I used to have huger respect for a company of the stature of Maruti. This incident has shook me to the core. Some of my best professor fondly used to recall how the planned the project Maruti in 80s.
But this news is a quite a contrast from the socialist fabric on which maruti was built. Sure maruti has changed its cloths to suit today's capitalist world, but never in my dream i thought the change in clothes will change to company culture to such an extent.
On one side there is a character assassination of few Labor Leaders and on the other side the Company leaders are getting awarded "The Order of the Rising Sun, Gold and Silver Star" by The Emperor of Japan
Maruti Chairman awarded The Order of the Rising Sun by Japan - NDTV Profit
Don't know whom to favour but considering these labour Leader have taken additional risk and have put their life on stake; most likely these leaders are the ones Speaking the truth not the Maruti Management.
Who would have incentive to leak the news to other labors, it Can't be these guys, it has to be company officials leaking such news to character assassinate these folks. Not only they lost their jobs and got pittance for that, they also lost their reputation and chance to work with any other company. And in any case 16 or 40 Lakh rupees can't be and shouldn't be seen as bribery at all. With this money one can't even buy a Flat in Gurgaon which starts upward of 80 Lakh rupees these days. This can only be seen as severance pay so that these guys can start their business somewhere in the remote corners of the country. For a guy who can damage a company's loss to the extent of 2300 crores, 40 lakh or even One crore seems a small amount.
Now if we assume it is Maruti Management who has done this thing I have to assume that they are the worst management to not have heard any call of workers. Afterall, what else can a company lose if it accepts a simple demand of workers that they are looking for an "independent Union". I understand they run a risk of not able to manage their workers through probably already in-the-pocket labour leaders. Well thats a huge risk, but if true isn't that unethical in the first place.
As an Indian, I feel Disgusted that Management was talking to everyone else but never even cared to adjust to few demands by labours but looked more and more the cronies who are carrying out the orders passed from Japanese leadership. It not only lost 2300 crores of lost sale for its own Investors by not accepting a simple demand of one month of labour salary not deducted from workers ((1000+1500))*12,000 Rs per month= 3 Crore rupees Only).
For Consumers it gets worse from here. Now you have 1000 unsatisfied and annoyed workers making Cars on maruti assembly lines in manesar and another 1500 workers making suzuki powertrains; knowing fully well that not only none of their future demands will get fullfilled but also they can't risk choosing another leader to fight for them. Its the management that seems culprit here who lost 2300 crores of investors money by not heeding even the genuine demands of the workers.
As a customer I would not want to run the risk of buying cars from this company, knowing some key critical components might be missing in the cars which i can never figure out. (think Airbag Sensors Missing, which gets utilized just once in life and can be fatal)
I have to give in to the fact that this has been the worst possible example set for the corporate india by a stalwart.
I shudder to think that its a distinct possibility of having a real life replication of the opening sequences from AB starrer DEEWAR.
Disclaimer: I am secretly hoping I am wrong on all counts and corporate India takes only the good example from this incidence.