Quote:
Originally Posted by theEnd I'm sorry to brink it up again but it would be great to hear how that shootout went down. Maybe just a brief summary (since its probably not fresh in your memory anymore). |
Briefly, here goes...
Nakamichi CD700mkII - Overall a very balanced, very old school sound, kinda analogue... if you know what I mean. Great natural sounding midbass, warm mids and highs. Lows are tight and defined and while highs lack detail at the top end, its still very pleasant sounding. No processing, simple tone controls, and a simple interface. Soundstage was The transport is a bit scary though as the mechanism is a bit complex and thus prone to issues if not maintained well.
Panasonic CQ-TX5500 - A surprise package, the Panny Bottlehead has a very warm yet lively representation of music. It sounds natural and has a overall lush feel to it. A a very laid back feel if you will. It plays MP3 so thats a bonus, though it only does upto 256K VBR I think. Its a bit fussy with some CD-R media but original CDs work just fine. This is the kinda source that lets you play almost anything and makes it sound good. Again, no processing apart from basic tone controls. Soundstage is reasonably wide and centered very well. The gold Jap Hi-Fi look and the tube glow are something one either likes or doesn't. Either ways, a great HU.
Kenwood K-CD01 - This Kenny was again a surprise. Using the same DACs as other more expensive HUs, this one has the most basic build quality in this group. No copper chassis, normal pigtail RCAs. Only the front faceplate is brushed aluminum and the knobs, buttons are of nice quality. The Kenwood has a more tighter sound than the above two. Its more controlled, detailed and upfront. Highs are detailed and open. Again, no processing etc but puts out a great soundstage thats both high and wide. For the price this one is a no brainer. Probably the cheapest serious SQ unit you can buy.
Alpine 7998 - We were expecting a lot from this unit and it didnt let us down completely. Excellent build quality and features. Copper Chassis, VFD display, 3way active crossover, TA etc. That said, it was against some very tough competition and in the sheer SQ front, it didnt do so well. Even the Kenny was a ahead with a fair margin. Bass was a bit muddy and exaggerated, while mids and highs were anylytical and a bit cold. Soundstage was nicely centered and reasonably high, though nowhere near the best we heard in this test. This one didnt really impress us as much as we thought it would.
Clarion HX-D2 - This was one of the units we had the most experience with. For the test we ran it in DIRECT mode which switches off the processing. The soundstage was among the best in this test. Mids and Highs were again the best in this test, even if they do sound a bit Digital. Low Bass is one area where the unit has less than stellar performace. Sub bass almost always sounds a bit "delayed". It also has a tendency to be cold and analytical at times, and will make bad recordings sound just as bad as they are. Not very forgiving that way.One fix is to use one of the other preouts for sub as that sounds much better. The transport and lens also deserve a special mention as they are the most robust we have seen. We have seen this unit play CDs that no other would. The unit can do 4way active with TA, GEQ/PEQ and a lot more. This is the best built unit in this group and by far the most flexible (processing wise).
Pioneer 9400MP - A japanese built Pioneer, this one again used to be fairly expensive in its time (2002/3 I think). This unit actually performed better than the Alpine 7998 on most counts. But was bettered by the Kenny overall. A nice HU overall with a pleasant presentation and nice transport. The built quality was great (by today's standards).
This is how we would rate the best in this group:
Best Overall SQ HU: Clarion HX-D2
Best VFM SQ HU: Kenwood K-CD01
Best SQ HU: Panasonic CQ-5500TX
Disclaimer:
- I dont represent any brand mentioned above.
- Tests were done over few days, weeks.
- A very wide variety of music was heard.
- All HUs were level matched.
- Listening tests were done in home, and again in car.
Hope this helps...
Cheers!