[gomzi]

Originally Posted by Rehaan

Was informed by a friend that as of a few days back MTNL has a few new plans :

1) 1mbps - Unlimited - 1599/month
2) 4mbps - 8gb - 1499/mo

More here : MTNL Broadband Internet Services Tariff Plans

cya
R

Hey, I've noticed that plan too and thinking of changing to the 1 mbps option.

Has anyone here used either of these plans? How are they?

The only option where I live is MTNL, the cable operator has horrible service and I get no GSM/CDMA signals at home.

[Rehaan]

Originally Posted by DerAlte

Tikona: "Contention Ratio - 1:30 for unlimited & High Speed Internet Plans; 1:10 for Circuit Breaker Plans"

Good point. However, given our infrastructure, what is an acceptable contention ratio?

The PDF posted by netfreak says :
"Broadband: We recommend maintaining ratios between 1:20 and 1:50, following standard practice in the UK, for both business and residential customers."

In which case the 1:30 of tikona should, in theory, be okay - right?

Originally Posted by Sahil

I have my doubts on this company....

Yeah, i hadn't even heard of it before a friend sent me the link. He might be getting it. Lets see how it turns out.
Haven't heard anything new about reliance's similar - "WiMax" - in a while.

Originally Posted by gomzi

...thinking of changing to the 1 mbps option.

Has anyone here used either of these plans? How are they?

Firstly, moving from hathway(cable) to MTNL (ADSL) was a night and day difference for me.
See, the thing is, not only do download speeds improve, but there is also so much less latency - so regular browsing is much snappier and more pleasurable.

As for the 1mbps plan - i have put in my papers. Switching from 2mbps/16GB to 1mbps/unlimited and saving Rs 800/p.m.
Will let you know once its in effect.

However, DerAlte's point has made me think : Is there likely to be a different contention ratio for unlimited plans vs limited plans on MTNL ?? Is that even possible / likely?

cya
R

[Rehaan]

Originally Posted by Rehaan

As for the 1mbps plan - i have put in my papers. Switching from 2mbps/16GB to 1mbps/unlimited and saving Rs 800/p.m.
Will let you know once its in effect.

Just started this plan today.

speedtest.net shows no change in speed

111ms ping
1.75mbps (same as when i was on the 2mbps plan)
0.21mbps upload (same as before, most MTNL plan uploads are @256kbps)

So far so good! (Though i wouldn't be surprised if download speed drops to 0.85mbps in the future, as they start imposing the speed limit).

cya
R

[Cyrus43]

This is What I got!! PATHETIC!!! And Im paying 2400 P.M.

[nishantgandhi]

^ this looks impossible. I am on the 512 kbps UL plan for Rs 999 pm and I get about 50-53 kbps download speed on torrents!

Even right now, when some downloads are on, this is the speed that I am getting:

[trrk]

Hi,

This is what a 2MBPS / 4Gb connection with BSNL has given me.



I am lucky as this hardly has seen any downtime.

[Cyrus43]

This is getting ridiculous!!

[NetfreakBombay]

Do you use parallel connections for phone?

Specifically, do not split phone line before ADSL.

[gomzi]

Originally Posted by NetfreakBombay

Do you use parallel connections for phone?

Specifically, do not split phone line before ADSL.

Do you mean using the same phone line for internet and landline phone? I'm doing that and facing problems with it. such as low speeds, internet connection keeps getting disrupted when phone is used and so on.

So now i've decided to resurrect an old "on hold" mtnl line I had and use that exclusively for internet access. Will that help?

unfortuantely, where I live MTNL is the most reliable ISP. All others that I have tried are either very very slow or unreliable.

[nishantgandhi]

Originally Posted by Cyrus43

This is getting ridiculous!!

Whats the problem now? Are you on a 512 kbps connection? If yes, the above reported speeds are normal.

Originally Posted by gomzi

Do you mean using the same phone line for internet and landline phone? I'm doing that and facing problems with it. such as low speeds, internet connection keeps getting disrupted when phone is used and so on.

So now i've decided to resurrect an old "on hold" mtnl line I had and use that exclusively for internet access. Will that help?

unfortuantely, where I live MTNL is the most reliable ISP. All others that I have tried are either very very slow or unreliable.

Dont have to follow the on hold method. If you are on ADSL, the entire logic is to be able to use the phone line simultaneously for voice and data.

Just get a an ADSL splitter. It costs just 30-50 bucks. One wire goes into it from your main (wall) line. Out comes 2 wires, one of which shall go into your ADSL modem/router and the other shall go into your telephone. Simple.

And remember, if you have parallel telephone lines, using that at the time when you are surfing shall slow down internet speeds massively.

[Cyrus43]

Originally Posted by nishantgandhi

Whats the problem now? Are you on a 512 kbps connection? If yes, the above reported speeds are normal.


Dont have to follow the on hold method. If you are on ADSL, the entire logic is to be able to use the phone line simultaneously for voice and data.

Just get a an ADSL splitter. It costs just 30-50 bucks. One wire goes into it from your main (wall) line. Out comes 2 wires, one of which shall go into your ADSL modem/router and the other shall go into your telephone. Simple.

And remember, if you have parallel telephone lines, using that at the time when you are surfing shall slow down internet speeds massively.

NO!! I am on a 2GB Scheme!!!! Thats the Point. And I have the Above config at home and the net disconnects when I pick the phone up from the bedroom line.

[yogi1771]

Mumbai users a new kid on the block and the plans are just too good just check it out,planning to shift from MTNL.
Nivyah

[gomzi]

Originally Posted by Cyrus43

And I have the Above config at home and the net disconnects when I pick the phone up from the bedroom line.

Originally Posted by nishantgandhi

Dont have to follow the on hold method. If you are on ADSL, the entire logic is to be able to use the phone line simultaneously for voice and data.

Just get a an ADSL splitter. It costs just 30-50 bucks. One wire goes into it from your main (wall) line. Out comes 2 wires, one of which shall go into your ADSL modem/router and the other shall go into your telephone. Simple.

I already have the splitter and for about an year, internet+phone worked fine simultaneously

A few months ago, the problem started wherein the internet kept getting disconnected when the phone is being used. The MTNL chappie made a few visits, but could not figure out why this was happening.

Which is why as the last option, i'm planning to resurrect the "on hold" phone and use it exclusively for internet.

[Akshay1234]

Originally Posted by Cyrus43

NO!! I am on a 2GB Scheme!!!! Thats the Point. And I have the Above config at home and the net disconnects when I pick the phone up from the bedroom line.

put a splitter in both places, where your internet is and where your phone is. also the internet should be on the primary line, and the phone on the parellel or secondary line, thats what the mtnl guy told me.

[Cyrus43]

BAABOING!!! thats the sound of everything Going Bouncer. Anyways, Now that I have all the time in the world to spare..(yeah right!!!!) I am getting an all new line installed. I have had just about enough of this nonsense!!

EDIT:

Nivyah

This looks Interesting!!!