Hi,
Frankly you've got three decent choices in the SUV/MUV league in this price budget. 12 Lacs OTR stretch is not saying much, when the original budget itself was about 10 lacs OTR- because unfortunately, the choices are limited in this price range and those SUV type vehicles which will beautifully fit the bill for you are all priced much higher.
For example if you could stretch to about 17-18 lacs then without a doubt I would suggest the Chevy Captiva which is a great SoftRoader with a lovely Diesel engine, the Hyundai Tucson which is another great SoftRoader with a good Crdi Diesel Engine or even the Honda CRV if you dont mind a Petrol engine.
Therefore, in my opinion, your choices are between The Toyota Innova, The Scorpio 2.2 MHAWK, The Safari 2.2 Dicor.
My own recommendation to you is based on the following:
1. Delhi based and driving in busy areas. (Ease of parking, Turning Radius etc will therefore be one criterion.)
2. Ample head room
3. Minimum Maintenance
Given these three points you could consider the following in order of priority:
1.The Toyota Innova is the most "car-like" in terms of handling and is easily the most comfortable of the three for normal city use. Its nose to tail overall length and size could be a disadvantage at times in the city, but it redeems itself admirably by its "car-like" handling. This vehicle is not tacky at all. Reasonably powerful and sufficiently torquey engine for slow crawls in the city in low gear, but such a light car like clutch and gear box, that you will not feel driving fatigue. A good diesel engine, plush and comfy interiors with good headroom for a tall person, Toyota Quality everywhere and with their legendary reliability, you mostly will not encounter troubles in terms of niggles and servicing etc. However, this is more like a VAN type people mover and not really an SUV/ Soft Roader. Its looks are van like. Maintenance is minimal given Toyota's robust quality standards but spare parts are a little expensive, being Toyota. Fuel efficiency will sit at around 10-12 Kmpl in city with AC. After sales service from Toyota is good. Re-sale value of Toyota vehicles is absolutely first class.
2.The Scorpio 2.2 VLS (lower end variant to the VLX) because, though very powerful and big, it has compact proportions and is easy to handle within city areas, it has a good turning radius (5.6metre), a great 2.2 MHawk engine and since it is the lower end variant, does not have all the unnecessary expensive toys that come with the VLX. It is a tough macho looking SUV which is well put together- feels solid. Interiors etc are functional and comfy but do not feel like they have been cheaply put together. Good headroom for a tall person. Powerful and Torquey with a clicky gearbox, this vehicle can chug along in first and second gear with your foot off the accelerator in thick city traffic.This vehicle is excellent and comfy on highways and to really enjoy the engine, one needs to hit the highways and open it up a bit! Mahindra vehicles are generally very reliable, low on maintenance and can be rough used a great deal. Spares also are not expensive. Fuel Efficiency will hover at about 10-11 Kmpl in city with AC. Their after sales service is also good. Re-sale value is usually very good for most Mahindra vehicles.
3.The Safari 2.2 EX Dicor is a very good spacious vehicle and you get lots of electronic and electrical toys and gizmos at a real VFM price but its disadvantage is that it is cumbersome and big, tougher to handle in busy areas in terms of parking, navigating narrow lanes, heavy traffic conditions etc. Also in my opinion, cheap-ish plastics and fiddly bits takeaway to an extent from its appeal. It is however an extremely comfortable vehicle with lots of headroom and a handsome looking SUV. Power and Torque etc are great but it has a squashy mushy gearbox which can be irritating. Some Turbo lag also exists in second gear. Ideally one should do lots of long distance cruising and highway driving to get the most enjoyment out of it. This 2.2 is the latest Tata offering and clearly is their best offering as a Safari variant. However, you could possibly run into niggles and irritants with the reliability of some mechanicals and the electrical/ electronic stuff in this vehicle and frankly Tata Passenger Car/ vehicle After Sales Service is not the best as of now. Fuel efficiency will generally hover around 10-11 Kmpl in city with AC. Re-sale values are not clear on this particular variant because it has been in the market only about 9-10 months, but the earlier Safari's did not enjoy high re-sale values at all.
Without mincing words I would say bluntly that it comes to a straight shootout between the Innova and the Scorpio in this case.
However, bearing in mind your father's daily requirement on his commute, I would heartily recommend the INNOVA if you and he dont mind its "space-wagon" looks -you and he certainly wont regret it. Apart from the above three, I would also say that at a pinch you could even consider the FORD FUSION PLUS 1.4 TDCI Diesel with ABS at Rs 8 lacs odd.
Some Advantages: Diesel with ABS, pretty comfortable headroom,compact proportions, SUV/Station Wagon stance and looks, good ground clearance, Diesel engine, very responsive and easy to handle in the city with good low end torque for those interminable first and second gear bumper to bumper crawls, spacious inside, decent interiors, excellent Fuel efficiencyin city (about 14 Kmpl with AC) and 18-20 Kmpl on highways, relatively low on maintenance unless ill treated consistently.
Some Disadvantages: Ford Service, general cost of spares, relatively high acquisition cost of the vehicle considering its overall size and value package.
I hope this helps you to decide.
However, I would certainly suggest that you test drive all the above and ask your dad to test drive all these himself to see which he is most comfortable with. If possible do a peak hour test drive and another one at low traffic time as well. You'll see the different aspects of the same vehicles better this way.
Cheers and all the best.
Last edited by shankar.balan : 4th July 2008 at 14:55.
Reason: some additional info
|