Which MUV????

harry_jatt · 7th March 2010, 23:47

Kapps

I had a similar budget as u and after a lot of contemplating decided on the xylo E6(seven seater). got the delivery on 5th feb and i must say it was a great decision

. Got free insurance and free extended warranty and after loading it up with alloys, wide tires, double din stereo and component speakers cost me 8.40. As for the last row seating it is the best in class. It has done 4100kms till now, took it on a punjab trip and the comfort is just unbeatable.
If you need any assistance regarding this i'll be happy to help.

Harry.

addyhemmige · 8th March 2010, 10:03

Quote:

Originally Posted by adzegeek

addyhemmige

IMHO, why not Bolero for estate use? and doubling up to the other tasks.

Safari and Scorp will do all three jobs listed, but wont be as rugged as Bolero.

Safari (again my personal opinion before this becomes WW-III) is little less "reliable" than Scorp.

Now, we still haven't decided on what car yet. My dad is leaning towards getting the Linea (which again, I don't like) and buying my uncle's Qualis for estate use. We will dispose of the Sumo. So, no question of buying any MUV/SUV now

k!ng_@thur · 11th March 2010, 17:38

My thought is everyday comfort is most important. A good offroader with decent looks vs the two separately. By that standard, the Safari (even 4x4 if the estate roads get bad during the rains) is probably the best way to go.

KALINGA · 11th March 2010, 19:27

Anyday prefer XYLO over any TATA car.
Now XYLO comes with Airbag and ABS. And no one beat the space it offered in this price range.

if your budget is not a constraints then INNOVA is the best choice.

if you have a limitted budget then XYLO comes after Innova. There are many XYLO ownership thread available.

After all you are buying a car for your family. i suggest you that you should consider the safety first.

XYLO topend model is the best (Feature rich and Safety feature) car with limited budget. If the budget is not limited then you may opt for INNOVA V model.

No idea if TATA GRANDE is offering the ABS and AIRBAG.

scopriobharath · 14th March 2010, 17:26

Go in for a Xylo as a first bet.
Grande is next. It is a Tata so quality would be below Xylo
Tavera is low on maintenance but absolutely zero resale value. Very low on maintenance
Innova If you can really stretch that much

siddharthp · 31st March 2010, 17:55

If your budget is 8 Lacs,you can go with Xylo E4/E6.I will always prefer Xylo over Grande.
Also,you can search for 2nd Hand Innova G4 Model,you may get lucky,(for 2007 model 6.5-7 Lacs is right price).

I had similar requirements in Aug 2009 and started with budget of 7-8 Lacs.I thought of New Xylo,3 year old Innova(70 k on Odo),however finally could not resist temptation of buying Innova GX model for 10.7 on road.I am extremely happy with my decision because of 3 year/1 Lac Kms warranty.

However with your budget,Xylo is also very good option as I stated earlier.

7th March 2010, 23:47	#31
harry_jatt Newbie Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: New Delhi/Noida Posts: 14 Thanked: 0 Times	Kapps I had a similar budget as u and after a lot of contemplating decided on the xylo E6(seven seater). got the delivery on 5th feb and i must say it was a great decision. Got free insurance and free extended warranty and after loading it up with alloys, wide tires, double din stereo and component speakers cost me 8.40. As for the last row seating it is the best in class. It has done 4100kms till now, took it on a punjab trip and the comfort is just unbeatable. If you need any assistance regarding this i'll be happy to help. Harry.
	() Thanks

11th March 2010, 17:38	#33
k!ng_@thur BHPian Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Delhi Posts: 49 Thanked: 0 Times	My thought is everyday comfort is most important. A good offroader with decent looks vs the two separately. By that standard, the Safari (even 4x4 if the estate roads get bad during the rains) is probably the best way to go.
	() Thanks

11th March 2010, 19:27	#34
KALINGA BHPian Join Date: Dec 2009 Location: PUNE Posts: 724 Thanked: 374 Times	Anyday prefer XYLO over any TATA car. Now XYLO comes with Airbag and ABS. And no one beat the space it offered in this price range. if your budget is not a constraints then INNOVA is the best choice. if you have a limitted budget then XYLO comes after Innova. There are many XYLO ownership thread available. After all you are buying a car for your family. i suggest you that you should consider the safety first. XYLO topend model is the best (Feature rich and Safety feature) car with limited budget. If the budget is not limited then you may opt for INNOVA V model. No idea if TATA GRANDE is offering the ABS and AIRBAG.
	() Thanks

14th March 2010, 17:26	#35
scopriobharath Senior - BHPian Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: Chennai Posts: 3,617 Thanked: 1,330 Times	Go in for a Xylo as a first bet. Grande is next. It is a Tata so quality would be below Xylo Tavera is low on maintenance but absolutely zero resale value. Very low on maintenance Innova If you can really stretch that much
	() Thanks

31st March 2010, 17:55	#36
siddharthp BHPian Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: Pune Posts: 78 Thanked: 20 Times View My Garage	If your budget is 8 Lacs,you can go with Xylo E4/E6.I will always prefer Xylo over Grande. Also,you can search for 2nd Hand Innova G4 Model,you may get lucky,(for 2007 model 6.5-7 Lacs is right price). I had similar requirements in Aug 2009 and started with budget of 7-8 Lacs.I thought of New Xylo,3 year old Innova(70 k on Odo),however finally could not resist temptation of buying Innova GX model for 10.7 on road.I am extremely happy with my decision because of 3 year/1 Lac Kms warranty. However with your budget,Xylo is also very good option as I stated earlier.
	() Thanks