Quote:
Originally Posted by shan_ned Along with the hybrid, Honda could have got the Diesel CVT as well to boost their sales. It looks like Honda is sort of happy to play safe with whatever sales they are doing. |
Diesel has no future with the strict emission norms. Even today's BS6 engine's soot burning is kind of a 'jugaad' for me which is going to make the ownership experience a pain in the long run especially if you drive mostly in the city or mountains. With stricter emission norms, this is going to get even worse.
Quote:
Originally Posted by shan_ned Yes, Honda should have released with 6 airbags as a standard for all the models at the time of launch. Now, they corrected it with the R variants. |
+100 on this.
Quote:
Originally Posted by shan_ned While I personally prefer manual transmission, CVT is a different thing when it comes to enhancing the comfort. It is brilliant. If people do back to back test drive of MT versus CVT, they may fall in love with the CVT. This is reflected in the Elevate sales with CVT selling the most. A few are paranoid about the rubber band effect. Once they get used to it, they will love CVT. And with paddle shifters, drivers can get hold of some control. |
Can completely relate to it. I mostly drive an Innova Crysta 2.8 L Diesel Torque Converter with 176 PS and 360 Nm torque ( 1200 - 3200 rpm ) in Bangalore. But, when I go to my home town, I get to drive the Yaris 1.5L CVT and I have fallen in love with that experience. It's the smoothest drive you can ever experience on typical city traffic conditions. Even on the highway, you just need to learn how much you need to push the pedal to get the optimal balance of acceleration and refinement. If you floor the pedal, the CVTs can downshift crazy and take the rpm to peak in no time. The car will then accelerate keeping the rpm at the max power band. The problem with this is that even though theoretically the car does accelerate the hardest this way, most drivers feel that this is slow progress because of the disproportionate engine noise. It's just a matter of learning to modulate the A-pedal to get the optimal output from the car.
TLDR: Driving an automatic is a different art compared to a manual gearbox. In a manual gearbox car, when you press the A - Pedal, only the fuel flow changes. In an automatic, the speed with which you press the accelerator and how much you press determines the aggressiveness of gear downshifts as well. So, you need to be more mindful about that. And each type ( DCT/DSG, Torque Convertor, CVT ) has a different character. So, there is a learning curve for each to get the best performance and smoothness out of it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ulysses 1) The engine noise was too much, especially at lower gears. I have an i10 NIOS for daily drive, the engine of the NIOS would be super silent, compared to the noise from the Elevate's engine |
I got a similar feeling when I first switched from driving the 1.0 l 4 cylinder Maruti Suzuki Zen to the 1.6l Maruti Suzuki Baleno(old) Sedan. The Baleno made a sound whereas the Zen was very refined. That was because the Baleno engine was more free revving and the rpm needle climbed aggressively. It's kind of similar with even the Elevate. The i-vtec engine means that the rpm climbs even more aggressively and it will make a sound. But, I felt the tone sporty than noisy.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ulysses 2) in the CVT version, the rubber-band effect was very prominent. It gets reduced to some extent in the "sports" mode, but otherwise the vehicle just takes ages to pick up speed. |
It's a relative thing. If you are comparing against Turbo charged engines, then you are right. It is not comparable. But, among the NA engines, the Elevate provides decent performance. But, CVTs can give an impression of slow progress due to the disportionate noise thanks to its ability to downshift fast and increase the RPMs. Even more so with the i-vtec. But once you get a hang of how much to modulate the accelerator to keep the rpm at certain levels, this feeling will start coming down.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ulysses 3) the suspension is not suited for bad roads. Every bump and pothole are felt (strongly) inside the cabin, especially in the second row. |
This is a very interesting observation. Not a single review has called out the ride comfort as bad. In fact, all of them has mentioned it as one of the best in the segment. I felt the same too. So, I am not sure about this point.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ulysses Otherwise it is a large vehicle, with ample space and legroom and a big boot space. |
I am not sure about this as well. For me, Elevate is a 4 seater if you prefer comfortable seating. If you push in 5, it's going to make it uncomfortable for all 3 on the 2nd row. This is also in part due to the headrest design which has a curve on the sides which forces you to keep the head inside of it rather than on any part of the headrest. So, if you sit on both sides with your head aligned inside the headrest, there is practically no space left for the middle passenger. Even a child might find it uncomfortable to sit in the center. But boot space is huge and I guess is is the best in class.