Quote:
Originally Posted by quicksilvr I second .anshuman. I just picked up a 06 decontent model, and it does have ABS and TCS.
If you find a top-end, go for it, or the decontent does the job as well, you wont miss anything great, except for the airbags maybe.
I was in the same dilemma as you, whether to pick up an Octavia or an Elantra, but the Skoda horror stories put me off of it, though I love that car.
But I like the Elantra better after driving it for a few days, and the power delivery is waaay better than that of the Ocatavia 1.9s! |
Now this is going to be a long one
Firstly power delivery in skoda till probably you reach 120 is better than Elantra probably because it has a smaller turbo and spools a little early and thanks to gear ratios as well beyond that point i guess elantra is way better
Let me rate the both in a scale of 100 ( i am doing this as i have owned both the cars and serviced both of them in company and outside both)
Build quality Elantra : 75 Skoda : 90
Reason : Bought a used
Skoda 2003 which had done 45000 and drove for another 40000 before i sold it it had absolutely no rattles after all the abuse i have given that, also nothing was changed other than the cluthplate in the whole episode cause of daily driving
Elantra : I have driven that car for about 3000ms after picking it up but yes it does rattle a bit here and there probably its inborn(birthright) in korean/Maruthi cars cars
Spares:
Elantra: 90 Skoda : 75
Skoda:it is quite expensive in the showroom but if you know a good mechanic like i do it will be 15% more expensive than that of an elantra bought in A.S.S : (yes for some spares one needs to order and then replace for elantra unlike for Skoda; readily available)
Drivability: Skoda : 90 Elantra: 75
I some how feel Skoda feels a lot better inside than the elantra; though it has some nice gizmo's missing. You will not feel any strain driving in the city compared to Elantra. Trust me Wihout
TC Skoda will handle if not better but as good as Elantra
Topend: Skoda: 65 Elantra: 95
Elantra will trounce a skoda outright in this section as i feel top end of Skoda takes too long a time to reach it can cruise in 140-145 easily above that it is a tad noisy and yu will feel the strain
Where as elantra will do 180 all the way without any discomfort
Braking : Skoda : 60 Elantra 90
Elantra with all its gizmos will brake considerably better than a skoda which has quite horrendous braking distance. Personal experience as a little better braking would have saved me a Lakh of rupees
Seating comfort in the rear
Skoda : 75 Elantra : 80
It is slightly better than skoda it was a purely personal experience
Resale value Skoda : 90 Elantra: 60
Elantras have a very bad resale value compared to a skoda cause of it brand image
Mileage
Skoda : 95
Elantra : 75
Skoda rules the roost here i would get easily 14 to 15 in city with ac on , while elantra i am returning figures of 10- 11 Kmpl
In highway I would easily get about 19 to 21 where as in Elantra i am getting about 13 to 15
Snob value: Skoda 90, elantra 60
If you really care for it
If you do decide for skoda pick up the one with Abs as it has got rear disc option unlike the ambient and Elegance which comes with drum brakes