Re: Malaysian Airlines Boeing 777 (MH370) goes missing I have seen various questions on the mobile phone on this plane and how they could be traced etc.
I wrote the below on an aviation forum. Hopefully it provides some insights into Mobile Phone and Mobile Network capabilites. I have tried not to use any real technical jargon.
Couple of things on the various mobile phone myths surrounding this tragic incident.
As pointed out earlier, the fact that you hear a ring tone, doesn't necessarily mean the mobile phone on the other end is ringing. It could be just the network. People still sort of think as a mobile call is a sort of one to one connection. It is, of course, but through a complex maze of routers, switches, fiber, microwave connections and various other radio frequencies. It all zero's and one's.
It is technically feasible or possible to be in range of a mobile network at say 35.000 feet. It is just not very likely. Mobile Network Operators want to provide radio coverage on the ground, not in the air. So typically your antenna's are pointing downwards. By the way, just because you see the antenna's mounted on the towers vertical doesn't mean they radiated evenly along a horizontal axes. We use electronic tilt. Radiowaves being radio waves and propagation will mean you get coverage in various spots, including at 35000 feet. A lot will depend on the technology and the frequency used. The higher the frequency (e.g. 1800-2300 band) the less coverage you get. 800-900Mhz will reach much further. And the old 450Mhz systems such as NMT450 had an incredible range.
When I was based in the USA and piloting my own planes, such as Cessna, Cirrus, Diamond I did some testing. I think I wrote about it on this forum as well. Cant remember the exact numbers anymore. But in general you would not get voice or data coverage above 10-12000 feet. That doesn't mean it can't happen.
Mobile network are planned so that coverage is provided through contagious "cells". Once your mobile phone is properly identified in the mobile network the network knows in which cell you reside. It will also know which are the neighboring cells. As you move toward the edges of your cell, radio coverage will weaken and the system will decide to hand you over to the next cell. This all happens without us users knowing, its a seamless handover, providing the system is well optimized.
These cells are planned out on the ground, based on frequency planning, power output etc. Obviously, some of that radio energy will make it all the way up to 35.000 feet. However, at that altitude the same cells might not be present, so the system doesn't know to which cell you need be handed over. In such a case you would experience a dropped call and or data session. As long as you have coverage, you will be able to call again, but you are unlikely to experience smooth seamless handovers at those altitudes.
Depending on country, technology, competition and sometimes legislation, operators will or will not allow you to roam between them. So there might be a network and your phone will actually pick up its signal, but it is not allowed to attach/register itself. If that happens during a call or data session, again the call will drop. Cross country roaming is mostly not allowed and also has some legal challenges.
So, if a mobile phone is switched on and registered in a particular mobile network, it is known in which cell the phone is located. And of course, the operator will know where that cell is, geographically speaking. Depends a bit, but a cell could be several square kilometers or even larger to something only say 100 square meters.
Within most mobile networks there are technical possibilites to narrow down the location even further. Either through what is essentially triangulation or by the help of built in GPS in your (smart) phone. In some countries it is legal requirement for the mobile operator to provide precise location information with any call to emergency services (e.g. 911). So they immediately know your location.
All of the above is based on a known mobile in a known mobile network. Once you know the number you can start looking for it. If you don't know the number or you don't know the mobile network it becomes very tricky, proverbial needle in the haystack type of scenario.
The idea that you can simply trace a mobile phone that is switched on is therefor in practice a little bit more complex. Lots of articles these days on NSA capabilities. I have no idea of their capabilities other than what I can make up from the various news articles. As they tend to be written by journalists rather than Telecom and or ICT specialist I'm not so sure what they can or can't. But it seems they listen in to calls rather then actually physically locate a phone. Two very different things.
There is this persistent believe that mobile phones can be traced, even when switched off. In order for that to happen we need something akin to a Men on the moon conspiracy to make that happen. There are literally thousand of engineers involved in the specification, standardization and design of Mobile telephony systems.
What is true is that when you switch of your phone, the location where you switched off is likely to be known. You move away from that position with your phone switched off, nobody is going to be the wiser!
Jeroen |