Today I test drove the Baleno Lxi. After couple of schedule confusion, they finally landed at my home with the test car. Surprise, surprise, it was not stock. The Lxi which should be riding on steel rim and 165/80R13 was instead riding on 175/70R13 with Alloys. Smart chaps!
I kept reminding myself not to compare this engine with the 3.2 VTEC beast I used to own. After driving in some really bad traffic, I choose Jayadev flyover as my test track. I stayed in 2nd and ripped it. By the time I reached the end of the flyover, the maruti salesperson claimed I had hit 100KMPH after the peak point. May be, I don't know since I was watching the road. Anyway, there was a stopped vehicle at the flyover exit and I had to come to complete halt. I was quite surprised how easily I could bring it to a stop on the slope in that speed, being in 2nd gear may have helped. After that I drove on some bad (almost mud) roads to test the ride comfort. My wife sat in the back to test the rear seat comfort. She was pleasantly surprised at the smooth ride, much better than the NHC ride on a better road.
Pros:
Great engine, at no time it felt underpowered. It kept on giving while I climbed the flyover incline.
Braking was excellent.
Amazing AC.
Surprisingly great low end torque.
Rear seats are extremely comfortable, great thigh support. Leg room was adequete.
Front bucket seats were great too. However, my wife had some issues with the front head rest. We are going to try that again with some seat adjustments.
I mentioned many mods I require and the sales guy was fine with all of them and said everything will be covered by warranty.
Seat covers were good although grey.
Car felt quite solid and rigid unlike my former Maruti cars. Rode the humps and potholes without a squeek. Felt quite safe.
Very good ride comfort. I intentionally didn't avoid any potholes and rode fast over humps and not a squeek from my wife in the back either...
Cons:
Very dull looking dash and interiors, needs to be souped up. This can be fixed I hope.
The gear shift is not very smooth unlike the NHC.
Tiny side mirrors when compared to Santro.
The head rest for front passengers is not very good, this is big issue for my wife.
There may be other cons, but wasn't apparent to me.
The Baleno Lxi on road in Bangalore will come to Rs. 6.5L before any mods. I think that is an excellent value, only Rs. 1L more than Fiat Petra on road. Now if you consider the A.S.S and service network, that one lakh premium suddenly feels worth it.
Anyway, I was planning to test drive Petra too, therefore I decided to give a call to Sundaram. But, where is their number? Fiat has no website, so you can forget that route. So I googled for
sundaram motor bangalore fiat and got these two links as first two hits.
http://www.mouthshut.com/review/Pal...l)-53324-1.html (one year old review)
http://www.mouthshut.com/review/Pal...l)-71115-1.html (one month old review)
Reading these two links suddenly put things into perspective. I really liked the Baleno performance, even impressed. Now if I test drive the Petra, it is possible I'll be impressed even more, say by 10%. Based on feedbacks from BHPians, I don't think Petra will be head and shoulders above Baleno, the differences will be marginal. Such difference will not make up for the A.S.S and peace of mind you get from Maruti. Besides, with Fiat I might lose warranty on many parts due to mods. Finally I don't think I have the stomach to deal with Sundaram. In my company I blacklist any vendor who behaves unprofessionally. Therefore how can I consider a car dealer who is certifiably incompetent and unprofessional. With all these thoughts I have to say
NO to Fiat Petra with a heavy heart and
Heck NO to Sundaram Motors with relief and glee.