|20th June 2009, 22:24||#91|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Aug 2006
Thanked: 1,784 Times
I am wondering whether the poor fit and finish in the interior department is thanks to some tips from FIAT's business partner ? maybe they were told that its better to compromise on that department and offer a killer pricing which is ( at the end of the day ) what the Indian masses want !
Hows the turning radius/manouvereablity in the city ?
|20th June 2009, 22:37||#92|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Feb 2008
Thanked: 384 Times
Absolutely Brilliant Review Rush. You covered almost all the points. One question from my side:-
If you were in the market for a petrol premium hatchback , which would you choose among the 3 :- i20 , Jazz, Punto ( 1.2,1.4)?
|20th June 2009, 22:41||#93|
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Margao, Goa
Thanked: 780 Times
Last edited by pedrolourenco : 20th June 2009 at 22:42. Reason: Forgot the Dzire
|20th June 2009, 22:52||#94|
Join Date: Jan 2009
Thanked: 58 Times
Good review. The only major drawback about GP mentioned in this thread is the rear leg room.
In my Tiida hatchback, the rear seat can be moved forward and backward, in addition to being reclining, just like the front seats. Thus the rear leg room can be increased when the boot space requirement is minimum. The rear seat also has 60:40 split and center arm rest.
Fiat should consider providing this feature in GP in future updates. Then the GP would be a complete modern "big" hatch.
I have scanned in literature regarding this feature from the Tiida's owners' manual.
|20th June 2009, 22:52||#95|
Join Date: Jun 2008
Thanked: 291 Times
@GTO - Pls post photos of GP fully loaded, especially the back seat, with 3 on it or just 2 with the front seats pushed fully back... also photos of the black GP from different angles, just to drool on
|20th June 2009, 22:54||#96|
Join Date: Jul 2006
Thanked: 29,449 Times
The lower spec variant Emotion without the pack has 175/70-14 which must be having the bridgestone B250.
The Emotion pack is 195/60-15 so goodyear GT3.
The base active and dynamic is 165/80-14 but bridgestone does not have a tyre in that size.
|20th June 2009, 23:11||#97|
Join Date: Jun 2008
Thanked: 291 Times
Is there a noticeable difference in the front overhang?
Last edited by Sivasankar : 20th June 2009 at 23:28.
|20th June 2009, 23:14||#98|
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: NOIDA, Manchester & Cardiff
Thanked: 59 Times
A professionally written review GTO.
I had earlier test driven Linea. Well I found the interior material quality disappointing (poor to say the least). I was also put off by long throw gear lever and long clutch.
Interior ergonomics were also not proper. The bottom of centre console protruded too much for my liking and the instruments had a poor finish.
On the other hand exteriors were very well designed and finished. Paint and chrome quality was very good. So after admiring the car from outside when we sat in the car, the interiors were a let down as it did not jell with the high quality exterior.
The suspension and ride quality was impeccable as befitting a German or Italian car but engines were short of power.
After reading your review, I think most of the above is true for Punto also, which is sad. FIAT should have provided better quality interiors, better packaging and ergonomics to match the beautiful exterior. I dont think the price difference due to this would have been more than 20,000.
I think there is still a vacant slot for a perfect high quality hatch which the Punto could have filled. Jazz is out priced but will still sell due to Honda name, Fabia has been let down by pathetic service, costly spares and poor engines, some thing is amiss in i20 also and Swift is cramped and flimsly built.
All is still not lost yet. Let the current Punto carry on as a VFM package. FIAT can still grab that perfect hatch slot by providing more powerful engines, better packaging, ergonomics and better interiors. Rest of stuff is already there in the car. FIAT bosses should also understand that the Indian market is now maturing at rapid pace and there are plenty of customers who appreciate a high quality and powerful car and are willing to pay for the same.
Best of luck to Linea and Punto.
Last edited by akj53 : 20th June 2009 at 23:16. Reason: spelling correction
|20th June 2009, 23:18||#99|
Join Date: Aug 2008
Thanked: 18 Times
nice review GTO.your reviews seem to get better.( is this the third one that a manufacturer paid for all traveling expenses etc for the review.? waiting for plenty more to come!)
btw i would suggest that a thread be created in team-BHP reviews which contains all the links to the reviews you have done so far so that it would be easy for a person to make a decision about the cars he has considered.
moreover once a hype about a car dies out you have to go really back in the pages to read a review. Case in point is the ritz review which is not in the first few pages(ok some times it was in the first page) but anyways say after 6 months it will be difficult for a person who wants to make a car choice between say ritz and punto to search through the entire forum for that review.
hope this request is not too much to ask right.?
Last edited by amulu10 : 20th June 2009 at 23:20.
|20th June 2009, 23:22||#100|
Join Date: Feb 2005
Thanked: 2,132 Times
One things that irks me and puts me off completely is blanket statements like Tata Service is BAD. Sure they are not the best but its not bad. Even on our forum, I havent come across many cases where a disgruntled Tata customer has written an email and he/she hasnt been responded to. They have the best warranty replacements in the country (who would replace the whole front seat just because one of the springs inside was making a slight squeaky noise!)
Talking about my recent experience with ABS motors, as soon as the job card was opened on the Siebel CRM and promptly got an sms saying the same. The guys at Tata can see it and can also see what rating have you given them for the service. After the service was complete and the job card was closed, i got another sms saying that my car was ready to be picked up!
The following up was good too with 3 calls during the week ahead asking if I was satisfied with the service.The worst attitute I have seen is with Honda and their snobish dealers.
Last edited by extreme_torque : 20th June 2009 at 23:24.
|20th June 2009, 23:31||#101|
Join Date: Jun 2008
Thanked: 0 Times
GTO, thanks much for your efforts and yet another unbiased great review.
( Those are my first words here on TBHP and am excited ! First cry of a new born ? )
Back to main topic :
Two days before launch date :- heard a Punto made it to the showroom hear and tried to get a sneak peek and lurked around the yard with a Safari sales representative, but was in vain !
Day of launch :- Was planning to go to showroom right after work. But I managed to hit my head on a door and had to go to hospital to get a stitch. From there I went directly to showroom and was greeted by a Blue mini-Maserati. It was a stunner !
Imposing front drill and the tear drop headlamps is what catches the eye. I was not planning to buy a Punto and this is the first time am going to a showroom to see a vehicle on its launch date. But the spirit shown by TBHP-ians on the other Punto thread where the page count went to 50 odd from 20 got me pumped up, to go from hospital to showroom, instead of going home !
Sales rep. was wondering what is this guy doing with a white bandage on head. Loved the tank like build and the huge tyres on emotion pack and the 12 spoke alloys looked pretty nice. Came back home and told my cousin he is going to buy this once he see this ride. Like most of us, he was waiting to see how this will be priced and it perfectly was in his budget. But now the drive factor..
Very next day that sales rep. called telling TD vehicle is ready and we can go for a spin. ( maybe going there with a bandage made him feel am going to book one straight away ). Since I wanted to go with cousin, it was scheduled for Saturday.
Made arrangements with the rep. to bring it home to see how it fits in our garage and thanks to him, he agreed for that
Today :- At sharp 9.30, black beauty was here. A 1.3 MJD emotion pack. Cousin took the first chance while I enjoyed the vast leg room in front seat.
Skipping elaborating the drive, since we do have a far far better review from GTO
Jotting down some points.
Too many to write.
Most points already covered by all seniors in both Punto threads
While driving to showroom, even when her tank was full, needle was still at E(mpty). Representative said, vehicle has to be re-started ( like a Windows machine? ) to show correct status. Am not sure, but I believe even after a restart later, it showed same "E". So may be it takes 5-7 minutes. ( or the needle was faulty ? )
Final verdict, as GTO said, more like a heart's buy. Should be fun to drive on long highways than to take it to city. If it is a heart's buy I need, I still think of proceeding with my Safari dreams. and not comparing hatch to a SUV
|20th June 2009, 23:32||#102|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Jan 2008
Thanked: 391 Times
Fantastic review GTO! Almost all my doubts have been cleared, particularly the highway manners.
I took a short TD myself today at Concorde Motors, Mysore Road, Bangalore. It was 1.4 P Emotion+variant. The drive was short as there wasn't much fuel left in the car.
I actually wanted to see electric blue, but they didn't have that with them. I will have to try with other showrooms. Delivery time is around 4 weeks.
I will take a few more TDs and then decide when (not if) i am going get this beauty.
It looked like the people at Concorde weren't keen on selling anything, be it Fiat/Tata. I hope everyday isn't the same there.
|20th June 2009, 23:36||#103|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: May 2007
Thanked: 1,943 Times
Any car with less than 4 mtrs. length, less 1.2L petrol motor and less than 1.5L diesel motor will be eligible for tax concessions.
|20th June 2009, 23:37||#104|
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: New Delhi/Gurgaon
Thanked: 26 Times
Absolutely mind blowing review!
I wish I could write as well as you can
If I plan to buy a next hatch it as to be RED PUNTO MJD + Petes. Period.
|20th June 2009, 23:48||#105|
Join Date: Apr 2004
Thanked: 236 Times
Very well-written review. a big thank you for that!
I have 2 questions-
1)You were not impressed with the gear-shift.how would you compare it with the Palio 1.6?also was the rubbery shift quality too much of a bother?
2)is the pcd of the grande punto 100 or 98(as in other Fiats?)
@Sivasankar-right from the time i saw the car i had got a feeling that something was odd in the front when compared to photos of the car in other parts of the world