We are a family of four adults with two cars. One car does 80kms / day on an average and the other one does the city commute.
It swaps places as per the availability and requirement.
History of our cars can be seen in the below chart
Why do I need a car ? Getz Crdi
- It will be almost 8 years old soon.
- It has done 1,62,000 kms till date.
- It is running on the original clutch. Its hard now, but doesn't slip yet. Another 10k kms, it might surrender, My gut feeling is that replacing the clutch at this juncture would be like opening a can of worms resulting in many niggles here and there asking to be taken care of frequently.
- Hyundai parts are becoming expensive with each day.
- Hyundai Motor Plaza (Company owned workshop) has shut its operations in Delhi and other dealers around have no clue about Getz. Everytime i help them to find the correct part numbers.
- Minor Rust has started to creep in at some places and there is no solution other than repainting it everytime its pops up.
Ford Figo TDCI
- It is only 3 years old and 42,000 kms old.
- Absolute VFM car, niggle free experience till date and maintenance is cheaper than Maruti
- Best handling hatchback ever.
- It is not a great highway mile muncher thanks to narrow seats and a lazy engine past 80kph.
- For service, I need to travel 40kms for a service station. Atrocious ! Wonder how all the Figos and Ecosport people around manage this.
What do I want or plan to do ? - Replacement for Getz.
- Hatchback or a good handling sedan would do.
- Running would be 80kms daily and some highway trips to the hills or even a cross country. Would be running 25k kms in a year.
- Budget 8lacs ~ 12 lacs (Stretched)
- It has to be a diesel. (But, i'm confused after the proposed odd/even rule and diesel ban in Delhi)
- ABS mandatory.
- Good boot space to carry luggage for the trips.
- Good seats with support for long journeys
- Good Ground Clearance (>175)
- FE 15 kmpl or more
What are the options i see ? Polo 1.5 D
Best looking hatchback
Sweet engine.
Robust and good handling.
Why not ?
a) Emission scandal
b) Maintenance and service parts cost is insane if something goes wrong.
c) No space for rear passengers
Maruti Ciaz
Another beautiful car
Loaded with all the features.
Reliable and Maruti service
Why Not ?
a) 4.3 m sedan to be driven alone daily in traffic. No sense to me.
b) 1.3 DDIS Engine is sedate for this car.
c) Tin can shell.
Maruti Baleno
Stunning looks.
Over loaded with features
Reliable workhorse from Maruti
Why not ?
a) Flimsy build.
b) Seats (Especially the rear) is pathetic.
c) Interior quality is ultra cheap.
d) NVH is average
Ford Ecosport
Sweet looking mini SUV
Good engine.
Robustness of a Ford
Why not ?
a) Current Ecosport might be at the end of life cycle. New one expected in 2016.
b)Another Ford in the house, with service center 40kms away. NO !
Ford Aspire/ New FIGO
Different and nice looking car
Amazing engine tune.(Tempting)
Features loaded
Why not ?
a) It ain't built like a FORD
b) Another Ford in the house, with service center 40kms away. NO !
c) Seats narrow like the old Figo.
Hyundai i20 Elite
Looks stunning
Features loaded
Premium finish inside out.
Top notch refinement (Best NVH for a diesel)
Why not ?
a) Waiting period 2 months
b) Service cost is crazy. Hyundai is looting customers these days.
c) Not a great handling car. (Steering feedback is disappointing)
Maruti Scross 1.3 Alpha (Top end)
Spacious
Features rich
Premium build quality unlike any other Maruti.
Handles well
ABS and 4 disc brakes
Why not ?
a) 1.3 DDIS engine is sedate for a 11 lac car
b) Boring looks
Maruti Scross 1.6 Delta (Base model)
Engine made me grin like I did 8 years back while test driving the Getz Crdi.
Premium build quality unlike any other Maruti.
Handles well
ABS and 4 disc brakes
Why not ?
a) Price
b) Price
c) Price
d) No Auto AC
e) No Alloys
f) No Projector headlamps
Please suggest if I'm missing out some cars and help me solve the car buying puzzle.
Also, the Delhi rule of odd/ even number cars and diesel ban has made things even worse for me.
Thanks in advance.