; primarily that, this is an obsolete effort at writing a review of an arguably obsolete automobile. I mean, what does one say about one of the best-selling cars in India, one that shaped middle-class aspiration like few others; the Kia Seltos of the early 2010s, albeit more fun to drive and soulful, that hasn’t already been said? Secondly, even if someone does err in having their attention grabbed by a random twenty-something-year-old in a quest to live out an auto journalist fantasy to cope with Monday morning blues, is there anything new to be said? We’ve all heard the same tale told and retold to the point of monotony and eventually to the point of it assuming the role of a nostalgia-inducing lyrical of the years gone by, the natural aspirated free-revving engine, in the case of the Type-2 Vtec Honda City, the g16B in the OG baleno, and the k24 in the Honda Accord, among others, being the heroes of these tales. Obviously, with time, forced induction in engines was a wind that was inevitably going to sweep the auto industry, either by appealing to the head with better fuel economy and tax benefits due to smaller capacity motors and better pollution law compliance or by brute force. I mean, if you had 3.5 lakhs to spare, with a couple of lakhs for upkeep, would you pick up a 1.8 turbo-petrol in the Laura or a 1.8 naturally aspirated in the Civic? The larger majority is likely to pick the former. Face it, the double whammy of better fuel economy and better power figures does more than just offset the inability to high-rev the nuts off your engine. The auto industry reacted promptly and in spades, ushering in the age of small turbocharged engines and changing the face of the Indian car scene in less than a decade. Gone are the Palios, the Fiesta 1.6s, and the ladder-on-frame people movers that were more like trucks than cars (they seem to be making a comeback now, though). As much as we speak in our ineffable enthusiast lingo about hard-to-grasp abstractions like soul, character, etc., a feature-loaded vehicle the likes of the Seltos or Kushaq, delivering better fuel economy, more “badi gaadi” feel amongst other things is what most of us would put our money on. And is that such a bad thing? I mean, a 1.4 TGDI Seltos would leave my City biting its dust on the expressway like nobody’s business. The truth is, we were responsible for this. We, car buyers as a larger collective preferred turbo-diesels that offered better low and mid-range performance sans much top-end performance, as in our national engine, the 1.3 multijet from Fiat. And my submission is that this point of distinction is not necessarily a bad thing. The more fierce the competition, the harder marques will try to set themselves apart, and if Mahindra can go from being a crude people-mover maker for rural India to a sophisticated lifestyle-vehicle maker, then the future is not all bleak. Even Force made a valiant effort at pulling a Mahindra with their Gurkha. The truth also is, while dreams and aspirations we must have (I mean, we’re car guys, how else do you obsess over something like a Lancia Delta Integrale given that most of us will never even have the privilege to behold one), the more pragmatic of our priorities in life take over, and this is why I feel that while niche vehicles will continue to exist right alongside cars that serve the primary purpose of carrying our keisters from A to B; cars that could both carry your family and make you smile ear to ear when you finally had the opportunity, to rev-match, downshift, and floor the throttle, however, are a concept relegated to the yesteryears. And I know Lamborghini makes the Urus, Mercedes, the E-class AMG, etc. but they’re not entirely what the large majority of us would deem accessible, and my point here also revolves around fun that is accessible. The common factor amongst all the cars that were considered cars for the enthusiasts in our automotive scene’s nascent years, was the combination of simplicity and fun. I’m not saying that older cars made power accessible to everyone but all the discernible sensations of driving could be experienced. Steerings were hydraulically assisted, kerb weights were low and engines revved freely. Simplicity was of the essence to make these cars marketable to the world at large. So for the enthusiast on a budget, fun behind the wheel was accessible. Only a handful of us end up having the opportunity to experience the vehicles we grew up dreaming about, and even smaller minorities have the pleasure of calling them our own. The truth is that many of us will never end up owning the cars that adorned our bedroom walls as we grew up. Let me ask you this; what brought you closer to the realization of your auto-related aspirations? Was it owning that poster of a Hyuara, a Diablo or an F430 that kept the dreams of someday owning one alive? Or was it a brand new Opel Astra, a Tata Sierra, or a Safari (depending on when you were born), parked in your dubiously affluent uncle’s driveway that you would rather pick? Also, is it the pursuit of the latest, fastest and baddest that characterizes your love for wheels or is it something else? Penned this review about a year before I went for a trip to Italy, and as luck would have it, lo & behold I feel, despite everything that has been said and done, despite the raving reviews and thumping sales, this is, in my humble opinion, an underrated car. These are cars that you just can’t ignore when you step out, they are everywhere. And one of the fallacies of the mind is that it unwittingly confuses commonplace and every day with boring. My point is, that I have never, in all the time that I have spent driving this car, had an instance where redlining it didn’t bring unmatched gratification. When you use the same car for airport runs, hauling groceries, etc, how do you not associate it with the mundanity of everyday chores? This is a car that belongs to a dwindling breed that recalibrates your beliefs around it when that weekend drive does arrive. And not in the “badi gaadi” way either. If the GC is too low for trips to the Himalayas, and the brakes are too poor beyond 120km/h for most people’s ideas of high-speed driving, amongst other things. Why is it then that I continue to have great fun in it? The answer is what follows the rapid climb in revs beyond 4000 rpm that makes you feel like you’re behind the wheel of something special. It lacks in several areas and a 13-year-old car simply cannot offer the convenience of a newer car, but the thing with this car is that it has an uncanny ability to continually grow on you. It has gone from looking like the best thing to have ever graced a Rural UP road to now a simple people mover and yet it still feels remarkable to me. One charming jap juxtaposed with another Somewhere in rural Bihar while traversing from Kolkata to Delhi There are some erudite reviews of this car on this very forum by fellow-bhp-ian(s) that you should look at instead if a sense of objectivity is what you’re after since an attempt at trying to reproduce the same information with a similar degree of objectivity will be futile, especially since this car represents my starting point with cars. It will always be the baseline of my expectations due to my years of memories with the car. Redlining it, sneaking it out of the house to take friends out on drives, can’t be put into words with any real efficacy anyway Yet, as one does with most irreconcilable desires, I will attempt regardless and share my perspective. What I like:
What I can live with:
What I don’t like:
Uncle Dear with his discerning eye for detail making sure the Cowl is bolted in properly post-cleaning The part that’s not incessant, unsolicited opinions? The engine is the star of the show, it doesn’t shove you in your seat since there is never a sharp spike in power delivery across the rev range. But the linear rise in revs as the exhaust starts to sound throatier will delight the driver in you. The rev-limiter cuts off the fuel supply sharply and doesn’t allow throttle input until it drops down to lower rpms when you push too far. The steering is well calibrated, heavier than EPS(s) in new cars but not cumbersome still. It doesn’t have the feedback you may expect from an otherwise rewarding experience, but it is predictable and the linearity of how much the wheel turns based on degrees of steering input is reassuring. It does have a proclivity to understeer if thrown into a bend with aggression, but it duly communicates its inability to carry your expected pace in advance. So there are no dirty surprises when driving spiritedly. It’s also very easy to drive, the dimensions are short by today’s standards and it never feels unwieldy. Controls are light and ergonomically the vehicle is s-o-r-t-e-d, so everything falls at hand intuitively. The NVH is far from exceptional, tyre noise is fairly audible in the cabin and the windows feel thinner than the Corolla Altis letting in ambient sounds. (perhaps, an unfair comparison, but my next best standard, regardless) Another area where the car leaves an impression is its looks, it carries a mix of curves and some aggressive straight lines that are uninterrupted from one end of the car to the other. This is an example of a design that is diametrically opposed to a Gen 2 Hyundai Creta, for instance (A vehicle that also commands a sweet niche in the market, perhaps also comparable in sales price after adjustment for inflation), in terms of the sheer number of design elements. I believe this car belongs to that era where automotive companies were nailing the judgment between restraint and excess in car design. But this is very subjective and a matter of personal preference. She recently went for a mid-life makeover at an FNG that turned out not so friendly, but then again, such is life. On the mechanical front, the gearbox fluid has been replaced, a new clutch with clutch release bearing has been put in, the lower suspension arms are new, and the brake system has been bled and new oil has been put in. The rear suspension has been replaced and the front suspension was replaced only 20,000 km. ago. About half the car’s panels had scratches on them and have been painted over, the clear coat has been fixed across the vehicle and new leather upholstery has been installed. However, just as a word of caution, I would steer clear of Classic Auto in Noida, sure they may be good at their mainstay (I wouldn’t know), putting brand new upgrade components on off-roaders which is a simple task comprising of taking off a few nuts and bolts and putting in a replacement, but for all the messy tasks where the elbow grease to monies ratio doesn’t sit kindly with them, expect cut corners and sales tactic that behoove a Karol Bagh salesman more than it does a large, professional-seeming concern. It has also been a pain to find a garage for my car in Delhi-NCR after having been used to the professional standard of work at Alok Automobiles in Kolkata, most that I’ve been to, thus far, feel like they’re built with a get rich quick mindset. Suman da with no qualms about getting his hands dirty washing the car post service. The 1.5 liter SOHC 16 valve i-VTEC heart of the matter. Note the steering trim piece that broke in the process of tucking in the leather, of course, the garage of course could do no wrong, however. Conclusion My experience with the car hasn’t just been pleasant just because of its ability to feel fast. It has been a car that has stuck through stints across the country all while accommodating a family through all its errands, highway runs, school and office commutes. This may not be an impressive number to the cross-country drivers here, but the car has been stationed in Chennai, Mumbai, Lucknow, Delhi, and Kolkata through the years and not all of them offer similar road conditions. The fact that it wasn’t trips but rather operating in and out of different roads, weather, humidity, and traffic conditions with inviolable reliability is what impresses me. It is also the second car I ever drove after learning in a Mahindra Bolero. It has taken me to half marathons, training, and internships at different offices. It became a part of my day, a reliable friend that would never falter. When there was uncertainty in other areas of life, this one could always be counted on And that’s not something that shorter ownership periods can ever offer. Considering everything though the car has been a pleasure to own and maintain. For folks contemplating retaining their older cars, I implore you to pay heed to that thought. The way the relevant policy seems to be shaping up, we might end up with an entire generation of cars wiped out like the Contessa, Corsas, Daewoos, and Mondeo already have. Some people must retain the cars of their years. Car culture seems to value certain niches more than others; Exotics, German Yountimers, and Beetles will find their homes, but the Safari Dicor Petrol and the Chevrolet Forester may just perish, for instance. Of course, whether every car is worth saving is a whole different conversation. (I’d say, yes!) Between the environmental impact of large-scale factory production of new automobiles and the fact that a 2.2 BS6 diesel engine will always emit more Nitrogen Dioxide than a 1.5 BS4 petrol engine, it also objectively makes sense considering the environmental footprint involved. Don’t even get me started on EV(s) with lithium-ion batteries that do less for the environment than I would care to elaborate upon. In a world that follows trends and enjoys consumerism, my humble submission is that some people should take it upon themselves to hold on to the cars of their years. As you may have guessed, I have no intention of ever letting go of this car, from here to infinity. |
(68) Thanks |
The following 68 BHPians Thank brohanv for this useful post: | 2nd_gear_7krpm, abtyagi, aerohit, AlphaKiloPapa, amitabhr, anandhsub, Aravind_M92, arjpillai, avisidhu, Bimmerhead557, BLACNWYTE, Boo, catchjyoti, CentreOfGravity, chinmaypillay, DicKy, Doge, evil_grin, fawad0222, FlashMustang, GaryTSI, GForceEnjoyer, govindremesh, GTO, Herschey, HumbleBee, IamNikhil, InControl, iSubham, libranof1987, lordrayden, lxskllr, mk600, mohitchalla, MotorDev, NarediAni7518, nikipedia87, Pete_EV, PrasunBannerjee, pritanshchandra, rajvardhanraje, ringsoftime, RJ2285, ronythomas, sainyamk95, sanjayrozario, shancz, shishir333, Shreyans_Jain, SILVER-ARROW, speedfreak92, sri_tesla, swe.desi, TurboCruiser, UD17, Uqaab, vattyboy, vb-saan, VigKed, vigsom, visionrider, vivek_saha1304, Voodooblaster, Vsh06, VTec_KickedInYo, W140SKlasse, Yash390, yoshimitsu |
|
21st March 2024, 11:28 | #2 |
Team-BHP Support | Re: 3rd-gen Honda City Review | Why I think this generation is an absolute gem Thread moved from the Assembly Line to the Reviews section. Thanks for sharing! Going to our homepage tomorrow |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks GTO for this useful post: | TurboCruiser |
21st March 2024, 14:36 | #3 | |
Senior - BHPian Join Date: Feb 2011 Location: On-board JWST
Posts: 1,377
Thanked: 4,134 Times
| Re: 3rd-gen Honda City Review | Why I think this generation is an absolute gem Quote:
On few occasions, I got to drive this beauty and can relate to your joy in those years. The style, the power, the refinement, the dynamics . And a testament why next generations of this marvelous creation couldn't carry on the legacy. | |
(2) Thanks |
The following 2 BHPians Thank AutoNoob for this useful post: | arunavshekhar, VTec_KickedInYo |
21st March 2024, 23:21 | #4 |
BHPian | Re: 3rd-gen Honda City Review | Why I think this generation is an absolute gem Nice review and mostly agree...But I would say the 4th Gen Honda city especially in it's facelifted avatar would take the title over the 3rd Gen in a tough matchup and easily over the 5th Gen on the roads now 1. 4th Gen is a out and out looker all around and on any side you look at. 2. Driving dynamics is better. Very sharp purposeful and sure footed than the 3rd Gen. I have taken emergency brakes at high speed thrice to avoid cattle and sudden truck movements on highways...it has braked predictably with negligible nose dive and as much power as the drums at rear could manage. 3. The Car had the basics in place wrt to Twin airbags,ABS, Rear AC vents, Machin cut alloys and decent sound system 4. Available for under 10L in the manual V variant till the time it was discontinued...a fantastic VFM considering this was in 2023 when even a Alto 800 or Wagon R was priced ridiculously near touching distance of this range with gimmicky features |
(4) Thanks |
The following 4 BHPians Thank venbas for this useful post: | InControl, sri_tesla, visionrider, vsrivatsa |
22nd March 2024, 18:45 | #5 |
BHPian Join Date: Jan 2021 Location: Mumbai
Posts: 506
Thanked: 1,281 Times
| Re: 3rd-gen Honda City Review | Why I think this generation is an absolute gem A close friend of mine still owns this generation of the car albeit the facelifted one. So far in his 11 years of ownership he has put 1.93L Kms on the Odometer and trust me if it weren’t for the reading you wouldn’t even know that the car has run so much. The silky smooth CVT and great rear seat comfort helps the car’s characteristic as a mile cruncher. It is a purist’s car that checks all the right boxes. Even as per 2024 standards, the car has everything that one NEEDS, really miss this generation of cars! While cars have improved greatly since then, so have their prices. Back in the day, the common man could think about buying a city by saving a bit and stretching their loan amount a bit, these days similar segment cars have become almost 2x-2.5x in price. Thanks for this piece of nostalgia! |
(4) Thanks |
The following 4 BHPians Thank AKSarkar1 for this useful post: | arunavshekhar, FlashMustang, ronythomas, VTec_KickedInYo |
23rd March 2024, 01:47 | #6 |
Newbie Join Date: Jun 2023 Location: Bangalore
Posts: 10
Thanked: 24 Times
| Re: 3rd-gen Honda City Review | Why I think this generation is an absolute gem One of the best cars Honda India ever made. The car was aspirational when it was launched. I was 10 years old when we got this beauty home. I learnt driving, my younger brother learnt driving an still she runs like a charm. Even at 1.1 lakh odd kms and 15 odd years old the joy that this car gives while driving it is unmatched. Your car looks impeccable. Please do make a post on the maintenance aspects over the years if time permits. |
() Thanks |
23rd March 2024, 16:23 | #7 | ||||
BHPian Join Date: May 2021 Location: Kolkata
Posts: 27
Thanked: 238 Times
| Re: 3rd-gen Honda City Review | Why I think this generation is an absolute gem Quote:
1. Looks are a subjective matter. I believe the 3rd generation is the most proportionate looking of the lot and now the 5th generation. The 4th generation lacks a sense of Honda design individuality and is slightly overdone. The facelift looks better, however. 2. The suspension setup felt better in terms of suppleness, but the braking power upgrade isn't commensurate to the fact that this car was a brand-new generation. It also experiences nosedive upon braking, however, marginally less relative to the GM3. 3. The GM3 only lacked rear AC vents from this list which was a necessary upgrade. IMO the 5-spoke alloys of the pre-facelift GM3 are much prettier than the 4th Gen. Also, the 4th gen just like other generations has wheels and tyres that don't adequately fill in the wheel wells, this was somehow visually exacerbated in the 4th generation. There are two facelifted 4th generation Honda City(s) in my extended family. One is even in the last picture of the review. This is a purely subjective matter and I concede to your right to pick a favorite, but I found the 4th generation the least desirable of the lot. It diluted the City brand, it lacks that Honda design flair in terms of visual appeal and interiors. It is the most prone to squeaks and rattles of any of the Honda City(s). And the steering feel is nowhere as communicative. Put simply, a sense of permanence that one got from the older lot of Hondas, died a quick death with this generation of the City. Quote:
Quote:
One important thing to check is whether your airbags have been replaced under the recall. Because they will merrily shoot metal shrapnel into your face in case of deployment otherwise. The US Justice Department even imposed a hefty penalty on Takata, Honda's airbag vendor. Quote:
Ah, this is all too relatable. My car's RTO of registration is also refusing to renew registrations upon expiry. Have banged my head against the wall in this regard, but there really is nothing you or I can do. | ||||
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks brohanv for this useful post: | nikipedia87 |
23rd March 2024, 19:14 | #8 |
Newbie Join Date: Jul 2022 Location: Bengaluru
Posts: 20
Thanked: 28 Times
| Re: 3rd-gen Honda City Review | Why I think this generation is an absolute gem Lovely post. I have 5th Gen city and love revving the engine, chassis manners are great, it is just the suspensions which need some tweaking. 3rd Gen City is my favorite City though |
(2) Thanks |
The following 2 BHPians Thank Lokesh Soni for this useful post: | brohanv, nikipedia87 |
24th March 2024, 08:07 | #9 |
BHPian Join Date: Jan 2020 Location: Hyderabad
Posts: 294
Thanked: 973 Times
| Re: 3rd-gen Honda City Review | Why I think this generation is an absolute gem
Get the AC checked by an FNG. The service center doesn't do AC checks properly. Most likely the radiator has dust on it that needs washing and the coolant needs to be refilled. That's what had happened to my city. After doing that it chills phenomenally. |
() Thanks |
28th March 2024, 06:21 | #10 |
BHPian Join Date: Apr 2013 Location: Mumbai
Posts: 29
Thanked: 80 Times
| Re: 3rd-gen Honda City Review | Why I think this generation is an absolute gem 👍🏻👍🏻 Shifted to a Creta and still sorely miss my Honda city after 4-5 months ! Working up the courage to sell off Creta at a loss and get a city again. Or even elevate. Toyota somehow keeps launching Maruti siblings in the 15-18 range else that could have worked too. Though the previous Creta looks pretty good to me with the alien futuristic design and isn't bad really, it doesn't really connect to you like the Honda City or Civic did. Completely inexplicable why. Maybe I just like sedans and not SUVs like I thought |
(2) Thanks |
The following 2 BHPians Thank amitabhr for this useful post: | GreenmachinE, nikipedia87 |
28th March 2024, 12:24 | #11 |
BHPian Join Date: Oct 2010 Location: Mumbai
Posts: 233
Thanked: 1,309 Times
| Re: 3rd-gen Honda City Review | Why I think this generation is an absolute gem Warms the cockles of the heart of the old product guy who was the Project Leader for your City. You truly love the car and it shows. To be fair I had fought and lost for 1) Better GC 2) Better rear brakes 3) Fatter tyres. Your lovely review is a wonderful homage to the work of those faceless, nameless people who had worked passionately to make this car what it is (and what it is not). |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks Ferruccio for this useful post: | W140SKlasse |
|