Quote:
Originally Posted by geek Please let me know if there is another car worth considering in this category except Baleno.......the looks are too dated |
The Baleno would meet most of your priorities like low maintenance, good FE etc and is a fun car to drive too. But then, since looks are a priority for you and you find its looks dated, it is ruled out. The other cars are the Petra, Indigo etc, but they are no lookers either. The Fiat Adventure station wagon is also a good car - great looks, nice build, etc. But then FE is pretty low.
Quote:
Originally Posted by geek Already done the analysis......I save approximetely Rs 20000 over a period of 7 years if I buy Honda city considering the initial cost difference and difference in fuel cost. |
Curious to know how you arrived at this figure and the inputs used (like respective FE for both cars etc).
Quote:
Originally Posted by geek I dont know the difference between the resale price or maintenance cost of the 2 cars so that has not been consiedered. |
Resale would be higher for the Honda and comparitively maintenance would be lesser.
Quote:
Originally Posted by geek Looks ................ Yes Definitely |
Looks are subjective and you would be the best judge. I find both of them drab.
Quote:
Originally Posted by geek Maintenance Cost. Yes that is a factor....what would be the the annual difference in maintenance cost of the 2 cars |
Don't have exact figures. But a recent issue of ACI (Nov'05, I guess) has a comparo of spares cost for C-segment cars. Have a look. I don't own either of the cars, so can't be authoritative. But from what I read here and from guys I know that own Ford (Ikons), I would rate the Ford to be higher in maintenance costs.
Quote:
Originally Posted by geek FE..................... Yes but as I said I save only 20000 over a period of 7 Years |
NHC is the clear winner here.
Quote:
Originally Posted by geek Safety Features... I think both the cars should be up to the mark as far as safety is conerned |
Not really. Fiesta scores here with quite some safety features that are absent in the NHC.
Quote:
Originally Posted by geek Resale Value....... Yes that is important |
Honda would win here, but then quite a lot depends on the way the car was maintained.
Quote:
Originally Posted by geek Brand Value........ Both are equal from my point of view |
Honda is rated higher by most Indians. But if they are same for you, we could leave it at that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by geek Exciting to drive vs peaceful mind - Cant I get both?
Speed vs Mileage - I drive only 20% on the highway and the maximum speed would be 120 I guess
City driving vs Highway driving - 80 % city and 20% highway
Looks & comfort - Initially when NHC was launched I did not like its looks, but now I guess I am used to the car. Fiesta, on the other hand, has a very masculine look. Also I found Fiesta more comfortable
Ride and Handling The power steering of honda was good but overall the Fiesta was a pleasure to drive |
With majority of your driving in the city, and max speed of 120, if I were in your shoes, I would go for the NHC, which is a city car, gives best-in-class FE, has lower maintenance costs etc etc. But then, I don't like its looks, which was why I did not go for it and instead got myself a Baleno.