Quote:
Originally Posted by brutus Well, i have a different opinion about that. A few years back, a spitfire 9 was found in a riverbed near Chandigarh. The Air-force took to restoring it, and the way they did it made it look like some Circus contraption rather than a real plane. Just like any Vintage car, it better if these things land up in the hands of people who who thier jobs, and are going to keep it well, even if it mean it going abroad. The Air-force is going to do nothing but keep it as trophies outside their gates, like they did with them earlier. Infact they already have a Airworthy Spitfire 9 and Spitfire 18 at Palam, and they too have been lying rejected for some time now.
Bikram |
We are saying a very similar thing. When I say that we do not care for our heritage, I do not mean you and me as individuals but the attitude of the authorities, be it a ministry or an organisation in General. But I do not agree that it is better to send an item out of India even if we do not maintain/restore these properly. Just a couple of days ago there was a
news item that a sandstone slab at the Taj Mahal in Agra fell off. Do we now allow the Taj to be sent out of India for better maintainance? Surely not.
Basically none of the authorities or ministries bother about heritage. Be it the armed forces, or the Railways, or the ministries. Even attempt or rather seemingly attempts made for heritage are half hearted. Attached is a news article which appeared in the Indian Express 24th December
Mumbai edition. How nice, Gujrat Police is to create a museum. But even the newspaper editor is at fault for wasting Newsprint like this. There are no contact details. The purpose of such a news item should be to encourage people to contribute. I have several photographs of a Jeep with BMC registration on which it says 'PILOT" and "AHMEDABAD POLICE". I would be more than willing to make a small contribution by making a framed collage of these photos, about 6 of them which they could hang on a wall. And it is interesting, the registration is not only of Bombay State but it is also a Bombay number. This photo came out of a big lot which I purchased from Chor Bazar. It came out from Police 'Katchra' and is so interesting in content, there are prohibition boats,Police Land Rovers ( I never knew that they had these),Amphibian trucks used in Police
action in Goa, laying of foundation stones, police motor workshops etc. This should have been preserved by them, but they sold the whole lot to a "ferrywallah".
Similarly I saved the International Woody station wagon formerly owned by the railways. The railways could easily collect more artifacts for their rail museum and have sub museums all over India. But just have a look at the Mysore museum, you will be disgusted. Clocks without movements, rusty wagons exposed to the elements etc.
Then there is the Army Museum in Ahmednagar. They have a Rolls Royce armoured car.Very rare, I believe just 3 to 4 survive in the world. And it is kept in the open along with other stuff like tanks.See Railway stations in smaller towns. There are many which have nice steam engines kept out in the open. They just deteriorate as they are left out to rot, giving an annual thick coat of ugly paint does not preserve these things.
Then go to Nehru Science Centre in Mumbai. What a bunch of Jokers. They have 2 engines, one of the first electric railway engines and not
preserved. They had been given the Mazagaon Docks steam truck, it was taken back after it was allowed to get dilapidated. They were presented a Sentinel Steam truck restored by Telco apprentices, fitted with new tyres. A pedestal was made and it was kept out in the open. And you know how far the Science Centre is away from the sea and the 'Nullah'. And we can go on.
One more personal note. I live on Laburnum Road, famous for Mani Bhavan where Mahatma Gandhi lived and now a Museum. I entered after many years with a tourist friend. I noticed that they were displaying the first set of the Gandhi currency notes in a frame. Rs 1/-, 2/-,5/-,10/- were OK but the Rs 100/- note was a Xerox copy. I had collected a lot and decided to give them one, I felt that a Xerox copy would look stupid. After 1 year when I had another visitor and went there, the xerox copy was still not replaced. "We have to arrange for a carpenter" is what they said. Stupid
uninspired people.
One of the major difficulties Vintage car owners face is with their registration books. Sometimes taxes are due, other times books are lost or unavailable as the owner did not transfer when new replacement series were issued, like BOM to BMW. RTO was supposed to keep the old
records, but now they even do not have the later records. So a special provision was made and a notification was issued to help vintage car owners. This and lifetime tax for Vintage/classic cars were some of the few good initiatives made by the government. But what happened? Only
selected few cars were given this benefit, a Humber, a Ford T, a MG TC, some cars belonging to a high official of VCCCI. So when a fascility was given, few kept this close to their chest, defeating the very purpose. So not only the government, but also the people themselves are responsible for this sad state of affairs. The was another issue about a Museum for Bombay, let someone else tell that story.
But there are collectors, who if given a chance will buy heritage and restore/preserve it. Like Mr. Tarun Takral. He purchased a railway waggon, had to PAY a premium over the scrappers. How ridiculous. He purchsed a plane from a flying club, double dekker bus from a municipality, and all were complicated issues. He persists, but many would not bother to go through all the trouble.
For many collectors it is very difficult to bear expenses for everything. First the artefact, then the restoration and then the housing/display. And public would be denied access in most cases as one cannot welcome visitors to see cars at home. Though some collectors have opened their premises for the public, at their expense. An example where such problems were solved is the Sinnsheim Technical Museum in Germany. This is a group of collectors who run the place. They display their artefacts indoors, maintain them to the extend possible, have fascilities for restoration which members can use, public is allowed to visit by paying an entrance fee which goes into the upkeep. And they also aquire stuff for the Museum which then belongs to the association. So they have the Concorde and the Russian Tupolev Concorde type plane, only place in the world to have both these planes. And Corporates, ministries donate stuff, they have very old machinery which are art objects themselves. And a
lot of World War II stuff.
So Mr. Brutus, we do agree with each other, but I would not like to see the stuff go out of India, as we again cannot import. Maybe if more people become aware some ministry may decide to set up a heritage centre
where even individuals can display their stuff.