As I have stated in my Intro thread, my research into buying a new car started from November last year (when I stumbled into team-bhp for the first time!) and, sadly, is still continuing.
After months of pain-staking research and almost finally deciding on the Grande Punto, I still have doubts over my final selection. This is due to combined factors which I have thought over, time and time again, related to sparing use, comfort of self and family, re-sale or no re-sale etc.
A bit about myself and my requirements -
I am a very sparing driver. My daily drives consist almost entirely of driving to my office and back (which is about 4 kms), and the occasional trips to the centre of the city, markets, relatives and back. And the very sporadic ride outside the city (maybe once every 6 months or so), usually for a company meeting or a wedding or an occasional trip for the holidays.
I own a Maruti 800 right now which, come July, will complete 5 years with me. Till now, it has done around 22,250 kms. The Apollo Aceleres it came with are still doing their faithful duty. Apart from the servicing and the occasional punctures and a side-indicator bulb blowout, it has been a trouble-free car. Touchwood!
What I am looking for - low maintenance, plenty of space to sit at least 5 adults, stress-free driving and riding experience, good FE, boot or no boot doesn't matter, a good-looking head-turner will be an added bonus.
My budget for the new car - 7 lakhs (max.).
The first point to ponder -
Diesel or petrol?
Numerous members have pointed out in several threads that if you are a in-city driver who drives less than 20 kms a day, petrol is the way to go. But with petrol prices touching Rs.70/ltr and slated to go more upwards within the next couple years, is it still feasible till assuming) it touches Rs.100/ltr by 2013-end?
Diesel cars need to be driven more (as the experts say), and require more maintenance, although the clatter and the sluggish pulls have become a thing of the past. The fantastic MJDs from Fiat have been wonderful in their refining, as is evident by most of the cars using it in their powertrains today - the TATAs, Swift/Dzire, and Fiat's own cars. Can a sparing driver like me who drives around 15 kms/day (max.) keep and maintain a diesel car?
Then came the models which I shortlisted, and here they are -
1) Figo - (+) Great car, loads of space and a wonderful diesel version.
(-) Looks are pretty bland, not a fan of the backlight cluster, rattling issues, cramped rear seat, Ford A.S.S., resale value unknown.
2) Polo - (+) Hot-looking (read HOT-LOOKING!), very peppy and proper 4-cylinder 1.6 engine, driver's car.
(-) Backseat is really cramped, Rear is rather-plain looking (like the old Zens), Lack of features in the top-end versions, cost of spares and ownership, resale value unknown.
3) Swift - Don't like it's looks plus a very common sight on the roads, and so, although a very good car (segment-leader actually), scratched from list.
4) Dzire - See above. I actually got a chance to TD one and felt cramped inside, that plus poor rear visibility made me back out. Scratched.
5) Indigo eCS - Common sight as the middle-class sedan and taxicab, VFM, bland looks, rubbery gearbox and no feedback from the steering. Scratched.
6) Etios - (+) Toyota brand, no-nonsense car, great suspension, driveability, biggest boot, space.
(-) Not a fan of the centre console, tacky plastics, plain looks from front and behind, resale value.
7) Punto - An example today which says love at first sight exists!
(+) Fantastic looker (even hotter than the Polo, excusez moi!), great MJD engine, awesome suspension and riding comfort, great load of features (including Blue & Me), a special driver's car if there ever was one.
(-) Cramped rear, tail-light cluster, cramped pedals, fuel guzzler (maybe), rusting issues, tacky interior parts, TATA's A.S.S. for Fiat cars, resale value.
8) Verito - Practicality over flashy, silent performer image.
(+) Plenty of space even in rear seat, big boot space, awesome suspension and riding comfort, nice driveability, a no-nonsense car if there ever was one, Mahindra brand.
(-) Outdated looks (the front resembles the Esteem! No wonder they compare Etios to this), rebadged-Logan, resale value, image of a tried-tested-and-failed car, taxicar image.
Most of the other cars like Beat, i10 and i20 I didn't really consider because I am not a huge fan of Hyundai and I didn't like the looks of Beat. Considered the Vento, Verna (the new Fluidic one) and also the Jazz but their pricing is beyond my range.
Out of the above listed, I have TDed the Figo, Polo, Dzire, Indigo, Etios and the Punto. Haven't TDed the Verito yet because the Mahindra showroom here hasn't got one yet (!). Friends suggested that a sedan meets my needs more than a hatchback because, apart from the Jazz, no other hatch has the kind of space and riding comfort I am really looking for.
Heart has been totally floored by the Punto (even the new Punto Evo sends my pulses racing). But head is trying to beat some sense into my heart. Ergo the dilemma.