Team-BHP > Technical Stuff
Register New Topics New Posts Top Thanked Team-BHP FAQ


Reply
  Search this Thread
12,418 views
Old 17th November 2022, 18:39   #1
Distinguished - BHPian
 
Join Date: Oct 2012
Location: Delhi
Posts: 8,101
Thanked: 50,880 Times
Dealing with Electrical parasite drains

We have quite a number of threads dealing with drained batteries. There are various reasons a battery could become drained. Nearly all cars do drain the battery over time. Modern cars more so than older cars.

The Internet will tell, you for a modern car, the continuous drain with everything shut down is still some 40mA. Personally, I think that is a bit on the low side these days. Irrespective, a battery should not drain to the point where it won’t be able to start the car in a matter of days. Personally, I would become suspicious if I could not leave my car parked for four weeks and find the battery drained.

Recently, I experienced a drained battery on my Jeep. I suspected a possible so called parasite drain. Something, which should not be there, that drains the battery whilst the car is parked.

I investigated the issue in detail and reported it in my “fiddling with car thread”.
https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/diy-d...ml#post5433411

But as I have seen numerous similar problems being reported on the forum, I thought I do a little write up on this phenomen parasite drain. The name suggest it is something you don’t want and it is also sneaky. In Dutch we call it clandestine drain. Different word, but same sentiment. You don’t want it!! Just to be clear, it is a drain over and above the “normal” drain on your battery.

When your car fails to start, first order of business is to determine whether it is actually the battery. Even without any tools it is usually easy to check. If you turn the ignition key on and try to start and nothing happens, not even a click of the starter motor relay (Bendix) it might be the battery. Another easy test is to turn the ignition on and put the headlights on. If they appear dim, or don’t light up at all, chances are you have a drained battery.

If you have a multimeter you could also check the battery voltage. Without the engine running, you should have at least 11,5V, preferably you want it to be well above 12V really. With the voltmeter attached switch on the lights, if the voltage drops considerable, again you might have a drained battery.

When you experience a drained battery, the simplest thing is too jump start the car, using jump leads, booster pack or even just pushing/towing the car and dumping the clutch whilst in gear, usually gets it going. Do check your owner manual on what the procedure is!! Not all cars can be jumpstarted, or even towed.

There is always the possibility that the battery is simply at its end of its useful life. Voltage readings of the battery and during charging give some indications, but to get a proper diagnosis of the state of the battery you need to have a special battery capacity measurement tool.

Of course, if your alternator is not charging properly you will end up with a drained battery. But in nearly all cases you are likely to get a yellow and or red warning light if the battery is not charging properly.

When you experience an unexpected drained battery you might want to check a few simple things first. On modern cars switching the ignition off, will switch of most electrical power to all the various electrical users. Not all, we will talk about that further on. But for instance radio, car external lights and so on tend to switch off, sometimes with a bit of time delay. But you might have inadvertently left something on, that is still powered irrespective of the ignition key position. Think parking lights, think internal cabin light, valet lights, internal light in the dashboard or the light inside the boot!

My Alfa Spider suffered from a drained battery and it was a very simple internal valet light underneath the glove compartment. The light fitting itself is the switch too. Passengers often, inadvertently, switched it permanently on, with their legs. You would never notice, because it had a minuscule bulb. But it was enough to drain the battery in a couple of days!

Glove compartment and boot lights tend to be switched by means of some type of push switch in the door/boot frame. But sometimes they go wonky and again it will be a matter of days before your battery is fully drained. One tiny bulb will do that! Easy to test; put your mobile phone on video, stick it into the glove compartment or boot, close it and open it up after a minute or so. Review the video to check the light goes out when the lid closes!

If you noticed the battery draining unexpectedly after work has been carried out, check carefully all wiring, connectors and so near the spot where the work was carried out.

By far the biggest cause of parasite drains tend to be incorrectly installed aftermarket accessories. On quite a few cars, the cigarette lighter is permanently powered. If you keep a USB charger in there, well... easy guessing!

Before digging in, a few thoughts about multimeters. Because if you want to trace a parasite drain you will need a multimeter capable of measure tiny voltages, tiny and big currents.

You need to be able to measure with a reasonable degree of accuracy too. Multimeters come in analogue and digital versions. The digital ones are not necessarily more accurate. You really need to read the specification for the accuracy. The number of digit it displays is not necessarily an indication of its accuracy and or resolution.

I have a collection of analogue measuring instruments, including this very nice analogue multimeter. Probably fifty years old, still working. Anorak fact: This is a Simpson 260, they have been manufactured from about 1930 and are still in production. The earlier models are very similar to the current ones. Current price is approx $500! It is considered superior to digital multimeters for specific applications.

https://simpsonelectric.com/wp-conte...heets/2608.pdf

Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-img_8903.jpg

But I tend to use a digital multimeter for several reasons. They tend to be more far more robust, important in a workshop. If you drop it, it is more likely to still work properly than an analogue one.

Also, most digital multimeters are simply much more convenient to use. You don’t need to worry about choosing the correct scale so much. Within reason the internals are protected and you just rotate the knob to get the correct reading. Also, it doesn’t matter if you mess up the plus and minus as the display will display + and - as well. Getting your polarity wrong on most analogue meters might damage it!

A word of caution though on the measurement of currents. When you start measuring you might easily find yourself having to deal with 2-6 Amps. That is quite a lot for these multimeters. You do need to make sure you connect the measuring probes correctly for the respective amps. Which is always different from voltage and for instance resistance measurements.

Here you see my multimeter set up for measuring up to 20VDC. Black lead in the common/mass connector and the red lead in the Volt / Ohm connector.

Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-img_8897.jpeg

Here it is set up to measure up to 2 ACA. Note the red lead has moved to the dedicated 2A connector!

Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-img_8898.jpeg

Here it is set up to measure up to 20ACA. Note the red lead has moved to the dedicated 20A connector. Also note the red text right above the connector. Unfused.

Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-img_8899.jpeg

On many digital multimeters the highest current setting is unfused. So you better know what you are doing, or you might blow up, or probably melt down your multimeter!! Also, most of these kind of multimeters are not suitable to measure high amps continuously. Neither the leads/probes and or the internal components can handle it. Anything over a few Amps, you need to disconnect the meter every 30-60 seconds or so.

All digital multimeters will have an internal power source, very often a 9V battery and a fuse. One of the advantages of an analogue meter is they do not require an internal power source to measure voltages or currents. (only for resistance measurement)

Here you see the internalsl of one of my other multimeters. I had to open it us as the internal battery (note the clips in the top right corner) was drained and also the fuse (10A) was blown!

Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-img_8900.jpeg

Just about all cars have some electrical drain when shut down. Even my 40 year old, W123 uses a bit of electricity. The clock and the radio. Most car radio/audio centre are switched by means of the ignition key. But most radio’s / auto centre are also connected directly to a positive terminal. This ensures that all presets in your radio / audio centre remain intact with the engine switched off. But that does require a small, tiny, continuous drain on the battery.

Anybody who has installed aftermarket radio’s in their cars, would be familiar with the typical power supply wiring for a car radio. One black wire minus (mass), one red plus wire (switched), one red plus wire (continuous). (and maybe another wire for the automatic antenna.)

Those of my age will also remember very early radio’s with mechanical presets! Those would have only two wires.

OK, so you have established that you have a drained battery and the suspicion is that it is related to a parasite drain. You have checked the obvious (see above). Now it is time to dig in and take some proper measurements to determine what is causing the parasite drain.

The internet will tell you to simply “pull fuses one by one”, but that might not work on modern cars. In fact on modern cars, pulling fuses might not work at all. Besides, what and where are you measuring. Broadly speaking there are two different approached to finding a parasite drain. By measuring voltage drop across each fuse. Or by measuring current draw in the respective circuits. I will discuss both methods.

In theory the voltage drop measurement is the best. Especially if you have a modern car.

Modern cars have become a bit of a challenge when it comes to finding parasite drains. One might expect that when the car is locked and undisturbed, electrical activity ceases and current drain from the battery drops to (near) zero. Unfortunately, this is not the case. When locked and undisturbed the car is shut down or sleep mode. It will still be drawing a so called quiescent current. On modern cars this quiescent current is required to maintains various on board data (system and control module settings), time, memory settings, and to monitor the Passive anti lock system and alarm module. What is also important to note is that on almost all cars it take a certain amount of time before the car is, from an electrical point of view in this sleep mode.

As an example see this little table about various Jaguars.

Name:  Jaguar quiescent current drain.jpeg
Views: 1147
Size:  28.5 KB

It is important to understand what the normal quiescent drain is, when you try to trace a parasite drain. Because the parasite drain will be on top of it. So the question is really, what is the baseline, how much voltage/current should you have at various points?

An additional challenge is that for instance pulling a fuse, or opening a door, will wake up the car systems.

I did a little test on my Jaguar X308/XJR. Although this car is twenty years old, it has a very complex, elaborate electrical and electronically systems. This car has some 10 fuseboxes and 12 computers, scattered all over the car.

The battery is in the boot. So I hooked up my trusted multimeter to the battery:

Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-img_8887.jpeg

Note the battery quick disconnect installed. My multimeter is attached on both sides of the disconnect. So when I disconnect the battery by turning the green knob, effectively the multimeter is in series with all the electric circuits of the car. All current is flowing through the meter.

Note that the multimeter is showing 3,7Amps!! This is with the boot and the driver door open. After about 15 seconds the current drops to 1,5A. Because I closed the door and the cabin lights dim with a delay. The boot is still open and also has a boot light. After a while that dims too, even though the boot is still open. The current drops to 0,6A. After about 15 minutes the current drops further to about 0,31 A. Another 30 minutes and the current drops to 0,074A (74mA).

It stayed at 74mA, till I shut the boot properly. Have a look:

Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-img_8891.jpeg

This car has a boot open indication on the dashboard. Even with everything shut down, key out of the ignition it keeps monitoring that boot light switch. Only by closing the boot, the current dropped to 0,047 A (47mA).

This is the quiescent current drain of my Jaguar. This car has a Varta G14 95Ah battery. So in theory this quiescent current will drain the battery completely in (95/0,047)/24 = 84 days / 12 weeks. Obviously, it will not be able to start the car in a much shorter period. But simple math will tell you that if you have a parasite drain of only 40mA that will effectively half the time the battery will last. So even a small electrical problem, e.g. a positive wire chaffing and touching the chassis, can cause your battery to drain in a matter of days.

So before you start it is helpful to understand what quiescent current drain your car has. You won’t find it in your owners manual. You do need a proper workshop manual. You also need to understand how to keep the car in sleep mode. Or you might be measuring the wrong things all together.

Here is how car mechanics are/should be taught how to trace a parasite drain:

First you hook up some multimeter that measures the total draw on the battery. In this image (borrowed from the internet) a current clamp. And it shows a current of 1,9 Amps. You need to an initial measurement and then wait for the time period to reach sleep status and take another measurement.


Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-screenshot-20221118-10.20.58-am.png

What you could do is pull each fuse and see if the current drops. However, you might trigger the car out of its sleep mode. An ECU might reset and hide the problem etc.

Better to do the following
You take another multimeter, set to measure mV and start taking readings across each and every fuse.

Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-screenshot-20221118-10.17.44-am.png

These fuses have a known internal resistance. When current is passed through the respective fuse, there will be a voltage drop or rather differential. The voltage differential is a measure for the current through the fuse. You can look up the current value in these sort of tables.

Name:  Fuse Voltage drop.jpeg
Views: 1143
Size:  110.9 KB

There are different kind of tables available for different kind of fuses. You can find them, for free, on the internet. Just search for blade fuse voltage drop.

So you are looking for unexpected high values, above the quiescent drain. You might have to check all the fuses, because you need to get an image on how the total current is divided across the respective circuits.

Once you are able to establish the respective circuit you need start to investigate all the components, wiring, connectors etc of that circuit.

I did a little test on my Jeep as well, these are the two fuses/circuits I found carried a lot of current during my earlier investigations:

Fuse 15: 9mV which means 1,77Amps according to the table
Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-img_8904.jpeg

Fuse 40: 1mV
Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-img_8905.jpeg

During all of this you must ensure the car is kept in sleep mode. As you need access to the fuseboxes, you might have to disable door and or hood switches as well.

This method works well, but you do need a multimeter with a pretty good mV accuracy. I have found that the quality of blade fuses differs wildly. Which also means the internal resistance varies and you might get lost in the tables.

This method works pretty well if you have a large parasite current drain. (As in the above case). For smaller current parasite drains, it might become more and more difficult.

So you might have to resort to just pulling fuses. By just observing what happens you might very well be able to identify the correct fuse, circuit.

I will talk you through what happened with my Jeep, similar to how I described it in my other thread. But I will add some more detail and also some considerations for more modern cars.

If you have followed my “fiddling” thread you will know that I recently replaced both the battery and the alternator. I use my Jeep pretty regularly, or at least once a week.

So I was surprised to get an email the other day from Amsterdam Airport Valet parking. I had left my Jeep there 12 days earlier. They wanted to move my Jeep and found the battery empty. I gave them permission to start it using a booster. The next day I arrived at Amsterdam, Jeep started with no problems and seems to be running fine.

So it was a bit of a mystery to me, what had happened. And my first thought were about some sort of parasite drain. Although I also had a hunch it might be a different issue. The ignition key on my Jeep has a so called off ACC (Accessories) position.

Name:  Jeep Ignition .jpeg
Views: 1153
Size:  64.0 KB

With the key in the ACC position a number of electrical systems is powered on. For instance the radio, the electric doors etc. So it was likely that in the ACC position a larger current would be drawn then the quiescent current in sleep mode.

Because this is a 25 year old Jeep, with 320.000 km on it, the key lock mechanism is somewhat wonky. If you are not familiar with it, you might just turn the key anti-clockwise till it stops. But then you place it in the ACC position. I had a suspicion that this is what might have happened with the Valet Parking guys. ACC functions are pretty rare on cars these days.

So I needed to check what the quiescent current on the Jeep is and how much more the ACC position adds to it. I checked my workshop manuals and Jeep forums, but nobody could tell me anything about current draws. One thing is for sure, this Jeep will go into sleep or sleep ACC mode within 10 seconds of pulling the ignition key out. So that made things a bit easier.

Jeep parked in my garage, ready for some measurements

Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-img_8819-2.jpeg

First I decided to take a current measurement: All my cars have one of these quick disconnect knobs installed on the battery. It has a little fuse across it, to keep radio settings and so on when you disconnect it by turning the green knob.

I took the fuse out, connected my multimeter before and after the disconnect, so by turning the knob (disconnecting) any current will go through the multimeter. Here you see it with the knob still in the connecting position, so no current obviously.

Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-img_8784-2.jpeg

Next, I closed the doors, ensured the internal lights were off, ignition in the off position. I get a reading of 26,1mA.

Next I do the same but with the ignition in the ACC position. I get a reading of just over 1A!

So it was very obvious that with the Jeep in sleep mode all was well, i.e. a 26mA quiescent current drain is completely normal. However, the ignition in ACC position the 1A seemed high. But it did explain why the battery drained at the airport at the Valet Parking. The Valet guys would have accidentally put it in ACC,

This Jeep has a brand new Bosch Blue battery, 74AH. At a draw of 1A it would be completely drained in 74 hours, less than a week!!

i still wanted to make sure the 1A was normal for this ACC position. So I put the key into the ACC position, radio off, and door closed (otherwise the interior light comes on). Under these circumstances I measure about 1A.

Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-img_8818-2.jpeg

The Jeep has two fuse boxes. One as shown in the above image, in the engine compartment. Jeep calls this the PDC or Power Distribution Centre. There is also a fusebox inside the passenger compartment shown below:

Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-img_8826-2.jpeg

Interestingly, the owners manual only mentions the fusebox inside the passenger compartment. I have seen a similar thing on the Jaguar as well, not all fuses are mentioned in the owners manual. You really need to consult the workshop manuals to get the complete picture. So be aware!!

So I put the key into the ACC position, radio off, and door closed (otherwise the interior light comes on). Under these circumstances I measure about 1A.

So I started pulling fuses one by one. Every time checking the multimeter.
I saw a very noticeable drop on two fuses, number 23, small 15A and number 2 a large 40A. Both halved the draw approximately.

Fuse number 23 is in the Sentry key Immobiliser unit. But my Jeep does not have an Immobiliser. But with some further tracing, it appears my Parrot unit is hooked up to this circuit. Switching the Parrot off completely showed it was accounting for all the drop in amps when pulling fuse 23.

A Parrot is an electronic aftermarket device which allows your mobile phone to connect to your car sound system (speakers) via blue tooth. It has its own little microphone, so it is effectively a hands free mobile phone system. Switches sound from the radio to the call. Very simple, very effective.

So fuse 2 accounts for the remainder of the draw, about 50%. I have been doing some digging into the electrical drawings of my Jeep workshop manual. I am pretty sure this a quite normal.

So, in the end not a parasite drain on my Jeep. But I did learn a few things about my Jeep and its electrics. One thing I learned is how the wired the aftermarket Parrot unit. I mentioned earlier that aftermarket accessories often cause problems. Not necessarily because of poor quality, but due to poor quality workmanship in how they have been installed. Take my Parrot, it is wired up to a fused and ignition switched circuit. So with the ignition key off, no drain. But if somebody had installed it incorrectly and hooked it up to a permanent plus, it would be a continuous 400mA drain on the battery. Talk about a parasite!!

I hope you enjoyed reading up about this topic.

I found an excellent video explaining all the various aspects of tracing parasite drains I have described:



When all is said and done, how to trace a parasite drain is not all that difficul to understand. But as with most things in life, in order to put it in practice you need to know what you are doing and you need to have the proper tools. The methods I described show you how to identify the circuit with the parasite drain. You will still need to find the exact problem within that circuit which could be very, very time consuming.

Also, there might be cases where the problem is not in a fused circuit. Almost all cars have a number of plus wires running from the battery to various parts of the car without a fuse. Or at least a fuse in the regular fuseboxes. A good example for instance is that continues plus for a radio. Or for instance an immobilizer.

Jeroen

Last edited by Jeroen : 18th November 2022 at 20:35.
Jeroen is online now   (59) Thanks
Old 19th November 2022, 05:04   #2
Team-BHP Support
 
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Mumbai
Posts: 17,841
Thanked: 77,072 Times
Re: Dealing with Electrical parasite drains

Thread moved out from the Assembly Line. Thanks for sharing!
Aditya is online now   (2) Thanks
Old 19th November 2022, 08:02   #3
Distinguished - BHPian
 
vigsom's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: NSEW
Posts: 3,768
Thanked: 25,495 Times
Re: Dealing with Electrical parasite drains

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeroen View Post
1. On many digital multimeters the highest current setting is unfused. Also, most of these kind of multimeters are not suitable to measure high amps continuously. Neither the leads/probes and or the internal components can handle it.
2. In theory the voltage drop measurement is the best; set to measure mV and start taking readings across each and every fuse.The voltage differential is a measure for the current through the fuse. You can look up the current value in tables; different kind of tables available for different kind of fuses. You can find them, for free, on the internet. Just search for blade fuse voltage drop.
Thank You, Jeroen Sir, for this good refresher course. I followed method at S.No.2 when performing a parasitic draw test on my car in 2020. The culprit turned out to be the reverse camera.

On the lack of protection against high amps as pointed at S.No.1 above, wouldn't multimeter leads getting warm be a good tell-tale indication that they're running high amps?

Last edited by vigsom : 19th November 2022 at 08:12.
vigsom is offline   (3) Thanks
Old 19th November 2022, 10:37   #4
BHPian
 
SS80's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2019
Location: Bangalore
Posts: 246
Thanked: 928 Times
Re: Dealing with Electrical parasite drains

Amazing thread, read every line, an eye-opener indeed. My Manza has zero aftermarket accessories yet the battery drains out in 15 days if left unused. I will try the mobile phone method to check if it's the boot light or glove compartment light that's causing the drain. The battery itself is 2020 make, so still has 50% life I presume.
SS80 is offline   (2) Thanks
Old 19th November 2022, 11:13   #5
Distinguished - BHPian
 
SS-Traveller's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: New Delhi
Posts: 8,164
Thanked: 27,143 Times
Re: Dealing with Electrical parasite drains

@Jeroen: Thank you for a detailed description of parasitic battery drain, and how to test, isolate & resolve the issue.

One of the reasons that parasitic drain occurs here is due to bad wiring and switches of accessories with high current draw directly from the battery, bypassing the ignition switch. Some of our auto electricians have the knowledge level of a monkey when it comes to basic physics.

I have a voltmeter attached to one of the 12v sockets permanently, and even before cranking, I would know if I have a dead battery. Also, when the alternator isn't charging, the voltmeter would tell me. Or, in the rare instance of the alternator AVR going kaput, I'd know to switch off before high voltage fries the electricals of the car. Here's a picture for reference:

Dealing with Electrical parasite drains-20221119_105233.jpg
SS-Traveller is offline   (9) Thanks
Old 19th November 2022, 14:04   #6
Distinguished - BHPian
 
Join Date: Oct 2012
Location: Delhi
Posts: 8,101
Thanked: 50,880 Times
Re: Dealing with Electrical parasite drains

Quote:
Originally Posted by vigsom View Post
Thank You, Jeroen Sir, for this good refresher course. I followed method at S.No.2 when performing a parasitic draw test on my car in 2020. The culprit turned out to be the reverse camera.
Thanks, I had missed your excellent write up!

Quote:
Originally Posted by vigsom View Post
On the lack of protection against high amps as pointed at S.No.1 above, wouldn't multimeter leads getting warm be a good tell-tale indication that they're running high amps?
Absolutely, but you would be surprised how quickly that could happen. Also, that seem current heating up your leads is also passing through the internal components of the multimeter. They might be fried before you notice the leads getting warm.

Quote:
Originally Posted by SS80 View Post
Amazing thread, read every line, an eye-opener indeed. My Manza has zero aftermarket accessories yet the battery drains out in 15 days if left unused. I will try the mobile phone method to check if it's the boot light or glove compartment light that's causing the drain. The battery itself is 2020 make, so still has 50% life I presume.
I would be doubtful it is the boot or glove compartment light. Even a tiny bulb is likely to fully drain your battery in a matter of days. But do check with your mobile, as it is so easy to do. A two year battery giving you a 15 days drain, means that either the battery is on its way out, or you have some other parasite drain most likely.

Quote:
Originally Posted by SS-Traveller View Post
One of the reasons that parasitic drain occurs here is due to bad wiring and switches of accessories with high current draw directly from the battery, bypassing the ignition switch.
Yes, that can be a bad thing. I did not mention it, but of course parasite drains are also potential fire hazards. It is one thing if an accessories is permanently powered, but poorly installed permanent plus wires, chaffing can cause sparking!

Quote:
Originally Posted by SS-Traveller View Post
I have a voltmeter attached to one of the 12v sockets permanently, and even before cranking, I would know if I have a dead battery. Also, when the alternator isn't charging, the voltmeter would tell me. Or, in the rare instance of the alternator AVR going kaput, I'd know to switch off before high voltage fries the electricals of the car. Here's a picture for reference:
Love the little voltmeter. I need to get myself one!

Jeroen
Jeroen is online now   (4) Thanks
Old 19th November 2022, 20:04   #7
BHPian
 
UD17's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2022
Location: Dwarahat
Posts: 404
Thanked: 1,219 Times
Re: Dealing with Electrical parasite drains

What a wonderful thread sir, hats off.

The topic in this thread mainly discusses the battery drain due to parasites on the stationary vehicle.

I had an intersting observation for these parasitic drain during vehicle idling. During my yore days of working in OEM, we were getting battery drain on many test vehicles. Mind you, all these vehicle are never parked and battery are maintained in top notch condition.

Upon digging deep, we observed that during idle condition, due to some malfunction, the electronic parking break was taking nearly 60-70 amp of current from the battery. Which is a lot for a 120amp alternator. The alternator was getting the backlash and working in full vigor to compensate this current demand. This condition was creating a sort of high dynamics in complete belt system. As a result the alternator belt was getting slip, lot of noise, and in many vehicle even saw the snapping of belt, failure of tensioner.

This is one case of excessive current drain from vehicle components, but these drain may not be limited to one component but can happen with many scenarios.

Last edited by UD17 : 19th November 2022 at 20:06.
UD17 is offline   (3) Thanks
Old 19th November 2022, 23:02   #8
BHPian
 
Join Date: Oct 2020
Location: Pune, San Diego
Posts: 247
Thanked: 2,446 Times
Re: Dealing with Electrical parasite drains

Thanks for sharing a comprehensive writeup. I've had to learn most of these strategies while attempting to fix the battery drains I experienced while doing retrofits in my VAG cars. In fact, my default assumption when my car doesn't start is that I have a parasitic drain or a short somewhere, and I've gone through the entire ordeal of testing for a drain, only to find that it was a bad battery all along I'll share my most recent experience soon, since your thread inspires me to complete penning down my last experience
fluidicjoy is offline   (1) Thanks
Old 20th November 2022, 03:43   #9
BHPian
 
Join Date: Jul 2021
Location: Kolkata
Posts: 201
Thanked: 201 Times
Re: Dealing with Electrical parasite drains

Thanks for this excellent writeup. What is the normal drain expected from a switched off hatchback? Something around 50Ma?
Sumedik is offline  
Old 20th November 2022, 14:11   #10
Distinguished - BHPian
 
Join Date: Oct 2012
Location: Delhi
Posts: 8,101
Thanked: 50,880 Times
Re: Dealing with Electrical parasite drains

Quote:
Originally Posted by UD17 View Post
The topic in this thread mainly discusses the battery drain due to parasites on the stationary vehicle.

I had an intersting observation for these parasitic drain during vehicle idling.
Upon digging deep, we observed that during idle condition, due to some malfunction, the electronic parking break was taking nearly 60-70 amp of current from the battery.
This is one case of excessive current drain from vehicle components, but these drain may not be limited to one component but can happen with many scenarios.
Yes, these sort of parasite drains are only noticeable, or rather become a problem, with the car/engine stopped over a longer period of time. Obviously, even when the car/engine is running there is still the parasite drain. But as the alternator tops up the battery it is not noticeable. But it is measurable of course.

To your point there are all sorts of scenarios where you could see an excessive drain from various components, be it stationary, idle or running. They all require some different diagnostic techniques. Can be very difficult and time consuming.

About a week ago I was at a technical day organised by my Jaguar Specialist Raymond. (see https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/diy-d...ml#post5438794)

Raymond discussed a recent case on the transmission of a Jaguar X350. It was giving problems, without any codes. They replaced several bits, including at one point the brain. Only to have to replace it again. Long story short, he eventually managed to trace it to a broken free wheel pulley on the alternator. Which caused voltage spikes when the engine RPM dropped quickly and rather than the alternator free wheeling down to the match the RPM was forced downward and that caused a spike. Normally that should not happen, but in this case it did.

By and large, (very) large currents tend to be easier to trace. They are easier to measure, sometimes things run hot or start to make noises. Transient voltages/currents (as in Raymond’s case) are really difficult to find.


Quote:
Originally Posted by fluidicjoy View Post
In fact, my default assumption when my car doesn't start is that I have a parasitic drain or a short somewhere, and I've gone through the entire ordeal of testing for a drain, only to find that it was a bad battery all along
Yes, as I mentioned, always make sure it is not your battery first!

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sumedik View Post
What is the normal drain expected from a switched off hatchback? Something around 50Ma?
Being an hatchback has no bearing on the normal drain as such. I would say that the number of electronic boxes and (electronically controlled features in a car is probably a better measure for the queiescent drain.

As I mentioned the internet tells you around 40mA. If you look at the Jaguar table in my original post you will see all values for all models listed below 40mA.

But as I also mentioned, I think these days some cars are likely to have a somewhat higher queiscent drain. But I doubt it would be more than double. Would be interesting if somebody could measure it on say a BMW, Mercedes, Lexus, Audi. The sort of high end type of cars.

The more high end, the more features tend to be hidden where the average driver has no knowledge of. But they all draw some current.

During that same visit to Jaguar Specialist Raymond, spanner mate Peter and I learned of another unknown Jaguar feature of the X358. This car has air suspension and Raymond showed us how that impact the alignment of the car.

As soon as you start the car, the compressor kicks in and puts air in the suspension, this raises the car by a few mm. But here is the interesting thing; If you switch off the engine and the driver gets out, all pressure in the suspension will be released and the vehicle lowers itself a few mm. But if you switch off the engine without getting out, it does not do that. It maintains the pressure in the system. You need to know/understand that when you are doing alignments, because mechanics tend to switch on/off the engine without getting behind the wheel. (The car is on a lift and they just reach inside)

As you can imagine, such a system can also cause quite erratic parasite drain measurements. Again, it is all about understanding what the queiescent drain is when the car goes into sleep mode.

Just for future reference I will measure the quiescent current drain on all our five cars. Because not all workshop manuals publish quiescent current.

I will post these values in this thread in the days to come.

Jeroen
Jeroen is online now   (2) Thanks
Old 20th November 2022, 20:25   #11
BHPian
 
rst89's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2017
Location: Pune
Posts: 193
Thanked: 1,124 Times
Re: Dealing with Electrical parasite drains

Modern cars now wake up at least once per 24 hours to check whether car has been parked for a long time. And when you park for long time, depending on OEM requirements, you have to disable some functionalities.

Also lot's of mechanisms exist in car to switch OFF a glove box light bulb within 60 mins if it's left ON by mistake.

OEMs impose the sleep current requirements on products taken from their suppliers and are mentioned in requirements and tested during vehicle integration.
rst89 is offline  
Old 20th November 2022, 22:18   #12
Distinguished - BHPian
 
Join Date: Oct 2012
Location: Delhi
Posts: 8,101
Thanked: 50,880 Times
Re: Dealing with Electrical parasite drains

Quote:
Originally Posted by rst89 View Post
Modern cars now wake up at least once per 24 hours to check whether car has been parked for a long time. And when you park for long time, depending on OEM requirements, you have to disable some functionalities. .
Interesting, could you give us some examples?

Quote:
Originally Posted by rst89 View Post
Also lot's of mechanisms exist in car to switch OFF a glove box light bulb within 60 mins if it's left ON by mistake. .
Interesting, could you give us some examples of these many mechanics.

Jeroen
Jeroen is online now  
Old 21st November 2022, 23:15   #13
BHPian
 
rst89's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2017
Location: Pune
Posts: 193
Thanked: 1,124 Times
Re: Dealing with Electrical parasite drains

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeroen View Post
Interesting, could you give us some examples?

Interesting, could you give us some examples of these many mechanics.

Jeroen
1. Most modern chips in electronic control units(ECUs) have their own internal clocks to wake up and count how many days have passed after you last started car. So suppose 30 days have passed, you need max voltage from the car battery to crank the car. So you need to inhibit some other functions in car so that they don't consume voltage from car battery when you start the car after like 35 days. The function inhibited can be air suspension or HVAC fan for example.

2. Most cars need to disconnect relays to these things of you left them ON by mistake. Suppose you left the car in ACC mode, then a timer starts to disconnect all relays powered by ACC after 60 minutes as designated by the OEM requirements. Same logic can be applied if you leave car in IGN mode for long time. Modern cars have relays controlled by electronics for everything now. Some cars even chime when you leave some lamps ON by mistake.
rst89 is offline   (1) Thanks
Old 19th January 2023, 19:22   #14
BANNED
 
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: hump city
Posts: 1,293
Thanked: 5,861 Times
Infractions: 0/1 (7)
Re: Dealing with Electrical parasite drains

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeroen View Post
When all is said and done, how to trace a parasite drain is not all that difficul to understand. But as with most things in life, in order to put it in practice you need to know what you are doing and you need to have the proper tools. The methods I described show you how to identify the circuit with the parasite drain. You will still need to find the exact problem within that circuit which could be very, very time consuming.
Appreciate the time you set aside to write this post, with pictures, and write each step in detail. There are a few of us who debug their cars DIY, but much much fewer have the ability to write it up in a "DIY for dummies" manner and help fellow members. Your post is a great example of how to explain to the layman who wants a basic understanding of approaching electrical issues with the car.
venkyhere is offline  
Reply

Most Viewed


Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Team-BHP.com
Proudly powered by E2E Networks