Quote:
When I am putting my hard earned money on the table, I want to make sure that what I am getting is truly international standard or not.
|
All of us buy cars with our *hard earned* money pal, I wish we had money growing trees
Seriously though, a bit of advice :
Do NOT go merely by what you read on paper, wiki or stats. Think for a moment and gauge how relevant the product, whether old or new, is to you:
- A typical hatchback is driven 80 - 90% within the city itself. This is EXACTLY where the 1.4 TDCi is superior to the MJD, simply because of the absence of turbolag. The 1.4 TDCi is immensely more driveable in the conditions where you will be driving it the most.
- It's fuel efficiency matches or beats that of the 1.3 MJD.
- It's refinement is on par.
Of course, on the open road, the MJD will have better performance simply because it has more power. But again, where does a typical hatch spend more of its time? Would one logically choose an engine that suits the majority of its intended usage better? Logically, yes.
Don't get me wrong, insisting on the latest is a good thing. I like the 1.4 TDCi as much as I do the 1.3 MJD. However, we shouldn't be entirely blinded by the *newest* and ignore all other areas of practicality. As stated in my review, the Figo itself is developed on an older platform. However, as an overall car, it is superior to the Swift. It has more room (back is especially better), way better ride quality (Swift is stiff), excellent ride & handling and excellent driveablity (unlike the turbolag'ed MJD).
Now if you want to ignore all of those positive points just for "which is newer", go right ahead. We are here on Team-BHP for an educated opinion, not merely base our buying decisions based on stats.
Also, and continuing the discussion:
Quote:
When I am putting my hard earned money on the table, I want to make sure that what I am getting is truly international standard or not. If I see anything special being offered for the developing country only - not only the car but the car Mfg is also out of my list.
|
Well, your statements are self-contradictory then. NO hatch sold in India, save for the i20, is "truly international standard". Do spend some time comparing the poor fit, finish and quality of the Indian-spec Swift or Punto, that to their international counterparts.
Please remove all other Indian hatchbacks from your list immediately.
And yes, since you actually do want the *latest*, the Swift is NOT for you either. It's a car that's so showing its age. You should be favouring the Ritz instead. It's a hatch more modern than the Swift, and immensely more practical too.
Lastly, Fiat in 2009 has already introduced the newer gen of the 1.3 MJD that meets Euro V. By that, the one sold in India is already outdated (in your books, not mine).
If you only want to buy "international grade" products, be prepared to shell out a mean $$$ for that. Forget about buying any hatchback for 4 - 5 lakhs.
Quote:
Originally Posted by mohandas Again from the same source, Merc provides that age-old OM611 engine to the developing country only. |
Quote:
I could not get the point you are trying to make here. I though we were talking about TDCi and DDiS - not the OM611. Anyway, with the advance of technology, smaller size engine produces greater torque than the bigger old generation engine. For e.g. TDCi vs DDiS. 4V per Cylder of DDiS makes it more fuel efficient as well. So, anyway DDiS is better engine than TDCi.
|
The point I'm making is, irrespective of when the engine was developed, the one in the Mercedes C220 is still the SEGMENT BEST! It's got amazing power, durability, efficiency and refinement. If Mercedes can sell an old, but still very competent, engine in a 30 lakh car, why can't Ford in a 5 lakh car?
Change for the heck of change is not good. We shouldn't *blindly* go out for whats newest. Rather, we should evaluate whats best for us.
Quote:
I can bet lakhs on the fact that Swift will continue to outsell Figo. |
Of course it will. But the Swift also outsells the Ritz which is a better car overall. And a later model too. There's more to selling a car than just *which has the newest engine*!!