Diesel war : Chevy Magnum vs Skoda Octavia. Whats your pick? - Team-BHP

GTO · 7th July 2007, 16:34

Finally, the Octavia has some genuine competition. The previous diesel alternatives were either from a segment lower (Verna, Fiesta) or from a segment higher (sister Laura).

Whats your pick between the two 10-lac diesel options?

Advantage Chevy Magnum:

- Cheaper by about 1.5 lacs

- Far more power and torque. A whopping 3 seconds faster in 0 - 100!

- Greater interior room and space

- Comfortable backseat (A real backseat!)

- Extended warranty available (for upto 4 years). May turn out much cheaper to run.

Advantage Skoda Octavia:

- Solid build quality and a "built to last" forever feel

- More fuel efficient (as much as 15-20% more)

- Better handler. And superior overall chassis balance.

- Huge boot

mclaren1885 · 7th July 2007, 16:38

If it only had the old Optra front. Like Rudy's. This one is not to my liking.

manikjeet · 7th July 2007, 16:45

i would like to choose the optra as its a newer car and not like skoda octavia a much older model

rishibravo · 7th July 2007, 16:50

I would have to say Magnum. On contrary to mclaren1885's choice I prefer the new front of the magnum than the old optra

nevertouchme · 7th July 2007, 16:52

I did like the old Optra. This is not my type

. Can we even call this American? Korean stuff right?

My vote would be for Skoda.

Cheers,
Jai...

nbr · 7th July 2007, 16:52

Quote:

Originally Posted by manikjeet

i would like to choose the optra as its a newer car and not like skoda octavia a much older model

Octavia has started showing its age, the new shape of Optra is not that bad. i guess its just matter of time for us to get used to it.

abhibh · 7th July 2007, 16:59

Optra for me:
- Build quality almost as same as skoda. I dont feel much difference
- Faster and Common rail engine
- Great suspension
- Great interiors
- Comes at a bit lesser price
- Cheaper to maintain than Skoda

But the things that go in favor of skoda are:
- Its FE though both will have same FE in city and i am gonna post a thread soon related to "Skoda Rider 1.TDi FE woes" as soon as BSNL broadband works.
- Boot is huge as GTO says
- Climatic control etc and lot of information display on board
- Better handler / gear box than Optra.

Absar · 7th July 2007, 17:02

How about choosing the Skoda? I'd choose the Skoda family over the Chevrolet Magnum. I liked the older front of the Optra!

A

NIP · 7th July 2007, 17:07

base skoda rider is around 2 lakhs more than the base magnum...about time someone showed skoda what ripoff's they are !! and look at the magnum package !! magnum anyday for me...

GTO · 7th July 2007, 17:30

Quote:

Originally Posted by mclaren1885

If it only had the old Optra front. Like Rudy's. This one is not to my liking.

Its still available on the petrol? Yup, I like the regular Optra front end too. This one, somehow, doesnt match the rest of the car.

I added the price point in favour of the Magnum. Will be interesting to see how the market responds.

wizardofid · 7th July 2007, 18:32

I dont like this front at all, but I'd still go for the Magnum, if I had to, which I don't. More space inside and relatively much cheaper (possibly cheaper to maintain as well if the current Optra is anything to go by). Maybe in black? So that that strange front does not stick out too much

markiv · 7th July 2007, 18:55

Have voted for Magnum for the sheer performance (from the specs mentioned). However, I didnt like the new nose/grille.
Somehow all the GM cars have a very bland front. No character. I thought the initial optra had the best grille.
Even newer models like SRV, UVA are not good looking from front.

rahul_intlad · 7th July 2007, 19:00

Skoda certainly have responded ,nowadays you get ads which read do you think owning a skoda is expensive...and then finally they too show their three year warranty scheme.
Competition is always beneficial to the end user and nice that we have the octavia and the optra now but would be even better if only we get a few more in the battlefield.

totaloverdoze · 7th July 2007, 19:02

Skoda Octavia looks better but Chevy Magnum is a driver's car...

Rtech · 7th July 2007, 20:13

On paper it looks like the Magnum is the clear winner. More space inside and more power under the hood. But, I am still waiting to test it before I caste my vote. However, right now, it's 95% Magnum for me. The other 5% will happen after my test drive.

Also, seems like I'm in the minority here, I actually prefer the facelift to the old chrome grill. But yes, the front does not gel with the rear.

View Poll Results: Your choice?
Chevy Magnum	196	73.96%
Skoda Octavia	69	26.04%
Voters: 265. You may not vote on this poll

7th July 2007, 16:34	#1 (permalink)
GTO Team-BHP Support Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Bombay Posts: 13,115 View My Garage	Diesel war : Chevy Magnum vs Skoda Octavia. Whats your pick? Finally, the Octavia has some genuine competition. The previous diesel alternatives were either from a segment lower (Verna, Fiesta) or from a segment higher (sister Laura). Whats your pick between the two 10-lac diesel options? Advantage Chevy Magnum: - Cheaper by about 1.5 lacs - Far more power and torque. A whopping 3 seconds faster in 0 - 100! - Greater interior room and space - Comfortable backseat (A real backseat!) - Extended warranty available (for upto 4 years). May turn out much cheaper to run. Advantage Skoda Octavia: - Solid build quality and a "built to last" forever feel - More fuel efficient (as much as 15-20% more) - Better handler. And superior overall chassis balance. - Huge boot __________________ GTO Change the way you think, and watch the world change around you. Please don't PM for support. Use the Contact Form instead. Please read the NEW Team-BHP FAQ section for all your queries. Last edited by GTO : 7th July 2007 at 17:29.

7th July 2007, 16:38	#2 (permalink)
mclaren1885 Senior - BHPian Join Date: Jul 2005 Location: Bangalore (the city of modded cars) !! Posts: 3,862 View My Garage	If it only had the old Optra front. Like Rudy's. This one is not to my liking. __________________ Phoenix!

7th July 2007, 16:45	#3 (permalink)
manikjeet Senior - BHPian Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: chandigarh Posts: 1,014 View My Garage	i would like to choose the optra as its a newer car and not like skoda octavia a much older model __________________ *MANIK NANDA*

7th July 2007, 16:50	#4 (permalink)
rishibravo BHPian Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: New Delhi Posts: 545 View My Garage	I would have to say Magnum. On contrary to mclaren1885's choice I prefer the new front of the magnum than the old optra __________________ Boyz will remain Boyz.......Only their Toyz change

7th July 2007, 16:52	#5 (permalink)
nevertouchme BHPian Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Bangalore Posts: 184	Ameeerika vs Eurooopa haa? I did like the old Optra. This is not my type . Can we even call this American? Korean stuff right? My vote would be for Skoda. Cheers, Jai... __________________ Patience is the ability to idle your motors when you feel like stripping your gears.

7th July 2007, 16:59	#7 (permalink)
abhibh Senior - BHPian Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: In the Hood Near You Posts: 1,534 View My Garage	Optra for me: - Build quality almost as same as skoda. I dont feel much difference - Faster and Common rail engine - Great suspension - Great interiors - Comes at a bit lesser price - Cheaper to maintain than Skoda But the things that go in favor of skoda are: - Its FE though both will have same FE in city and i am gonna post a thread soon related to "Skoda Rider 1.TDi FE woes" as soon as BSNL broadband works. - Boot is huge as GTO says - Climatic control etc and lot of information display on board - Better handler / gear box than Optra. __________________ tinypic.com/player.php?v=35mo01l&s=4

7th July 2007, 17:02	#8 (permalink)
Absar BHPian Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Madras Posts: 552 View My Garage	How about choosing the Skoda? I'd choose the Skoda family over the Chevrolet Magnum. I liked the older front of the Optra! A __________________ Ford Ikon 1.6 Nxt ZXi, 2005 I cried because I had no VTEC, until I met a person who had no 1.6 ROCAM.

7th July 2007, 17:07	#9 (permalink)
NIP BHPian Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: Bangalore Posts: 634 View My Garage	base skoda rider is around 2 lakhs more than the base magnum...about time someone showed skoda what ripoff's they are !! and look at the magnum package !! magnum anyday for me... __________________ *Jeeping - Rock, not* Rice!**

7th July 2007, 18:32	#11 (permalink)
wizardofid BHPian Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Bangalore Posts: 185	I dont like this front at all, but I'd still go for the Magnum, if I had to, which I don't. More space inside and relatively much cheaper (possibly cheaper to maintain as well if the current Optra is anything to go by). Maybe in black? So that that strange front does not stick out too much __________________ 2005 Baleno LXi 2006 Marina TDi

7th July 2007, 18:55	#12 (permalink)
markiv BHPian Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Delhi Posts: 150 View My Garage	Have voted for Magnum for the sheer performance (from the specs mentioned). However, I didnt like the new nose/grille. Somehow all the GM cars have a very bland front. No character. I thought the initial optra had the best grille. Even newer models like SRV, UVA are not good looking from front. __________________ Fiat Palio 1.6 Sport (Oct'06-Apr'08) Hyundai Accent 1.5 GLE (May'08 onwards)

7th July 2007, 19:00	#13 (permalink)
rahul_intlad Senior - BHPian Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Pune Posts: 1,569	Skoda certainly have responded ,nowadays you get ads which read do you think owning a skoda is expensive...and then finally they too show their three year warranty scheme. Competition is always beneficial to the end user and nice that we have the octavia and the optra now but would be even better if only we get a few more in the battlefield.

7th July 2007, 19:02	#14 (permalink)
totaloverdoze Newbie Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: mumbai Posts: 22	Skoda Octavia looks better but Chevy Magnum is a driver's car...

7th July 2007, 20:13	#15 (permalink)
Rtech Team-BHP Support Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Bombay Posts: 5,982 View My Garage	On paper it looks like the Magnum is the clear winner. More space inside and more power under the hood. But, I am still waiting to test it before I caste my vote. However, right now, it's 95% Magnum for me. The other 5% will happen after my test drive. Also, seems like I'm in the minority here, I actually prefer the facelift to the old chrome grill. But yes, the front does not gel with the rear. __________________ He who makes the loudest noise usually has the least to say. Unfortunately they don't realise that and keep at it! ____

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Skoda Octavia Diesel: Resale Value	jkdas	The Indian Car Scene!!	6	29th July 2008 16:22
Optra Magnum or Honda Civic or Toyota Corolla or Skoda Octavia	The Hurricane	The Indian Car Scene!!	1	26th May 2008 06:50
Ferrari vs Porsche : Whats your pick?	GTO	The International Automotive Scene	64	5th February 2007 17:25
Two Delicious Looking Fiats-Whats Your Pick Eh?	roms	The International Automotive Scene	14	6th November 2006 17:16
Japanese or European cars? Whats your pick in India?	GTO	The Indian Car Scene!!	98	21st September 2006 14:11