Re: "Almost-New" used cars! The logic & beauty of buying 1 - 3 year old pre-worshipped cars As I have entered into 5th month of waiting on my Brezza Booking and still no definitive delivery timeline I am undergoing stressful days not being able to finalize on Plan B.
Hoping to get some advice from the experienced Members. My thought process goes like this -
I come from a Chevy spark which has set some benchmark (ride stability, refinement, interiors) and also some wants (engine power, Ground clearance, cabin space) in my mind. I sold it this year.
Structural safety is another critical factor and need a SUV form factor and no sedans and hatchbacks. Plan A - New Car
My initial choice was Tata Punch at around 7.5L-8L on road for the Pure or Adventure Variant. I felt the rear seat width is not much bigger and the 1.2L engine is a marginal upgrade (power to weight).
Then I came across Brezza ,which ticked most of my boxes including safety (assuming 4 Star from previous gen) and decided to extend my budget to (and capped) at 10Lac and booked it in July.
I do not like exterior style of Nexon and No to Hyundai's, Renault and Nissan and Honda (costly).
So, Its either Brezza or Punch if it's a new Car and nothing else. Plan B - Used Car
I know my mind says preowned car can be a good deal. But there are few pointers that are making me not comfortable in going ahead with Used cars which I will try to explain. 1.Budget -
I do not want to spend my max budget 10L or close to that on a used Car - could be any variants or any Make and models even if higher to Brezza. So, Tata punch being the other boundary condition I am comfortable to spend around 6-7Lac or lesser for a preowned car that is superior to Punch. 2. Age of car and Milage -
2019 and above with less than 25K on Odo. 3. BS4 vs BS6 tech - My key Hurdle
In today's sellers' market, I feel the pricing by organized resellers like cars24, spinny (not considering private dealers, Individual olx sellers) is higher by at least 50K -1Lac and I think BS4/BS6 standard is not factored in at all in depreciation calculation of 2019 and early 2020 models.
BS6 models are priced very close to the new ones.
With Government taking drastic measures in terms of emission standards etc., in near future, is it worth to pay the premium even if the car is good? 4. Manufacturer operation in India
Even though Ford is Out I think its Cars are being listed with premium pricing. It's the same situation with Honda with rumors about it shutting its India shop. Is it worth buying them as a primary car??
I don't want to get into the situation that I had with my spark with GM stepping out of India. Though I had a very very happy ownership experience with spark, there was always a feeling that what if some major breakdown happens? can the existing service centers find the spares, etc. 5. Min Structural safety 6. Usage is long term
At least I used my Spark for 12 years and I will keep the next car also longer as far as I can. Resale price not a major factor but don't want to sell for scrap price if have to do that in very short time as 2nd owner. Trivia -With drastically changing Technologies -electric, hybrids, etc. Should one really consider Longterm keep (10-15 Years) as a decisive factor in buying a car? (IC engines will not die in next 10 years for sure) Pre-owned Cars that I have checked -
Considering all factors described above with petrol Brezzas scarcely available and overpriced if available, the only choice I could make was a Honda Jazz. JAZZ
I have checked couple of Jazz models that look like well-maintained from 2019's priced around 7-8Lac. Confusion here -
For Jazz (Vs Punch) - Better 1.2L engine but BS4, Cabin Space,
Against Jazz (Vs Punch) - BS4, Lower ground clearance, not a SUV form factor, Discontinuation in 2023? and High chances? of Honda closing India shop. WRV
I had ignored WRV based on online reviews of it being underpowered, etc. But I accidentally happen to come across a low milage used one yesterday which actually ticked all my boxes as same as Brezza did for my needs in terms of equipment and interior/exteriors based on a spot check. It is still overpriced, and I am yet to take a proper TestDrive.
This is definitely better choice than a Jazz for me if I go to a used car Confusion here -
For WRV (Vs Punch) - Better 1.2L engine but BS4, Cabin Space, same SUV form factor, better equipment
Against WRV (Vs Punch) - BS4, Discontinuation in 2023? and High chances? of Honda closing India shop. Is Honda a better tradeoff over Punch:
With Tata's not so good reputation with service, one may have to visit twice for anything, but their service centers will definitely continue to exist across the cities and villages for many years to come and spares will be available. If Honda shuts shop, service may be available in major cities for few years, but what about after that and other parts which are far from cities?
I am getting suggestions to not go for the used Honda due to uncertainties.
I Need a Car at the earliest this month and have to make a choice b/w the Punch (not booked But, I am confident I can procure one) and the Honda WRV and the Brezza (Booked, not in my control, in mercy of Dealer/Maruti).
So, I am writing this post desperately and looking for some perspectives and advice from the distinguished members so that I can take an informed decision.
Thanks in Advance. |