Quote:
Originally Posted by shrvenkataraman Santro and i10 are off the list because of the Hyundai tag, very very bad petrol fuel efficiency as opposed to tiago or swift, also lack of space in the cabin as well as rear seat, among few other things.
So my budget is 6L max. That's one of the major constraints. |
Congratulations on your decision to opt for the Tiago and I wish you many years of enjoyable ownership and drives.
While I respect your comments towards Hyundai cars in general, and Grand i10 in particular, I would like to offer my opinion for the benefit of others who may have read about your views on the Grand i10.
We purchased a BSIV Grand i10 Magna on November 23 for considerable discount of Rs 85,000. The on-road cost was Rs 5.75 lakh and I got a further discount of Rs 1,25,000 as resale value of my old i10 2010 (1.48L kms) Magna 1.2L. As a result, my on-road cost was Rs 4.5 L for the Grand i10 Magna, which includes 5 year extended warranty. The Magna appealed to us as VFM as it had all the basic necessities on our checklist.
Regarding fuel efficiency, I must admit that FE figures would largely depend on the driving conditions and the driving style. By nature, I am a sedate driver and given the road conditions here in Goa, I almost always had an average of 17.3 kmpl (using top-up to top-up tests for over 200 times) on my i10 between 2010 and 2019 under mixed driving conditions.
I have, so far, done 900 kms on my new Grand i10 and two top-up to top-up FE tests have returned 17.5 kmpl and 17.8 kmpl. Again, under mixed conditions. So in my case, the FE is surely not bad at all for the two i10 siblings.
Regarding cabin space and back seat, I can't compare the Tiago and the Grand i10 as I never test drove the Tiago, as a Tata car was never on our list, given our concerns over long-term service and reliability. But we have been quite satisfied with the Grand i10 for our three-member family and the occasional fourth person.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bhatia.D17 As you mentioned above, I would like to know what mileage figures are you expecting.
I recently purchased Grand i10 Petrol and I am getting 11-13 kmpl in Delhi traffic which I find good for a Hyundai which has a bad reputation in FE.
My friend has achieved 15kmpl max in a Baleno for reference.
Grand i10 can be a good option for you in this price point if you require good space as well as good build quality.
Gi10 Nios Magna is priced around 6.5 L onroad if you are keen on getting a BS6 car.
Else BS4 models are being offered at 1L discount. So effective price of Sportz variant will be around 5.5- 5.7L.
No offense to respective owners of other cars.
Just my point of view. |
Fully agree.
Quote:
Originally Posted by shrvenkataraman i10 and Santro wise, there are a lot of compromises in safety, build quality isn't a given, and also Hyundai service costs are known to be a lot more than Maruti/Tata's range. Spares are costlier too right? Relatively atleast? |
For us, our car of choice has depended largely on the three cost factors (Purchase costs, Running costs and Service costs), fitment/build/ride quality and service support.
The purchase cost of Rs 4.5 lakh and the good FE we have got on the Grand i10 (avg 17.5 kmpl) have been to our expectations. We have not done the first service of our Grand i10 as yet, but going by the nominal service costs of our previous i10 (average was Rs 3,000-4,000), I have no doubt that our Grand i10 is not likely to be significantly higher.
I don't think the i10 has compromised on safety and build quility. In fact, we have always found a Hyundai hatch to have had better build quality than a comparable Maruti car in its price range.
Quote:
Originally Posted by jasjotbains One thing I would specify here is, with 5 i-10's in my family and neighbours, Hyundai petrol is one of the best engines out there. I have been driving an i10 sports for 6 years, and its annual service cost is equivalent to my Activa's annual service. Refinement wise, quality wise, reliability wise and customer support wise, its the best out there.
Oh, and I have constantly got 20+ kmpl (without AC - winters) on Chandigarh - Delhi highways while driving consistently at 100+ kmph as well as 17+ kmpl with AC and 175 profile tyres (stock were 155) on Salem - Coimbatore highway. Cannot say where the poor petrol efficiency comes from. |
Fully agree on the refinement, quality, reliability and customer support levels for our Grand i10. We too have loved the 1.2 petrol engine, first on our 2010 i10 and now in our Grand i10.
Quote:
Originally Posted by shrvenkataraman A friend of mine has an i20 and has gotten 9-12kmpl max in Chennai city traffic and 15-16kmpl max in highway driving. Petrol vehicle. Tiago on the other hand from most reviews i have read seem to improve efficiency towards the second service giving upwards of 14-15kmpl in city traffic and 22-23kmpl in highways (sedate driving) and 19-21Kmpl (normal driving with AC on and good speed). This is what I gathered reading so many ownership reviews here and on cardekho. |
There is a considerable difference between FE on the Grand i10 and the i20. The i20 is a heavier car and is bound to have a lower FE. You must compare the Tiago with the Grand i10.