Motard_blr and honeybee, please go through this first and then read my answers to your questions.
Methods of crosswind landings
There are two usual methods of accomplishing a crosswind approach and landing—the crab method and the side slip method.
Crab Method
The crab method is accomplished by establishing a heading (crab) in the direction of the wind with the wings level so that the aircraft’s track remains aligned with the centerline of the runway. This can be confusing but try to understand. The nose points in a different direction but the aircraft keeps itself aligned with the centerline. This crab angle is continued until just before touchdown, when the longitudinal axis of the aircraft must be aligned with the runway to avoid sideward contact of the wheels with the runway. The objective of this technique is to maintain wings level throughout the approach, flare, and touchdown.
The crab method has one other variation called crab touchdown. In this method, the aircraft can land on using crab only i.e. without the removal of crab angle. This is recommended on only slippery runways. Landing the airplane using crab only reduces drift toward the downwind side at touchdown and permits rapid operation of spoilers and autobrakes because all main gears touchdown simultaneously. This method puts excessive force and side load on the gear.
Side-Slip Method
This method ensures that the aircraft’s ground track and longitudinal axis are aligned with the runway centerline throughout the approach and landing. This method prevents excessive side loads on the landing gear. We align the aircraft’s heading with the centerline of the runway and then apply drift correction by lowering the upwind wing. This causes the plane to turn in that direction. Then we use the rudder for directional control. The drift is controlled with aileron, and the heading with rudder. The aircraft now side slips is such a way that both the heading and track are aligned with the centerline.
Side-Slip method Quote:
Originally Posted by Motard_Blr 1) Can the pilots actually see the runway and is it necessary to be able to see the runway?
2) How do you judge the distance of the main landing gear to the ground to know when to return the rudder to the centre?
3) With the main landing gear at an angle to the runway and the direction of motion and the fact they are not castors, aren't they subjected to huge forces when the tyres make contact with the ground? If so, would there a limitation on the number of cross wind landings before major parts need to be changed?
Thanks! |
1. Having visual contact with the runway is a requirement. If we cannot see the runway at the DA(H) - Decision altitude or height, we have to go around.
2. As said earlier, rudder is not always returned to the center when the aircraft touches down. In fact, on the 777, the rudder is used for directional control till the speed goes down to 30 knots. Remember that the rudder also controls the nose-wheel steering upto some degree.
3. In the first paragraph of this post, I have stated that crab landings, the one in which crab is not removed even on touchdown are used only in slippery conditions. If there is a landing in which the aircraft touches down very hard or with excessive side loads on the gear, the gear is inspected thoroughly for any damage before the aircraft departs for the next leg.
Quote:
Originally Posted by honeybee A couple of questions: I see a couple of planes very close to landing, but still deciding to go around, one even had its main wheels on the tarmac before it lifts off again and goes around. What gives? I can understand a few feet above the ground it's all shaky, but once on terra firma or within inches of touching it, should one go around?
I read in one of the posts above that while landing in a crosswind situation the nose of the aircraft may be pointing somewhere else, but the undercarriage is aligned with the runway - How do you do that? The only analogy I have is of beat-up and chassis-damaged vehicles with their body/nose pointing a few degrees right or left compared to the wheels. How do you do that in a modern airplane?
Sorry, a third question - On touchdown, do you guys just kill the power/throttle, like go from 40% power to zero or something? Would that help in reducing the speed (and in turn the lift) and help keep the aircraft 'down' on the tarmac?
Part of the third question above, really - with flaps out during the landing approach, you get more lift at reduced speeds. Also at touchdown, there are 'brakes'? or some flaps which are raised 'above' the wings to brake the speed. At this point, would it help to retract the flaps back in to prevent generation of lift, which would lift the aircraft again in air? Or do you NOT do it just to allow you to go around even after a touchdown? |
1. Yes, if you run out of rudder authority or don’t feel comfortable attempting the landing, you can and you should go around. During an automatic go-around initiated at 50 feet, approximately 30 feet of altitude is lost. If touchdown occurs after a go-around is initiated, the go-around continues.
2. Read the first paragraph about the crab landing.
3. The thrust levers are reduced to idle before touchdown. Then reverse thrust is applied upto a maximum speed of 60 knots, since it isn't effective below that speed. Then it is slowly reduced upto REV IDLE till we reach 30 knots taxi speed, at which point we shut the reverse thrust off.
4. Settling down the aircraft down on the runway is the job of the speedbrakes or the spoilers, what you're calling the "some flaps which are raised 'above' the wings". The speedbrakes spoil the lift from the wings, which places the airplane weight on the main landing gear, providing excellent brake effectiveness. Normally, these spoiler/speedbrakes are armed and as soon as a touchdown is sensed by the weight on wheel sensor, these are extended automatically. In case it does not extend automatically on touchdown, we have to do it manually.
Flaps are not retracted since they take a lot of time to retract and extend. By the time you retract them completely from full flaps to 0, you would've completed your landing roll. Also important is the go around requirement. It is much better to use the spoilers.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nempuguru Little OT! If experts here could brief little on this topic. Mods please delete this post if it is irrelevant. |
I will be answering these questions in the Egyptair 804 thread in Shifting Gears forum.