i am at a dilemma to get my new car.
a bit of history.bought my ANHC last year how ever was never comfortable with the car primarily because i was shifting from a Sierra and the elevated driving position had become a sitting in a hole position with the Honda, not to mention a negative road presence with people simply getting into your way at every opportune moment.lack of front bonnet visibility to mention. leading to some heart wrenching scrapes.simply put never felt comfortable with the Honda despite it being one hell of a car for a Sunday drive, or any place where the density of traffic would be less. the moment i step out of my residence the gate exits into half a kilometer of traffic which is waiting for the signal to turn green. competing with auto two wheelers and what not.so went back to using my sierra.
Anyway currently looking to buy a new car.had only one and only one car in my mind the Godzilla fortuner nothing else. test drove it was reasonably happy no other car even within the horizon. found a few flaws with the car will leave that for later. saw an article on the web for upcoming cars and there was the BMW X1. hm-mm this was in early November decided to wait and watch. come december the car was launched went and had a look at the wanna be SUV now stuck to deciding between either the fortuner or the X1.would like to have opinions on the X1 from people here. i need to get the car by May. getting the fortuner isn't a problem due to contacts can skip the waiting period. have listed some points as to why i like the fortuner and the X1 would love to hear opinions. had some questions to the X1 had now where appropriate to post them. so will list them here.
Foruner: Pro's
Godzilla on the road.
Pedestrians two wheelers,4 wheels running for their lives.
Sierra like road presence.
Partial head turner these days.
3 Liter
126 kW @ 3600 rpm (171 PS @ 3600 rpm)
Torque 343 Nm @ 1400-3400 rpm
near 2000kg
Full time 4 wheel drive
0-100 12.74 seconds
Ladder on Frame
True SUV
Supreme of road capabilites
Mileage gathered from tbhp City 7-8 highway 12
7-8 seater
Bullet proof reliability
Toyota service experience
Lower maintence service cost
Will outlast the owner
Rear ac vents
Way better leg rooon
CKD
Manual transmission
Suv driving Dynamics Boat like
tops out at 174 kmph
Cons
Spartan Innova interiors
Mileage VS the X1
Waiting period : not relevant
Braking issues : resolved to which extent unknown
Unfriendly vibrating gear knob
Not Liked by my better half hence looked at the X1 initially
X1
Only theoretical data
Con's
BMW estate for practical reasons badged as an baby suv/ crossover
No off road capability
cost of ownership experience
New unknown unproven
Hype
4 service stations in south India, i think.
Run flat tyre problem
Sitting in a hole feeling with rear seats
Lack of rear leg room
Comfortably seats 4
Styling Subjective
Quality of plastics poor
No i drive on the CE edition
Negative road presence with the car vs Fortuner.
Hatchback
Pro's The most important factor to me complete Front bonnet visibility
it's a BMW & German Factor!!!
fully electrically adjustable seat's
0-100 8.3 / 8.4 seconds
Tops out at 205 kmph
Halogen corona rings on CE edition
Automatic transmission without Paddle shift/ sports mode
(Six-speed Steptronic transmission Made by ZF
ZF manufactures for other cars, like Audi, Volvo,Jaguar)
Ipod compatabile factory ICE
6 Airbags
Fancy electronics
? Steering better
? stiffer ride quality
Liked by my better half
Arai mileage 15.4
177 Bhp
Maximum Torque 350 Nm at 1700-3500 rpm
On road all inclusive price of 26 lakhs registered at pondycherry
Due to time constraints have to make a choice quick, even if it means booking an X1 without a Test drive!
Looking for Opinions from current BMW owners with regards to Price, Negotiating lower price during paying a booking amount.
General happiness with your BMW purchases. Service Experience
Anything i need to know before buying a BMW
as for the foruner enough threads & posts exist to get a genuine feel of the car. as advised before by another member i need to make my own informed decision with regards to my needs best suited to me. how ever It would be my last opportunity to start a What car thread for some time. last time i bought the ANHC i didn't
.
Gladly Waiting for opinions and finer points
Am currently Looking 80 % at the X1 20% for Godzilla Post X1.
100% for the Fortuner Pre X1 Era.
For those of you who swear by Toyota reliability, yes agreed anyone who owns a Tata sierra know what that means compared to normal people.
Not interested in the CAPTIVA / CR V / SANTA FE / OR ANY OTHER CAR!
Discussion is limited as to why i should be buying the Corp edition X1 or not.
Questions
1) how feasible is it to replace run flats with tubless
2) Any one else seen the Car at the showroom your comments
3) Engine performance vs other cars/ Suv/ A4 / Superb
am i right in saying the engine is good
4) Can i consider an arai figure of 15 for an automatic to be good in real time city driving
5) How much can i expect as no claim bonus from my 1yr used ANHC
5) Any other bad news