Today around 1PM got a call from a friend that PALIO 1.3MJD has been launched and is available at TATA showroom. I didn't show much interest in it as the last 2 time when i went for 1.6 Stile Test Drive they didn't had the car. He checked with the dealer again and called me back that he has booked the test drive and he is coming by my office.
My friend arrives at 3PM and we head to TATA-Fiat dealer to check the car. I won't bore you with all the looks stuff as all have seen he car in flesh but i will do talk about interiors quality and fitments as i have never felt the NEW Palio interiors.
Interiors: I think it was the biggest let down for me at least. Fiat has gone TATA way. I was checking the top-end model and its interior quality was no way better than Swift or old Palio (blue interior). Plastic was tacky and it was giving TATA cars feeling. The beige is never my choice but to each his own. No complaints regarding car having beige interiors. Check the 4th pic for interiors fitments.
Handling / Comfort: Well no complaints in this section. FIAT as always a winner here notch above swift in handling / comfort and high speed stability. Touched 140 during the test drive. The full test drive was around 10 - 15 KM and everyone was comfy.
Engine / Refinement / Gear Box: Well this was not a let down at all engine is good but not as fast as swift or refined. The engine does the job quiet well. A little load can be felt when AC is switched on but the chilling AC lets u forget that. Only the one driving can feel the AC load. Engine picks up well after 1500 RPM and even though it says the torque kicks in at 2000 RPM you will not feel it until ~2200RPM (maybe because of the heavy metal build). I slotted the 5th gear @40KMPH (which is my test speed for every petrol or diesel car i drive for vibrations) and one can feel the vibrations on the floor, not like Indica V2 but yes there are vibrations. Slot the 5th gear at 50 - 60 KMPH and you can easily cruise upto 130. As i said it pick up pretty good after 1500 RPM.
Its in no way as fast as swift. I tried it many times and yes its dash must be around 15 secs to 100. Didint pay much attention as i like the handling of the car and was busy doing head to head with a safari. The road in which high speed test was done was curvy and bumpy and car gets 10/10 on that aspect. Max i could touch was 140 on that bumpy and curvy road and i would say the car still has the tank build as it was straight on line and i was still driving the car with 1 hand unlike swift which will need to hands on the steering at that speed. Even breaks were very good without ABS. Good job there FIAT
Gear box was not much to talk about i had problem slotting 1st and 3rd gear but only 2 times but yes still the problem is there. 5th gear was pretty smooth.
When i started the car i was clearly able to make out it was a diesel. There was clear sound inside the cabin during idling but on the move it was quiet smooth and felt like swift. One can even feel a bit of vibration on the floor. Not as refined as Swift.
Conclusion: A good car for anyone who wants alternative to swift (4 months waiting period here). Comes at 5lacs on road without ABS in Chandigarh. Where as Swift will need ABS which comes out to be around 5.45lacs on road Chandigarh. The price should have been less as Swift VDI (without ABS) is just Rs 20k costly than Palio SDX, but with a 4 months waiting.
Misc: The doors still shut with that THUD so its still tank like build. Fe will be good as Low fuel warning lamp was on while test drive and i even asked the Sales girl if that Fuel gauge was working or not. Engine is free revving as swift but don't over rev when u buy the car as its useless.
Two Disappointments:
1. Interior Plastic quality and its fitments.
2. Stupid Maruti dealers don't have SWIFT D for Test Drive. All the 3 dealers here in Chandigarh
. I wanted to test drive the swift after Palio for more detailed comparison but no test drive car available. On asking how the hell they are selling the car without test drive they say "Sir, its hot selling its same as petrol." I even saw people booking Swift D without test drive.
Any more questions just ask :-).
P.S. I like both Swift DDiS and Palio MJD and i do not own either of the cars . So the review is totally un-biased and what i felt and
i could be wrong too.