Quote:
Originally Posted by roy_libran Wow! Finally someone who puts Innova at the place it truly deserves. I completely agree with this on all counts.
- Severe Bachache after long journeys and / or regular usage is severe.
- The car's rear end just sways left to right at speeds and does far from inspiring confidence
- For the price one has to pay for this car, I would say these two factors alone make it ultra low value for money |
I do quite a bit of highway driving (Hyd-Kolkata, Hyd-Mumbai, Hyd-Bangalore, Hyd-Kanyakaumari etc etc) and have used whatever cars I evaluated and purchased over time ...Fiat Uno, Santro, Baleno, Alto, Innova. I currently own a Baleno and an Innova.
I agree with the fact that Innova has a stiff suspension and will thud through potholes. The thigh support may be a bit lacking if you are a 6 footer but is good enuf for normal persons.
However, the same stiff suspension (with a bit..but just that bit of sideways travel in large potholes) provides superior body control that a Scorpio owner can only dream of - even with a slightly more peppier motor. My uncle has a Scorpio so I say it from driving experience.
About comfort-our non stop travel distances increased substantially after we bought the innova. We travelled 1100kms from Thekkady to Hyderabad (5 adults, 2 kids and 2 weeks worth of luggage w/o a roof carrier) recently and everyone, including my 60+ yr old parents were not miserable. The longest we used to do in the Baleno was 750 / 800 kms at a stretch. In fact my father has taken a liking to driving the car and given the fact that he used to drive a Santro and used to find the Baleno big - thats saying a lot about ease of driving
So, I would not call Innova an overrated car. If you have a family and need the space and comfort. No other people mover comes close. Period.
Try doing 6+ persons for a 1000 km drive in another people mover which has poorer body control (with a *magic carpet ride* that any softer suspension will give at a lower speed) and ask the occupants how they feel. Quote:
Originally Posted by raj_5004 even i am pleasantly surprised to see someone supporting innova's negatives!
i am myself an innova owner so i am not against toyota or anything. but fact is innova is one overrated car in india. the only good thing about an innova is interior space/quality & reliability.
but there are many other things at which the competition scores much better than the innova. fact is innova sells because its a toyota!
i have been bashed many times on this forum when i have complained that the innova's seats are not comfortable & that NVH & stability at high speeds is not good. |
To each his own-I cannot believe that the superlight steering and lax body control of Scorpio is confidence inspiring at triple digit speeds. Maybe its just the macho feeling that adds to the confidence. Just google and find a bit of data on slalom times as well and see what is easier to drive through turns. See one link below that I found - maybe has outdated data Indiacar.com - Mahindra Scorpio
I find Innova pretty stable with better stability than Scorpio at turns. Last year, while executing a stifff corner, a scorpio overturned and my friend in his Baleno barely escaped collateral damages - he was coming from the other side of the turn.
Last edited by Buffetfan : 16th April 2010 at 00:44.
|