Quote:
Originally Posted by gsferrari Unlikely. Cars will only get more expensive over time, not less. |
Yes. That's why I used the word rational. Almost everything gets expensive but a 5% increase vs a 20% increase when inflation is at a 10% has two very different meanings in terms of increase. Relative Vs. Absolute.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gsferrari as did many of us here as well. |
The point was to underscore my intent and not serve as a comparison to what anyone else did.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gsferrari The problem with conspiracy theories is that the believer stops focusing on what should be important to him/her and gets sidetracked by imagination and speculation. |
I have worked in marketing and communications and thankfully aware of seeding, astroturfing and community management. If anyone believes that corporate giants aren't actively managing online chatter, I would consider them blissfully unaware at best.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gsferrari Nobody likes the pricing. Those who have come to terms with it are just moving on either by cancelling or continuing with their bookings. |
Which I did and got another car. However if there is a point of view that I want to express I don't think anyone rational would ask me to "shut up and move on". We see enough throttling of opinion nowadays to have another space where you'll be cowered into silence. Let's not go there.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gsferrari "Feelings" don't drive an industry. Hard cash and bottomline is everything. The cars are still selling and the exponential inflation boggles the mind. Are salaries also increasing with similar trajectories? When a Wagon R nudges 10L rupees you have to question the value of the currency. It is very quickly turning into toilet paper. Great for a "make in India" export centric market. |
I agree with currency devaluation but are automotive prices mirroring inflation trends? In absence of hard data, it's your word against mine so debating this would be useless. I will hold on the my
opinion that cars are priced ridiculously right now.
I've worked in real estate for a bit and was able to witness the crash and burn of the industry after the 2008-2013 bull run. I see signs of plateauing growth and even degrowth in the auto industry. Won't be as spectacular. But the signs are all there. (Again, it's an outsider's view, and if I were so brilliant I'd already have an SL. I don't.)
Quote:
Originally Posted by gsferrari I don't think anybody likes this. Even for Maruti it must be disconcerting if 30K bookings turned to 20K cancellations on the day of the price announcement. I don't think that's what happened but what if that had happened? The low volume of production and long waiting times is there so the factory can absorb these potential shocks. If it doesn't happen, the brand value is perceived to be higher as it "appears" there is high demand for the product. In both cases the manufacturer wins. |
Fool me once...
Strictly speaking for myself.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gsferrari So you would automatically perceive a message posted by someone tagged as an employee (direct or indirect) of MSIL as dishonest? |
Dishonest is not the word I will use. Influenced? Absolutely. Coloured? Yes.
It'd be naive to not expect otherwise.
Exceptions will exist, but we don't navigate by exceptions.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gsferrari Just trying to understand where you stand on this. Had Behram Dhabhar sir been around this discussion would have taken a very interesting direction. |
I think I have made my stand amply clear.
Also, this could potentially turn into needless needling while a certain gent in his faux camping jacket will be grinning at the amount of chatter being generated for his product.
If I may suggest chatting about this over frothy beverages if you're around these parts?
I keep coming back to this thread because, and I don't know why, I feel like having been taken for a ride by MSIL. Which has had the same reaction of hitting a huge pothole on one of our highways. I should have expected it, but it pisses me off regardless.
This far and no further. Unless I buy this car in the future, I swear off this thread here.
