Hi All,
To keep things plain and simple, I am in the market for a new car. I am willing to spend not more than Rs 4 lacs ex-showroom. Not set aside any budget for ICE. If it comes within this budget, I take it, else I wait for when I can. No big hurry, and you will know the reason why. Putting my budget constraints aside, I think I would prefer a hatch(for good ol' Bangalore driving) though I am a sucker for big boots(read sedan). I need very good A/Cs of course. I hate the heat(willing to transfer to Antarctica if someone offers me a job there) and I use the A/C a lot. May not be at full blast, but to some extent anyway. I at least need to keep my legs cool.
Next, to give you a background of my current possession. I own a M800, bought second hand, since 2 years and I love the car and have not had any problem with it yet. I have out-dragged most small and mid-engined cars off traffic signals. I had test-drive a dozen cars and fit into only this one when I purchased it. Funny considering that I didn't want to be caught inside an M800 prior to falling in love with the car. Notwithstanding that, I do want to upgrade my car now.
Finally about me. I am all of 6 inches tall, and thanks to an overly active metabolic system(of late), I am now at 86 kilos. So I am quite well built, wider than most normal males of that size and I easily rub shoulders(literally) with my wife on cars such as a Wagon-R.
That being said, I have shortlisted, after reading umpteen articles, the A-Star. Right, now before your brows raise and your eyeballs roll upward, consider reading the rest of the post. Due to various likes and dislikes of the hundreds of models in the market today, I have taken this decision. Writing about what features in which cars I like and dislike would take at least 1 hour of your time and I don't think you have that much time to spend just to get me to select a car.
What I would like from you, to help me, is to be very very critical of what I have written below. This could be quite interesting actually. I have read all the negative points of A-Star on this post and I have countered those negatives. I have also written a couple of positives. Tell me how I am being wrong while deciding on the A-Star, while throwing me some good alternatives. I am considering the VXi badged model. Importantly, I want a new model from the market(< 2-3 years old) and not some old model re-hashed, re-furnished and re-engined. Have fun reading the most relevant part of this post below.
A-Star Advantages:
1) Interesting looks - The looks need to grow on you. I 'prefer' the looks, and in certain shades, looks stunning from certain angles.
2) Driveability - Rigid chassis, love the gearshift, well balanced steering wheel without being toy-car like (I need to feel the car when I drive)
3) Good equipment levels as standard - ICE on the VXi
A-Star Problems(as mentioned in the forum, as countered by me):
1) 3-pot rattles during Idling - Who are the ones who idle their car these days? Save petrol, save the environment, save the ppl behind your exhaust pipe. Switch off the engine when you are at a standstill.
2) Rear bench is cramped - 2 years with M800 and 9000kms gone by, never once sat on the back seat, driven < 100 kms with 4 passengers, driven < 500 kms with 3 passengers.
3) No boot space - Made < 10 trips to and from airport/railway station and managed just fine. Just plan in advance between taking co-passengers for seeing-off, or reserving one seat space for excess luggage.
Any other issues with A-Star? No way Jose, and it clean beats the even higher priced competition in all other areas such as comfort, drivability and value for money.
A-Star then it is for me. Per my use, and not per shortcomings which are irrelevant to me. I'd rather crib about the car 10% of the time, than rue not having bought the car I want 80% of the time I use it. The remaining 10% buffer is for those times when only an Audi A4 or a BMW 3-series would keep me happy.
Ok, waiting for some expert comments from you now. I need to finalize on this car in the next one month and I really really would like to arrive at the right decision.
Thanks in Advance,
Prashanth
blogs.prashu.com