Re: Tata Nano Twist XT : Driven Booked a Dazzle Blue XT this week at Concorde SouthEx in Delhi. Hoping to get the delivery this weekend.
Shortlisting criteria below:
We own an Indica Vista and a Fiat Punto in Bangalore. Since moving to Delhi I have been trying to figure out which car to get for myself as a daily city rover. I was highly attracted to the Zest XT, however decided against it because of the price point and since most of my driving would be intracity. Generally speaking I loathe MS for having a paper like build quality (though I will admit they have improved the quality of their vehicles over the past ten years). I also have a personal criteria that says that I should buy only from companies that have Indian shareholdership and that manufacture in India.
I looked hard at the alto, the estilo, wagon r, the nano, the indica and finally the celerio. I am 5'10 and find getting into the alto a hassle and so I ruled that out. I ruled out the Indica since it is nearing the end of its lifecycle and I intend to keep my city rover around for a while so I would prefer to get a vehicle that will continue to be in production while I am using it.
The estilo, celerio and wagon r are both good cars, however given the internal space they run about par with the nano for me. The significant advantage they have is engine power and more boot space.
So my major concerns with regard to the nano vs these three cars were:
1. Can I zip around the city in a nano or will I feel like I am trying to drive a TVS XL on a highway?
2. Would the boot space meet mine (and the wife's) requirements?
3. Would the creature comforts of the Nano meet mine and the family's requirements.
Enter the test drive: I had discussed all the details and pricing options with the Concorde motors sales dude. He had come to my office and had called for the TD mule to be brought to my office. We went down and were standing at the gate and this white coloured mini pocket rocket screeched to a halt opposite my office. I could not believe that it was the nano since I have normally seen it being sedately driven by uncles, aunties and lady drivers (Yes I have a bit of a speed demon in me).
Took the car for a test drive ---- ooh the space was just perfect - not anywhere near the roominess of Basanti - my Indica Vista, but still enough that I didnt feel like I was driving with my hands scrunched up against me.
I was able to zoom up to 70 in ring road traffic at 7 pm, but had to brake due to traffic. Braking power was sufficient, though I don't see myself willing to do a hard brake at 120 (pipe dreams due to the 105 speed limitation).
AC was decent. Music system was decent. Gear action was good but could be better.
I decided that it was time to give it the acid test. I had my wife take a test drive the next day. Before I sent her for the test drive I listed all the negatives:
1. 624 cc engine - basically underpowered compared to the santro, the indica, the alto, the celerio, the wagon r, the i 10............and the list goes on (It does beat the Peele P50 however).
2. Boot space is minimal. Access is through the back seat.
3. Drum brakes.
With each item on the list her face turned more and more disapproving. I started making my peace with Maruti Suzuki or an Activa.
The next day when she took the test drive, she called me and went "I like it and I like the Dazzle Blue as well." I rushed to the showroom, booked it with the wife and mom hovering around.
Final price: 2.36 (Dazzle Blue XT, Mud Flaps, Floor Mats, 3 Yr comprehensive insurance, 3 Yr/30k AMC. (A note on the insurance: they give you 1 years insurance and 2 coupons for free renewals for the next two years).
Now keeping my fingers crossed and hoping to get the vehicle delivered by Sunday.
A few questions from my side to prior Nano XT owners:
1. Do you have any recommendations on things to watch out for during the PDI?
2. Does the AC work well in peak summer with 2-4 people in the car?
3. What is your servicing cost per 10000 kms working out to? |