Your opinion needed. E-class or 5 series?

Mikeo · 25th April 2005, 14:07

My uncle in Germany, with whom I stay is planning to change his car. Currently he has a 745i and a Z4 2.0, which is most of the time with me. He bought the 7 in Feb `04, bought it from a used car mart. I heard that Beemer’s got great demand in India right? Will there be a lot of restrictions if we had to bring the car to India? And how much can this car fetch up in the market? It’s a 2003 model. Over here, the demand for a used 7 is pretty low.

And now that he is planning to buy either an E-class or a 5 series. Not a brand new one but a used one. I am getting mixed reactions from my friends over here. His priority is a comfortable ride, good interiors, reliable. Most of the time, he will be on he back seat and it’s only on Sundays when he drives the vehicle.

What do u experts say?

Steeroid · 25th April 2005, 14:11

Gimme 5! Anyday.

Obviously you will have to take into consideration local factors like maintenance costs, insurance, resale value et al.

He'll be on the backseat? I'm curious - dyou get drivers in Germany and are they affordable, or are you planning to do the honours?

Also, whats he going to do with a 7 and a 5?

Deeps · 25th April 2005, 14:23

The 5 series for sure. I'd pick hat for the looks alone. I too am curious about the driver aspect.

Since the car would be left hand drive, it'd be illegal to bring it to india. Others, cooreect me if i am wrong on this.

islero · 25th April 2005, 15:12

I would say 5-series too, just a more complete car and tons more exciting than the Merc. If you dont mind the looks, then go for it.

autopsyche · 25th April 2005, 17:18

Another vote for 5, the car is HOT, mercs are for sissies

Mikeo · 25th April 2005, 18:01

Wow, that’s quick response from you guys. Seems like the Beemer is too hot over there!!
But the local reviews over here say that the E class is more comfortable than the 5 series and the 5 is much better to drive and more sporty. And that is really confusing me, as my uncle ain't a sporty driver.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steeroid

Obviously you will have to take into consideration local factors like maintenance costs, insurance, resale value et al.

Resale value is higher for the merc.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steeroid

He'll be on the backseat? I'm curious - dyou get drivers in Germany and are they affordable, or are you planning to do the honours?

Nope, he is gonna use it as his company car, so company persons will be there to drive it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steeroid

Also, whats he going to do with a 7 and a 5?

He will soon dispose of the 7 and then would go for either 5 or the E. Or is there any other car with almost same specs?

bhp · 25th April 2005, 18:07

5 series all the way dude

ajmat · 25th April 2005, 18:19

For me, the 5 series but would look at a merc 320cdi - new engines , for him - merc is more appropriate. End of the day, 95% of us are armchair experts - you need to drive and decide - both are not bad cars - all depends on what suits you most closely

sridhar24 · 25th April 2005, 18:52

Its the beemer any day for me

Steeroid · 25th April 2005, 19:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike

But the local reviews over here say that the E class is more comfortable than the 5 series and the 5 is much better to drive and more sporty. And that is really confusing me, as my uncle ain't a sporty driver.

Thats correct. However, I dont think the Beemers have the reliability issues with electronics that the Mercs seem to have.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike

He will soon dispose of the 7 and then would go for either 5 or the E. Or is there any other car with almost same specs?

Audi A6 or A6S

Gordon · 25th April 2005, 20:11

After reading the topic about all the possible problems faced by Merc owners, I'd say the 5 Series.

Maverick5490 · 25th April 2005, 21:08

Hi Mike..
I am a BMW service engineer here.. so do know a bit about them.. well the problems faced by Mercs and Beemers are almost the same.. but the new 5 has got loads of complex electronics to make life simpler.. which it doesnt.. there are a few reliability issues.. but nothing that cant be solved.. and that too in Germany!! finally its ur verdict.. i would go anyday for the 5 as it has the young and sporty at heart appeal.. the merc is simply boring.. so if ur uncle is gonna have the urge for a kickdown.. thee beemer 5 has to be it..

Regards,
Maverick.

Mikeo · 25th April 2005, 21:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steeroid

Thats correct. However, I dont think the Beemers have the reliability issues with electronics that the Mercs seem to have.

That’s only the recent worldwide recall right? Here Mercedes have apologized for that and has made appropriate changes.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steeroid

Audi A6 or A6S

Forget the audi, I know its pretty decent car, but my uncle don’t like its front looks. Have to say that they have messed up the grille work. But I love the A8, have to be a winner in its class, but simply big and too expensive. The Merc CLS would suit perfectly for him but its expensive and you cant get that soon in used car mart.
What about Alfa Romeo? 456 or something? But again that too is a sporty car right?

Mikeo · 25th April 2005, 21:55

Thanks Maverick, as I have heard in here, there are little reliability issues concerning mercs and a little more concerning beemers, whenever we go for a software upgrade for the 7, we used to see couple of 5 series after having a breakdown. And my uncle is tired of this beemer, the 7, after spending a lot for maintenance.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Maverick5490

i would go anyday for the 5 as it has the young and sporty at heart appeal.. .

There’s the problem. My uncle is not anymore young and sporty at heart.

Mpower · 25th April 2005, 23:02

Although I am a BMW fan, if you want comfort then go for an E class with air suspension.
I would suggest going for the diesel E-320 CDI.

Also Merc is launching a new range of V6 diesels to replace their inline 5 and inline 6s.

25th April 2005, 14:07	#1
Mikeo BHPian Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: ger Posts: 9 Thanked: 0 Times	Your opinion needed. E-class or 5 series? My uncle in Germany, with whom I stay is planning to change his car. Currently he has a 745i and a Z4 2.0, which is most of the time with me. He bought the 7 in Feb `04, bought it from a used car mart. I heard that Beemer’s got great demand in India right? Will there be a lot of restrictions if we had to bring the car to India? And how much can this car fetch up in the market? It’s a 2003 model. Over here, the demand for a used 7 is pretty low. And now that he is planning to buy either an E-class or a 5 series. Not a brand new one but a used one. I am getting mixed reactions from my friends over here. His priority is a comfortable ride, good interiors, reliable. Most of the time, he will be on he back seat and it’s only on Sundays when he drives the vehicle. What do u experts say?
	() Thanks

25th April 2005, 14:11	#2
Steeroid Senior - BHPian Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: N.A Posts: 7,046 Thanked: 2,752 Times	Gimme 5! Anyday. Obviously you will have to take into consideration local factors like maintenance costs, insurance, resale value et al. He'll be on the backseat? I'm curious - dyou get drivers in Germany and are they affordable, or are you planning to do the honours? Also, whats he going to do with a 7 and a 5? Last edited by Steeroid : 25th April 2005 at 14:12.
	() Thanks

25th April 2005, 14:23	#3
Deeps Senior - BHPian Join Date: May 2004 Location: Delhi/Noida Posts: 1,119 Thanked: 170 Times	The 5 series for sure. I'd pick hat for the looks alone. I too am curious about the driver aspect. Since the car would be left hand drive, it'd be illegal to bring it to india. Others, cooreect me if i am wrong on this.
	() Thanks

25th April 2005, 15:12	#4
islero Senior - BHPian Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Chennai Posts: 1,574 Thanked: 13 Times View My Garage	I would say 5-series too, just a more complete car and tons more exciting than the Merc. If you dont mind the looks, then go for it.
	() Thanks

25th April 2005, 17:18	#5
autopsyche Senior - BHPian Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: New Delhi, Indi Posts: 1,519 Thanked: 35 Times View My Garage	Another vote for 5, the car is HOT, mercs are for sissies
	() Thanks

25th April 2005, 18:07	#7
bhp BHPian Join Date: Jul 2004 Location: lokhandwala mumbai Posts: 840 Thanked: 170 Times View My Garage	5 series all the way dude
	() Thanks

25th April 2005, 18:19	#8
ajmat Team-BHP Support Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Bangalore Posts: 15,061 Thanked: 29,723 Times View My Garage	For me, the 5 series but would look at a merc 320cdi - new engines , for him - merc is more appropriate. End of the day, 95% of us are armchair experts - you need to drive and decide - both are not bad cars - all depends on what suits you most closely
	() Thanks

25th April 2005, 18:52	#9
sridhar24 Senior - BHPian Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Bengaluru Posts: 1,048 Thanked: 89 Times	Its the beemer any day for me
	() Thanks

25th April 2005, 20:11	#11
Gordon Senior - BHPian Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Mumbai Posts: 2,549 Thanked: 496 Times View My Garage	After reading the topic about all the possible problems faced by Merc owners, I'd say the 5 Series.
	() Thanks

25th April 2005, 21:08	#12
Maverick5490 Senior - BHPian Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: Thane Posts: 1,470 Thanked: 1,844 Times View My Garage	Hi Mike.. I am a BMW service engineer here.. so do know a bit about them.. well the problems faced by Mercs and Beemers are almost the same.. but the new 5 has got loads of complex electronics to make life simpler.. which it doesnt.. there are a few reliability issues.. but nothing that cant be solved.. and that too in Germany!! finally its ur verdict.. i would go anyday for the 5 as it has the young and sporty at heart appeal.. the merc is simply boring.. so if ur uncle is gonna have the urge for a kickdown.. thee beemer 5 has to be it.. Regards, Maverick.
	() Thanks

25th April 2005, 23:02	#15
Mpower Senior - BHPian Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Bangalore Posts: 10,409 Thanked: 1,732 Times View My Garage	Although I am a BMW fan, if you want comfort then go for an E class with air suspension. I would suggest going for the diesel E-320 CDI. Also Merc is launching a new range of V6 diesels to replace their inline 5 and inline 6s.
	() Thanks