Quote:
Originally Posted by BhaskarG Great review. Thanks again. However, can you elaborate what difference you felt compared to the Ecosport:
1. As a daily driver,
2. As a highway cruiser?
What are the compromises you had to make, coming from a dynamically sorted car like the Ecosport?
Also, how convenient will it be as the only vehicle in the garage? I am not considering off roading requirements for this question, just city rides and weekend trips. |
As you said, Ecosport is a Dynamically sorted car and in comparison, the Thar is just a big heavy old school SUV
1. As a daily Driver, For daily commute both Ecosport and Thar is good. Ecosport AT being petorl causes no worries of DPF in short city/town daily commutes like in the Thar Diesel, low FE numbers might cause some worry though.
But road visibility is better in the Thar. Ecosport has super thick A-Pillars and high set dashboard, and bonnet is not visible. Whereas Thar has pretty good frontal visibility.
2. As a high cruiser, no question, Ecosport will be a better choice by a big margin. Pretty sorted ride and handling, with slightly stiff suspension. Front seat has very good underthigh support (Infact, too much of underthigh support), although Ecosport lacks adjustable lumbar support, whereas Thar lacks underthigh support but gets adjustable lumbar support. In comparison, Thar is just about adequate as a Highway cruiser. With the hardtop, Wind noise is controlled and the mHawk 130 is a superb engine.
Engine wise, mHawk 130 will be my pick and ride & handling wise, the Ecosport. For Automatic transmission, Thar's 6 speed AT is by far the better one.
Compromises made for having the Thar over the Ecosport
1. I miss the passive keyless entry system of the Ecosport, which was awesome, no buttons to press, just touch the door handle. Same for the push button start on the Ecosport, which the Thar lacks.
Although not a massive compromise.
2. Rear Wash and Wipe was a good to have feature on the Ecosport which the Thar lacks. In our weather conditions, Rear wash and wipe would have been a nice addition on the Thar.
3. The Ecosport has a better sounding HU and speaker setup. Thar with its atypical speaker placement is not able to come close. Although compared to my Celerio, Thar has better sounding setup
4. Boot space is the biggest compromise on the Thar compared to any car, not just my Ecosport or Celerio, any car. As I said, boot is microscopic
5. Ride comfort is another compromise on the Thar compared to any car. And we have to adjust our driving style accordingly. Vertical and side to side movement on the Thar is not to everyone's liking.
Thar as the only car in the Garage
This is the big question, and a simple answer is, Thar as the only car in the garage wil be impractical. Even for a family of 3, Space wise, Thar is good enough, but ride comfort wise, ingress-egress wise, not very practical.
But if we consider the Thar for daily commute, it is pretty good option. Great engine and gearbox combination, Pretty good fuel economy numbers and tank range on the Diesel AT as well.
Practicality wise, for two person, Thar is a good option. Front seat view is very impressive.