350Z vs Cayman vs RS4

EVO6 · 13th February 2006, 19:55

I have voted for a Porsche...
Well the RS4 maybe a better option but then is it a pratical car as Audi India might not be able to service it...
The Porsche Cayman in that sense wud be a better buy...
Cant choose the Zeeeee as it cannot be homologated... But there is an option... By increasing its value by adding options and if u can bring the value to over $40000 then by god That wud be the first choice but then again we have to think about the biggest factor... WE ARE IN INDIA... When asked the Mumbai Nissan Dealer about the Zeeee, he had no comments.. not even any info whether they will bring it in... And most Xtrail guyz suffering with service issues...
So taking all this into consideration... Porsche wud be a hassle free investment...
Cheers

Aditya · 13th February 2006, 20:43

Porsche Cayman all the way! It's got pace, engineering and the best German badge.
I like the Audi RS4 too. But, a saloon is not as exclusive as a coupe.
Nissan 350Z - Cheapest of the lot, good for modifications. What do I think of it? You don't wanna know.

aah78 · 14th February 2006, 00:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vikas Mawandia

we want to posses all the gud brands in da world if that is possible someday...

and all the best to you in that venture....

anyways, so as you're still a student i'm assuming the car you buy is not going to be used as a family car but as your personal freak-out machine.
if i'm following you so far, then i'd advice you to go in for the Porsche Cayman followed closely by the Audi RS4 (just incase you feel like including a couple of your friends for a drive).
wouldn't recommend the Nissan 350Z. it isn't such a good car - though price-wise its your best option.

View Poll Results: Which is better value and will give great driving pleasure ?
Nissan 350Z	12	23.08%
Porsche Cayman	23	44.23%
Audi RS4 (2006)	17	32.69%
Voters: 52. You may not vote on this poll

13th February 2006, 19:55	#31
EVO6 BHPian Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Pune Posts: 488 Thanked: 13 Times	I have voted for a Porsche... Well the RS4 maybe a better option but then is it a pratical car as Audi India might not be able to service it... The Porsche Cayman in that sense wud be a better buy... Cant choose the Zeeeee as it cannot be homologated... But there is an option... By increasing its value by adding options and if u can bring the value to over $40000 then by god That wud be the first choice but then again we have to think about the biggest factor... WE ARE IN INDIA... When asked the Mumbai Nissan Dealer about the Zeeee, he had no comments.. not even any info whether they will bring it in... And most Xtrail guyz suffering with service issues... So taking all this into consideration... Porsche wud be a hassle free investment... Cheers
	() Thanks

13th February 2006, 20:43	#32
Aditya Team-BHP Support Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Mumbai Posts: 18,784 Thanked: 81,154 Times View My Garage	Porsche Cayman all the way! It's got pace, engineering and the best German badge. I like the Audi RS4 too. But, a saloon is not as exclusive as a coupe. Nissan 350Z - Cheapest of the lot, good for modifications. What do I think of it? You don't wanna know. Last edited by Aditya : 15th February 2006 at 07:53.
	() Thanks